Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
California High Court Sides With Police in Case Over Chases
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 7 years ago on
August 14, 2018

Share

SAN FRANCISCO — The California Supreme Court on Monday unanimously rejected a lawsuit that sought to make it easier to hold police liable for crashes that occur during pursuits.
A state law says police agencies are immune from liability if they have a written pursuit policy, provide annual training about chases, and require that all officers certify in writing that they have read and understood the policy.

“The standard is now so low that any department will be immune. All they have to say is, ‘We have a requirement,’ and that’s good enough.” — Abdalla Innabi, attorney 
However, the state Supreme Court said it would be almost impossible for large agencies with thousands of officers to show that every officer has met the certification provision.
“A requirement may exist even if not every peace officer complies with it,” Associate Justice Ming Chin wrote for the court.
The decision came in a lawsuit filed against the Southern California city of Gardena by Irma Ramirez, whose son was killed in 2015 after an officer bumped the pickup truck he was in during a chase and sent it crashing into a light pole. He was a suspect in an armed robbery.
Ramirez’s attorney, Abdalla Innabi, said the decision makes people less safe by protecting departments no matter “how negligent, how egregious, how reckless” the pursuit.
Chin said opening up agencies to liability for a single officer’s failure to complete the written certification would reduce the incentive for agencies to craft a pursuit policy and provide training.

DON'T MISS

Trump, Newsom Play High-Stakes Game Over Billions in Wildfire Aid

DON'T MISS

House Republicans Pass Budget Plan With Trillions in Tax Cuts, Deep Spending Cuts

DON'T MISS

San Francisco 49ers Announce Major Coaching Changes for 2024 Season

DON'T MISS

Trump Orders Security Clearance Suspension for Law Firm Aiding Jack Smith

DON'T MISS

Snell Happy With Velocity After Tossing Scoreless Inning in His Dodgers Spring Debut

DON'T MISS

Trump Wants to Sell ‘Gold Cards’ to Wealthy Immigrants for $5M

DON'T MISS

Madera County Honors K-9 Obie’s Heroism With a Purple Heart

DON'T MISS

Would a Fresno Smoke Shop Ordinance Cost Taxpayers Tens of Millions?

DON'T MISS

Ukraine and US Have Agreed on Framework Economic Deal, Ukrainian Officials Say

DON'T MISS

Trump’s Deportation Rates Lower Than Biden’s, but Expected to Rise

UP NEXT

Trump’s Deportation Rates Lower Than Biden’s, but Expected to Rise

UP NEXT

White House Says It ‘Will Decide’ Which News Outlets Cover Trump, Rotating Some Traditional Ones

UP NEXT

California Judge Testifies That He Accidentally Shot and Killed His Wife

UP NEXT

CA Senator Wants to Expand School Summer Meal Programs to Families

UP NEXT

Conservative Pundit, ex-Secret Service Agent Dan Bongino Picked as FBI Deputy Director

UP NEXT

Stock Market Today: Wall Street Drifts After Last Week’s Tumble

UP NEXT

Starbucks Lays Off 1,100 Corporate Employees as Chain Streamlines

UP NEXT

Newsom Seeks $40 Billion From Congress for LA Wildfire Relief

UP NEXT

Hunter Schafer Speaks Out About Being Issued a Male Passport

UP NEXT

LA Mayor Bass Removes Fire Chief Kristin Crowley After Wildfire Response Criticism

Trump Orders Security Clearance Suspension for Law Firm Aiding Jack Smith

13 hours ago

Snell Happy With Velocity After Tossing Scoreless Inning in His Dodgers Spring Debut

13 hours ago

Trump Wants to Sell ‘Gold Cards’ to Wealthy Immigrants for $5M

14 hours ago

Madera County Honors K-9 Obie’s Heroism With a Purple Heart

14 hours ago

Would a Fresno Smoke Shop Ordinance Cost Taxpayers Tens of Millions?

14 hours ago

Ukraine and US Have Agreed on Framework Economic Deal, Ukrainian Officials Say

15 hours ago

Trump’s Deportation Rates Lower Than Biden’s, but Expected to Rise

15 hours ago

Apple Shareholders Reject Proposal to Scrap Company’s Diversity Programs

16 hours ago

District 5 Forum: Candidates Discuss How They Would Handle the $20 Million Budget Deficit

16 hours ago

Future ‘Longhorns’ Tour Construction Site of Next Clovis Unified High School

16 hours ago

Trump, Newsom Play High-Stakes Game Over Billions in Wildfire Aid

After voters shunned Kamala Harris and sent Donald Trump back to the White House, California Gov. Gavin Newsom immediately positioned himsel...

15 minutes ago

Newsom and Trump Meet in LA After Wildfires
15 minutes ago

Trump, Newsom Play High-Stakes Game Over Billions in Wildfire Aid

Speaker of the House Mike Johnson, of La., with House Republican Conference Chairwoman Lisa McClain, from left, Rep. Tim Moore, R-N.C. and House Majority Leader Steve Scalise, of La., speaks during a news conference at the Capitol, Tuesday, Feb. 25, 2025, in Washington. (AP/Manuel Balce Ceneta)
13 hours ago

House Republicans Pass Budget Plan With Trillions in Tax Cuts, Deep Spending Cuts

13 hours ago

San Francisco 49ers Announce Major Coaching Changes for 2024 Season

13 hours ago

Trump Orders Security Clearance Suspension for Law Firm Aiding Jack Smith

13 hours ago

Snell Happy With Velocity After Tossing Scoreless Inning in His Dodgers Spring Debut

14 hours ago

Trump Wants to Sell ‘Gold Cards’ to Wealthy Immigrants for $5M

The Madera County Board of Supervisors honored K-9 Obie with a historic proclamation and Purple Heart for his heroic actions in a November 2024 pursuit, where he was injured while protecting deputies. (Madera County)
14 hours ago

Madera County Honors K-9 Obie’s Heroism With a Purple Heart

14 hours ago

Would a Fresno Smoke Shop Ordinance Cost Taxpayers Tens of Millions?

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend