Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Do Charter Schools Help or Hurt California Education?
NANCY WEBSITE HEADSHOT 1
By Nancy Price, Multimedia Journalist
Published 7 years ago on
October 4, 2018

Share

Charter supporters, citing the need to overhaul public education, want to change how schools are run. Opponents argue that charters steer revenues away from traditional neighborhood schools, cherry-pick the best and brightest and can avoid employment and governance rules that school districts must follow.
Charters, which the Legislature authorized in 1992, represent a small but growing fraction of the state’s public school system. They enrolled 628,849 students — more than 10 percent of the state’s total — in the 2017-18 school year, according to California Department of Education data.

“My position is this, I’m for any school that’s good for kids, period.” — Jim Yovino, Fresno County Superintendent of Schools
Overall in California, charter enrollments have climbed by 15.4 percent over the past four years even as overall enrollments dropped by 0.2 percent. The increase in charter enrollments in Fresno and Kings counties was close to the state average but climbed much faster in Madera County (34.5 percent) and Tulare County (26.7 percent).
In the Valley where both overall and charter enrollments continue to climb, charter enrollments ranged from 6.4 percent of total enrollments in Fresno County to 17.1 percent in Kings County.

Waiting Lists for Some Fresno County Charters

Fresno County’s percentage of charter school enrollees would be even higher if there were more options available, and consequently, there are wait lists, said Michelle Murphy, the California Charter Schools Association’s former regional director for advocacy in the Central Valley and Central Coast region.
“By and large, we are seeing that there’s a demand for charter schools, there is a demand for options,” Murphy said.
Students at charter schools tend to outperform their peers at traditional public schools, said Caity Heim, a spokeswoman for the California Charter Schools Association.
Using data compiled by the California Department of Education from the California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress, the association has found that 21 percent of Fresno County’s charter schools are in the top 10 percent of performance statewide, compared to only 8 percent of traditional public schools in Fresno County, Heim said.

Charters Do Well in Best School Rankings

Likewise, 18 percent of California’s charter schools are in the top 10 percent of performance statewide compared to 9 percent of the state’s traditional public schools, she said.
In U.S. News & World Reports’ annual ranking of public schools released in May, seven of the top 10 high schools in California were charters, including Fresno’s University High School, which ranked No. 5 in the state and No. 74 nationwide.

Charter schools are not a panacea, however. Students at for-profit charters tend to perform poorly, which is why both candidates for state Superintendent of Public Instruction, Marshall Tuck and Tony Thurmond, say they support outlawing them.
Two Valley charters — Morris E. Dailey Charter Elementary and Jefferson Charter Academy in Hanford — were among the 287 schools recognized by the 2018 California Distinguished Schools Program for having made exceptional gains in implementing academic content and performance standards adopted by the State Board of Education.
Charter schools are not a panacea, however. Students at for-profit charters tend to perform poorly, which is why both candidates for state Superintendent of Public Instruction, Marshall Tuck and Tony Thurmond, say they support outlawing them.
Recent studies and current data comparing charters to traditional schools with similar populations show that charters tend to provide greater benefit for students from low-income neighborhoods, but academic performance declines for more affluent students at charters.

The Kepler Neighborhood School Saga

There are exceptions. Kepler Neighborhood School in Fresno’s downtown, where more than half of students are classified as low-income, performed poorly in most categories on the fall 2017 state dashboard. The school scored in the lowest performance levels for Hispanic and low-income students. The Fresno Unified School District Board of Trustees, which oversaw the charter, voted this spring not to renew it, a decision backed by the California Charter Schools Association.
But Kepler got a reprieve when the Fresno County Board of Education opted to OK a three-year charter renewal. Jim Yovino, the Fresno County Superintendent of Schools, says there were several reasons why the county decided to give Kepler a stay of execution: The school’s management had changed, student performance was on the upswing, and the county could opt for a shorter reauthorization — an option that wasn’t available to Fresno Unified, which could vote only for a full five-year reauthorization or none at all.
The county superintendent’s office’s oversight of Kepler will include any needed assistance, as it would for any charter, he said.
Yovino doesn’t categorize himself as pro- or anti-charter: “My position is this, I’m for any school that’s good for kids, period.”

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

NY Times Bestselling Author Celebrating Book Release at Fresno Barnes & Noble

DON'T MISS

Dodgers Acquire Former All-Star Reliever Alexis Díaz in Trade With Cincinnati Reds

DON'T MISS

Christian McCaffrey Returns to 49ers Practice, Showing No Ill Effects From Injuries

DON'T MISS

Wall Street Falls as Trump Says China Violated Tariff Terms

DON'T MISS

US Consumer Spending Slows in April, Inflation Benign

DON'T MISS

US Supreme Court Lets Trump Revoke ‘Parole’ Status for Migrants

DON'T MISS

Tulare County Man Convicted of Child Molestation During Burglary Faces Life Without Parole

DON'T MISS

What Local Politicians, LGBT Community Say About Trans Track Star

DON'T MISS

Fresno Man Arrested After Stolen City Vehicle Pursuit, Fires in Madera County

DON'T MISS

Former MLB All-Star Breaks Ground on BMW/Porsche/Audi Dealership in Clovis

UP NEXT

Dodgers Acquire Former All-Star Reliever Alexis Díaz in Trade With Cincinnati Reds

UP NEXT

Christian McCaffrey Returns to 49ers Practice, Showing No Ill Effects From Injuries

UP NEXT

Wall Street Falls as Trump Says China Violated Tariff Terms

UP NEXT

US Consumer Spending Slows in April, Inflation Benign

UP NEXT

US Supreme Court Lets Trump Revoke ‘Parole’ Status for Migrants

UP NEXT

Tulare County Man Convicted of Child Molestation During Burglary Faces Life Without Parole

UP NEXT

What Local Politicians, LGBT Community Say About Trans Track Star

UP NEXT

Fresno Man Arrested After Stolen City Vehicle Pursuit, Fires in Madera County

UP NEXT

Former MLB All-Star Breaks Ground on BMW/Porsche/Audi Dealership in Clovis

UP NEXT

Fresno, Clovis to Open Cooling Centers as Temperatures Expected to Soar

Nancy Price,
Multimedia Journalist
Nancy Price is a multimedia journalist for GV Wire. A longtime reporter and editor who has worked for newspapers in California, Florida, Alaska, Illinois and Kansas, Nancy joined GV Wire in July 2019. She previously worked as an assistant metro editor for 13 years at The Fresno Bee. Nancy earned her bachelor's and master's degrees in journalism at Northwestern University's Medill School of Journalism. Her hobbies include singing with the Fresno Master Chorale and volunteering with Fresno Filmworks. You can reach Nancy at 559-492-4087 or Send an Email

Wall Street Falls as Trump Says China Violated Tariff Terms

41 minutes ago

US Consumer Spending Slows in April, Inflation Benign

47 minutes ago

US Supreme Court Lets Trump Revoke ‘Parole’ Status for Migrants

50 minutes ago

Tulare County Man Convicted of Child Molestation During Burglary Faces Life Without Parole

16 hours ago

What Local Politicians, LGBT Community Say About Trans Track Star

16 hours ago

Fresno Man Arrested After Stolen City Vehicle Pursuit, Fires in Madera County

17 hours ago

Former MLB All-Star Breaks Ground on BMW/Porsche/Audi Dealership in Clovis

17 hours ago

Fresno, Clovis to Open Cooling Centers as Temperatures Expected to Soar

18 hours ago

Costco Misses Quarterly Revenue Expectations Amid Reduced Consumer Spending

18 hours ago

Tulare County Authorities Respond to Double Shooting in Goshen

18 hours ago

NY Times Bestselling Author Celebrating Book Release at Fresno Barnes & Noble

New York Times bestselling author Monica Murphy is coming to the Barnes & Noble at Fashion Fair to sign her upcoming book. The Central V...

7 minutes ago

7 minutes ago

NY Times Bestselling Author Celebrating Book Release at Fresno Barnes & Noble

9 minutes ago

Dodgers Acquire Former All-Star Reliever Alexis Díaz in Trade With Cincinnati Reds

16 minutes ago

Christian McCaffrey Returns to 49ers Practice, Showing No Ill Effects From Injuries

A trader works on the floor at the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in New York City, U.S., May 19, 2025. REUTERSJeenah MoonFile Photo
41 minutes ago

Wall Street Falls as Trump Says China Violated Tariff Terms

People look for presents at the Macy’s flagship store during the holiday season in New York City, U.S., December 10, 2023. REUTERS/Eduardo Munoz/File Photo
47 minutes ago

US Consumer Spending Slows in April, Inflation Benign

President Donald Trump makes an announcement about a trade deal with the U.K., in the Oval Office at the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., May 8, 2025. REUTERS/Leah Millis
50 minutes ago

US Supreme Court Lets Trump Revoke ‘Parole’ Status for Migrants

Serafin Narcisco, 44, of Porterville, was convicted on Wednesday, May 28, 2025, of molesting a 4-year-old girl during a 2020 home burglary. (Tulare County SO)
16 hours ago

Tulare County Man Convicted of Child Molestation During Burglary Faces Life Without Parole

16 hours ago

What Local Politicians, LGBT Community Say About Trans Track Star

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend