Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Should Vaccines Be Required To Receive Welfare?
David Website Replacement
By David Taub, Senior Reporter
Published 7 years ago on
June 25, 2018

Share

Assemblyman Kansen Chu (D-San Jose) says he doesn’t want to penalize welfare recipients whose children’s immunizations aren’t up to date.


Assemblyman Kansen Chu (D-San Jose)
But his proposed AB 1992 may just do just that, according to a parents’ rights group.
State law requires CalWORKs recipients to be current on their immunizations or face a reduction of benefits.
“Instead of penalizing families, AB 1992 would help provide resources including transportation for those families to obtain the necessary vaccinations for their children,” Chu told his colleagues during a May 30 vote on the Assembly floor.
The bill would also give more time for families to prove or receive immunizations in hardship circumstances (lack of access to shots, victims of domestic violence, and homelessness, for example) without risk of penalty. The penalties, under Chu’s plan, also would be slashed from $130 to $50 as well.
Additionally, the legislation would allow county welfare workers to utilize medical databases to determine if an applicant’s child received vaccinations.
However, an advocate with the Parents United 4 Kids noticed that the bill doesn’t include religious and medical exemptions.
“This bill is coercive and is holding hostage cash incentives in exchange for vaccination,” writes Stefanie Fetzer on her group’s Facebook page.
Fetzer has a winning track record: Her advocacy helped spike two bills that she said would negatively impact homeschooling earlier this year.

Personal Belief Exemption

The current welfare law allows parents to opt out of the vaccination requirement if they file an affidavit stating that “immunizations are contrary to the applicant’s or recipient’s beliefs.”
Chu’s first version of the bill retained that language.
But, according to the state’s legislative tracking website, an amendment came May 25, the same day that the Assembly Appropriations Committee heard the bill. However, the staff report made no reference to the change. The committee passed the bill 15-0 with no debate, other than a comment to approve “as amended.”
Fetzer said that she was told by Chu’s chief of staff, Annie Pham, the bill would not get out of the appropriations committee unless the exemption language changed.
Assemblywoman Lorena Gonzalez-Fletcher (D-San Diego) chairs the committee.

Chu Confirms Dropping the Exemption

A May 30 floor debate in the Assembly centered on the personal belief exemption.
Assemblyman Tom Lackey (R-Palmdale) asked Chu point blank if the religious exemption remained in the bill.
“This bill will comply with current law. There will be no personal belief exemption,” Chu answered.
Gonzalez-Fletcher defended Chu on the floor as well, saying prior legislation removed such exemptions.
Although she did not call it by name, she referred to SB 277.  That law removed personal belief exemptions from vaccinations requirements for attending public or private schools.
The text of that bill specifically dealt with public schools, and did not reference welfare requirements.

A Matter of Rights

Fetzer says this is an issue of liberty.
“This is NOT a public health issue. Vaccination rates are high. There is no crisis mitigating such a heavy handed, totalitarian piece of legislation. Our legislators are testing the water. How far can they go? Can they withhold a parents’ ability to feed their children if the parents are unwilling to ignore their religious or personal convictions?” she said on Facebook. “Why are our legislators targeting this poor, minority community?”


“It is cruel to withhold welfare benefits from families in need.”Barbara Loe Fisher, NVIC
Barbara Loe Fisher serves as president of the National Vaccine Information Center. Fisher says her group “advocates for the inclusion of informed consent protections in vaccine policies and state laws, including flexible medical, religious and conscientious belief vaccine exemptions.”
She also opposes the removal of the personal belief exemption.
“It is cruel to withhold welfare benefits from families in need.  NVIC opposes AB 1992 and any legislation that threatens Americans with punishment for making voluntary vaccine decisions for themselves or their children,” Fisher wrote in a statement.
Fetzer said that members of Parents United 4 Kids and NVIC plan to attend a Senate Committee on Human Services hearing on AB 1992 Tuesday (June 26).

Supporters Concerned About Access


“Rather than giving people an economic sanction, we would prefer that if the department would like children to be vaccinated, they would simply help them become vaccinated.” Jessica Bartholow, Western Center on Law & Poverty
The Western Center on Law & Poverty co-sponsored the bill in an effort to increase welfare benefits to recipients. Jessica Bartholow, the group’s policy advocate testified at the Assembly Human Services committee.
Bartholow said the focus of her group wasn’t on exemptions, but rather increasing access for welfare recipients.
“What parents need to be in order to be successful and to exit poverty isn’t a slap on the hand,” Bartholow told GV Wire. “There are a hundred reasons why that might be a case (why a child isn’t vaccinated). Rather than giving people an economic sanction, we would prefer that if the department would like children to be vaccinated, they would simply help them become vaccinated.”
“We do believe that the policy moving forward will help more families than it will harm based on estimates of families that do have personal belief exemptions using data from other states, since we don’t have that data from our state.”
[Note: this story updated the fact that SB 277 removed the personal belief exemption to attend both public and private schools.]
 

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Canseco, Cheechoo to Sign Autographs When Chukchansi Cuts Ribbon on Top Golf

DON'T MISS

California Man Accused of Planting Cameras in Children’s Dance Studio Bathroom

DON'T MISS

Whatever Happened to the New Northwest Fresno Costco?

DON'T MISS

Iran Held Direct Talks With US Amid Intensifying Conflict With Israel, Diplomats Say

DON'T MISS

Oil Prices Jump as Israel-Iran Conflict Enters Seventh Day

DON'T MISS

Three New Judges Appointed in the Valley. Who Are They?

DON'T MISS

As Death Toll Rises, Gazans Make Life-Risking Journeys to Seek Food

DON'T MISS

EU Increasingly Resigned to 10% Baseline Tariff in US Trade Talks, European Sources Say

DON'T MISS

Hurricane Erick Strengthens to Category 3 off Mexico’s Pacific Coast

DON'T MISS

Democrats Want New Leaders, Focus on Pocketbook Issues, Reuters/Ipsos Poll Finds

UP NEXT

California Man Accused of Planting Cameras in Children’s Dance Studio Bathroom

UP NEXT

Whatever Happened to the New Northwest Fresno Costco?

UP NEXT

Three New Judges Appointed in the Valley. Who Are They?

UP NEXT

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Dillon Christopher Wade

UP NEXT

A Little Coffee With Your Whiskey? Downtown Fresno Gets New Craft Cocktail Lounge

UP NEXT

Teen Girl Accused as Getaway Driver in Caleb Quick Murder Appears in Court

UP NEXT

Tiogaland Brings Disney Food to Fresno on Friday Evening

UP NEXT

Proposed Law Would Allow Big Raises for School Board Members

UP NEXT

Mass Deportations Could Cost California Over $275 Billion, UC Merced Report Warns

UP NEXT

Truck Stuck on Tracks Hit by Train in Tulare County

David Taub,
Senior Reporter
Curiosity drives David Taub. The award-winning journalist might be shy, but feels mighty with a recorder in his hand. He doesn't see it his job to "hold public officials accountable," but does see it to provide readers (and voters) the information needed to make intelligent choices. Taub has been honored with several writing awards from the California News Publishers Association. He's just happy to have his stories read. Joining GV Wire in 2016, Taub covers politics, government and elections, mainly in the Fresno/Clovis area. He also writes columns about local eateries (Appetite for Fresno), pro wrestling (Off the Bottom Rope), and media (Media Man). Prior to joining the online news source, Taub worked as a radio producer for KMJ and PowerTalk 96.7 in Fresno. He also worked as an assignment editor for KCOY-TV in Santa Maria, California, and KSEE-TV in Fresno. He has also worked behind the scenes for several sports broadcasts, including the NCAA basketball tournament, and the Super Bowl. When not spending time with his family, Taub loves to officially score Fresno Grizzlies games. Growing up in the San Francisco Bay Area, Taub is a die-hard Giants and 49ers fan. He graduated from the University of Michigan with dual degrees in communications and political science. Go Blue! You can contact David at 559-492-4037 or at Send an Email

Fresno Police Seek Help Identifying 7-Eleven Robbery Suspects

16 hours ago

Fresno Council Scraps Cannabis Advisory Group, Extends Advance Peace Funding

16 hours ago

Buss Family to Sell Lakers at $10 Billion Valuation, ESPN Says

16 hours ago

Massive Security Breach: 16 Billion Passwords Leaked From Apple, Google, Facebook Accounts

16 hours ago

‘I’m an American, Bro!’: Latinos Report Raids in Which US Citizenship Is Questioned

17 hours ago

Florida Congresswoman to Revive Bipartisan Immigration Bill. Valley Leaders Join the Push

17 hours ago

LA Dodgers Say They Denied ICE Agents Access to Stadium Parking Lot

18 hours ago

Netanyahu Says Fall of Iran’s Leadership Not a Goal but Could Be a Result

18 hours ago

Hunger Strike Begins as California Prisons Hand Down Biggest Restrictions Since COVID

18 hours ago

Sen. Alex Padilla: This Is How an Administration Acts When It’s Afraid

19 hours ago

Muslim NY Mayoral Candidate Reports Threats, Jewish Ohio Lawmaker Threatened Separately

WASHINGTON – The New York City Police Department said on Thursday its hate crime unit was probing anti-Muslim threats against mayoral ...

14 hours ago

Assemblyman Zohran Mamdani talks to people after the New York City Democratic Mayoral Primary Debate at the John Jay College of Criminal Justice in the Gerald W. Lynch Theater in New York City., U.S., June 12, 2025. (Reuters File)
14 hours ago

Muslim NY Mayoral Candidate Reports Threats, Jewish Ohio Lawmaker Threatened Separately

15 hours ago

It’s Final. No Live Horse Racing at Big Fresno Fair in 2025

15 hours ago

Clover Is Eager to Bring You Good Luck and Great Joy

Fresno police are seeking the public’s help to identify two suspects involved in a May 31, 2025, robbery at a 7-Eleven on East McKinley Avenue. (Fresno PD)
16 hours ago

Fresno Police Seek Help Identifying 7-Eleven Robbery Suspects

16 hours ago

Fresno Council Scraps Cannabis Advisory Group, Extends Advance Peace Funding

16 hours ago

Buss Family to Sell Lakers at $10 Billion Valuation, ESPN Says

16 hours ago

Massive Security Breach: 16 Billion Passwords Leaked From Apple, Google, Facebook Accounts

17 hours ago

‘I’m an American, Bro!’: Latinos Report Raids in Which US Citizenship Is Questioned

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend