Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
California Lawmakers Consider Proposal to Eliminate Bail
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 7 years ago on
August 17, 2018

Share

SACRAMENTO — California would be the first state to completely end bail for defendants awaiting trial under a proposal unveiled Thursday that would create a new system to instead jail people based on their risk level.

We have baked into our law a system that punishes people, that takes away their liberty, that treats them differently just because they have less money.”State Sen. Bob Hertzberg, Van Nuys Democrat who authored the bill
The plan calls for most suspects arrested for nonviolent misdemeanors to be released within 12 hours of being booked, while those facing serious, violent felonies would not be eligible for pretrial release.
Courts and the state’s Judicial Council would have wide latitude to determine whether to release other suspects before trial based on the likelihood they’ll return to court and the danger they pose.
To be released from jail before trial in the current system, many defendants must post bail or property that can be forfeited if they fail to appear in court.
California would be the first state to make such sweeping changes. New Jersey overhauled its pretrial release system in 2017 to dramatically reduce the use of cash bail, although it didn’t ban bail outright.
Assemblyman Rob Bonta, a Democrat from Alameda who co-authored the bill, said the changes would result in fewer people held in jail before trial.

The Bail Industry Argues

The bail industry has argued that eliminating cash bail would take away an essential tool in ensuring defendants show up in court.
The American Civil Liberties Union of California was previously a co-sponsor of the legislation, but took a neutral position because of amendments to the bill. It supports the idea of eliminating bail but wants the bill to include study of the changes to identify racial bias and include stronger protections to ensure due process, said Natasha Minsker, director of the ACLU’s California Center for Advocacy and Policy.
The amended bill passed out of an Assembly committee Thursday and now heads to the Assembly floor. It needs approval from both houses of the Legislature and a signature from the governor to become law. Assembly Speaker Anthony Rendon and Senate President Pro Tem Toni Atkins have both identified bail reform as a top priority.
The proposal will likely cost hundreds of millions of dollars each year to fund new jobs in the judiciary to conduct the risk assessment process, Hertzberg said. Lawmakers are slated to consider a $15 million appropriation this year to train people ahead of implementation.
Under SB10, suspects would be categorized as having high, medium or low risk of failing to appear in court, endangering public safety or committing a new crime. The determination would be based on the charges, criminal record, missed court appearances in the past three years, and other factors.

Asking Victims if a Suspect Should Be Detained

Additionally, prosecutors would be required to ask victims whether a suspect should be detained, which would also be considered.
Low risk people would generally be released before trial, although they may be subject to some nonmonetary conditions to ensure public safety and their return to court. The Judicial Council, a rulemaking organization run by the chief justice, will determine what options courts have when setting pretrial release conditions.
Local courts would have broad discretion over whether to release people deemed a medium risk.
Officials would need to decide whether someone deemed a low or medium risk should be released before trial within 24 hours after the person is booked with a potential 12-hour extension.
High risk suspects would not be eligible for pretrial release. Some drug and alcohol charges, restraining order violations, past violations of pretrial release conditions and other factors could also make someone ineligible for pretrial release.

DON'T MISS

SpaceX Delays Flight to Replace NASA’s Stuck Astronauts After Launch Pad Problem

DON'T MISS

49ers Cut 2 More Players, Increasing Dead Cap Charge to More Than $86 Million

DON'T MISS

Did Chavez Use Public Funds to Support Wife’s Campaign? Arambula Asks for Probe

DON'T MISS

Two Men Identified as Suspects in Fresno County 2016 Double Homicide

DON'T MISS

Fresno Candidate Brandon Vang and Wife May Lee Emotionally Respond to Attack Mailer

DON'T MISS

Chargers Sign Former Steelers Running Back Najee Harris and Cornerback Donte Jackson

DON'T MISS

After Fresno Unified Student Dies, District Punishes Whistleblower: Lawsuit

DON'T MISS

USDA Ends Program That Helped Schools Serve Food From Local Farmers

DON'T MISS

Military Leaders Warn of Risks to Armed Forces’ Readiness in Temporary Funding Bill

DON'T MISS

Education Dept. Layoffs Gut Its Civil Rights Office, Leaving Discrimination Cases in Limbo

UP NEXT

Trump’s EPA Plans to Close All Environmental Justice Offices

UP NEXT

How and When to Watch Thursday Night’s Blood Moon Total Eclipse

UP NEXT

Bipartisanship Is Rare in the California Legislature. Here Are the Bills Breaking the Divide.

UP NEXT

President Trump’s Many Golf Trips Are Costing Taxpayers Millions Per Outing

UP NEXT

Lake Superior Shipwreck From 1892 Finally Discovered

UP NEXT

California Almond Growers Grapple With Uncertainty as New Tariffs Could Hit Exports

UP NEXT

California Lawmakers Propose Fixes for ‘Insurance Industry in Shambles’

UP NEXT

FBI Joins Search for Missing US Student in Dominican Republic

UP NEXT

Former US Rep. Katie Porter Steps Into Crowded California Governor’s Race

UP NEXT

LA District Attorney Says He Won’t Support Resentencing the Menendez Brothers

Two Men Identified as Suspects in Fresno County 2016 Double Homicide

10 hours ago

Fresno Candidate Brandon Vang and Wife May Lee Emotionally Respond to Attack Mailer

11 hours ago

Chargers Sign Former Steelers Running Back Najee Harris and Cornerback Donte Jackson

11 hours ago

After Fresno Unified Student Dies, District Punishes Whistleblower: Lawsuit

11 hours ago

USDA Ends Program That Helped Schools Serve Food From Local Farmers

11 hours ago

Military Leaders Warn of Risks to Armed Forces’ Readiness in Temporary Funding Bill

11 hours ago

Education Dept. Layoffs Gut Its Civil Rights Office, Leaving Discrimination Cases in Limbo

11 hours ago

Trump to Name Michelle Bowman as Top Bank Regulator at Federal Reserve

11 hours ago

Kuwait Frees a Group of Jailed Americans, Including Contractors Held on Drug Charges

12 hours ago

Senate Democrats Balk at Funding Extension, Raising the Risk of a Shutdown

12 hours ago

SpaceX Delays Flight to Replace NASA’s Stuck Astronauts After Launch Pad Problem

CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. — A launch pad problem prompted SpaceX to delay a flight to the International Space Station on Wednesday to replace NAS...

8 hours ago

8 hours ago

SpaceX Delays Flight to Replace NASA’s Stuck Astronauts After Launch Pad Problem

9 hours ago

49ers Cut 2 More Players, Increasing Dead Cap Charge to More Than $86 Million

10 hours ago

Did Chavez Use Public Funds to Support Wife’s Campaign? Arambula Asks for Probe

Jonathan Morales Ramos (left), 27, of Soledad, and Erik Madrigal Garcia, 26, of Orosi, have been arrested in connection with a 2016 gang-related double homicide near Reedley, the Fresno County Sheriff’s Office said. (Fresno County SO)
10 hours ago

Two Men Identified as Suspects in Fresno County 2016 Double Homicide

11 hours ago

Fresno Candidate Brandon Vang and Wife May Lee Emotionally Respond to Attack Mailer

11 hours ago

Chargers Sign Former Steelers Running Back Najee Harris and Cornerback Donte Jackson

11 hours ago

After Fresno Unified Student Dies, District Punishes Whistleblower: Lawsuit

11 hours ago

USDA Ends Program That Helped Schools Serve Food From Local Farmers

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend