Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Collusion? Bias? State Responds After Temperance Flat Vote.
David Website Replacement
By David Taub, Senior Reporter
Published 6 years ago on
May 10, 2018

Share

Although never mentioned by name, Kristal Davis Fadtke became the villain in the eyes of a roomful of ticked-off politicians.
 


Kristal Davis Fadtke
Last Friday (May 4), a bipartisan group of Central Valley politicians lined up at the podium to let the world know how angry they were about the paltry funding awarded for their project.
The California Water Commission went with staff’s recommendation to grant the Temperance Flat Reservoir $171 million dollars. That’s only 16% of the more than $1 billion they sought from Proposition 1 dollars.
The speakers put much of the blame on the staffer who scored the project low on a key benefit that determined the overall award.
That staffer is Davis Fadtke, supervisor of the Water Storage Investment Program with the state Department of Fish and Wildlife.
Davis Fadtke presented the findings to the commission at its May 1-3 meeting in Sacramento. She was one of 14 reviewers on the project.
Her department said that their funding recommendation met the letter of the law.

Temperance Supporters Unleash Wrath

A day after the May 3 vote, where the commission accepted the staff’s findings, a group of Temperance Flat supporters talked to the media at Fresno City Hall.
The group included Republicans and Democrats from the local, state and federal levels.
“The process that was used by the staff, in terms of the scoring and rating, I believe was flawed,” Congressman Jim Costa (D-Fresno) said. He felt the project didn’t get enough credit for environmental protection.
Assemblyman Jim Patterson (R-Fresno) accused Davis Fadtke of collusion with environmental groups.

“I personally witnessed a mugging by the commission.”Fresno County Supervisor Buddy Mendes
“We got denied over blind bias. I think the staff report of this particular individual was written or at least included all kinds of input from NRDC (Natural Resources Defense Council) and from Sierra Club. We were not asked significantly to come to the table with an alternative approach to this. Because every time we ask, there isn’t one to satisfy what we want,” Patterson said.
Fresno County Supervisor Buddy Mendes put it bluntly: “I personally witnessed a mugging by the commission. … They gave their responsibility away to the Fish and Wildlife service who had a license to steal.”

Fish and Wildlife Responds

Fish and Wildlife responded to GV Wire on behalf of Davis Fadtke. It said that the law was strictly followed in formulating the recommended funding awards.
“We understand the concern and passion voiced by supporters of Temperance Flat and other proposed water storage projects. We share the desire to see as many storage projects as possible receive Proposition 1 funding,” spokesperson Jordan Traverso emailed to GV Wire.
“Department staff followed the regulations and statutory direction of Proposition 1 in its review of Temperance Flat and all other projects. Staff reviewers have been transparent in how they arrived at their recommendations. There is no basis for suggesting otherwise.”

Devil is in the Details

Voters approved Prop. 1, the Water Quality, Supply, and Infrastructure Improvement Act of 2014, with 67% of the vote. Many supporters touted money for water storage projects, especially in the Valley.
However, Prop. 1 changed the Water Code. Specifically, Chapter 8, Section 79756 (b) which reads:
“No project may be funded unless it provides ecosystem improvements as described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 79753 that are at least 50 percent of total public benefits of the project funded under this chapter.”

Temperance Flat Scoring

The staff report broke down the public benefits (Appeal Response, see page 7) into five different categories, attaching a monetary recommendation with it. The breakdown:

Public Benefit Recommendation (in millions) CWC Vote
Ecosystem— Fishery Improvement for Spring-run Chinook Salmon $0 4-3 in favor
Ecosystem— Refuge Water Supply $85.7 7-0 in favor
Flood Control $104.3
Emergency Response $210.7
Recreation $100 5-1 in favor (one abstention)
Total $500.7

Initially, the staff recommended $0 for the recreation component; the commission added $100 million by a 5-1 vote.
Despite the $500.7 million recommended, only $171 million (double the ecosystem funding of $85 million) applied toward Temperance Flat’s funding.
The area that held back Temperance Flat was the $0 for the salmon, a view many supporters vigorously disagreed with.
“Temperance Flat applicants were not able to demonstrate a net ecosystem benefit that could be substantiated by staff as required by Prop. 1,” DFW’s Traverso said. “While not as much as the applicants were seeking, it still shows the state is willing to be an investment partner.”
Mario Santoyo, executive director of the San Joaquin Water Infrastructure Authority (which oversees the Temperance Flat effort), said that if the bond had passed when initially proposed in 2009, the project wouldn’t have funding problems. In the interim, a Democrat (Jerry Brown) replaced a Republican (Arnold Schwarzenegger) as governor.
Santoyo said lawmakers added the section that Davis Fadtke and her staff used to score the salmon public benefit in 2014. That compromise legislative language was necessary to get the proposition on the ballot.
It also led to the low ecology score.
[Update, 5/11/18: Doug Obegi, attorney with NRDC, said the 2009 version of the bond language did not change. “Proposition 1 included identical language to the 2009 proposed water bond regarding ecosystem benefits of water storage projects.” Obegi, as well as Santoyo, testified at the California Water Commission.]

DON'T MISS

5 Reasons Early Voting Is Overwhelmed With Falsehoods

DON'T MISS

Christian McCaffrey Returns to Practice for the 49ers From Achilles Tendon Injury

DON'T MISS

California Sues LA Suburb for Temporary Ban of Homeless Shelters

DON'T MISS

You May Have Blocked Someone on X but Now They Can See Your Public Posts Anyway

DON'T MISS

Some Republican-Led States Refuse to Let Justice Department Monitors Into Polling Places

DON'T MISS

Fresno Police Arrest Suspect in Fatal NW Apartment Shooting

DON'T MISS

Fresno Murder Suspect Stopped in Las Vegas, Others Wanted

DON'T MISS

Trump’s Crowds Are Dwindling as His Campaign Winds Down

DON'T MISS

Trump Threatens 25% Tariff on Mexico to Curb Immigration

DON'T MISS

Music Legend Quincy Jones, Architect of Pop’s Greatest Hits, Dies at 91

UP NEXT

Trump Threatens 25% Tariff on Mexico to Curb Immigration

UP NEXT

Sanger Men Arrested in Connection with Slingshot Vandalism Spree at Businesses

UP NEXT

What Is Sierra Unified’s Plan to Boost Lagging Student Achievement?

UP NEXT

Big Spenders: These Companies Are Giving the Most to California Legislative Candidates

UP NEXT

Fresno State Bulldogs Stumble in Fourth Quarter, Suffer Narrow Loss to Hawai’i

UP NEXT

Challengers Seek Seats on Tulare County Irrigation District Boards

UP NEXT

Shy Pup Finds Hope with Foster Family, Evasion from Euthanasia

UP NEXT

Immediate Threat: Mussel Invades California’s Delta, First Time in North America

UP NEXT

AMOR Wellness Trunk-or-Treat Brings 700 Mendota Residents Together for Halloween Fun

UP NEXT

What Kind of Trouble Is Miguel Arias Trying to Stir Up This Time?

David Taub,
Senior Reporter
Curiosity drives David Taub. The award-winning journalist might be shy, but feels mighty with a recorder in his hand. He doesn't see it his job to "hold public officials accountable," but does see it to provide readers (and voters) the information needed to make intelligent choices. Taub has been honored with several writing awards from the California News Publishers Association. He's just happy to have his stories read. Joining GV Wire in 2016, Taub covers politics, government and elections, mainly in the Fresno/Clovis area. He also writes columns about local eateries (Appetite for Fresno), pro wrestling (Off the Bottom Rope), and media (Media Man). Prior to joining the online news source, Taub worked as a radio producer for KMJ and PowerTalk 96.7 in Fresno. He also worked as an assignment editor for KCOY-TV in Santa Maria, California, and KSEE-TV in Fresno. He has also worked behind the scenes for several sports broadcasts, including the NCAA basketball tournament, and the Super Bowl. When not spending time with his family, Taub loves to officially score Fresno Grizzlies games. Growing up in the San Francisco Bay Area, Taub is a die-hard Giants and 49ers fan. He graduated from the University of Michigan with dual degrees in communications and political science. Go Blue! You can contact David at 559-492-4037 or at Send an Email

You May Have Blocked Someone on X but Now They Can See Your Public Posts Anyway

44 mins ago

Some Republican-Led States Refuse to Let Justice Department Monitors Into Polling Places

50 mins ago

Fresno Police Arrest Suspect in Fatal NW Apartment Shooting

1 hour ago

Fresno Murder Suspect Stopped in Las Vegas, Others Wanted

2 hours ago

Trump’s Crowds Are Dwindling as His Campaign Winds Down

2 hours ago

Trump Threatens 25% Tariff on Mexico to Curb Immigration

2 hours ago

Music Legend Quincy Jones, Architect of Pop’s Greatest Hits, Dies at 91

3 hours ago

Big Pharma Backs Harris 6-to-1 Over Trump in Presidential Campaign Contributions

3 hours ago

Sanger Men Arrested in Connection with Slingshot Vandalism Spree at Businesses

3 hours ago

What Is Sierra Unified’s Plan to Boost Lagging Student Achievement?

3 hours ago

5 Reasons Early Voting Is Overwhelmed With Falsehoods

This year’s early voting period appears to be far more polluted with election misinformation than those in previous presidential races, acco...

18 mins ago

Voters cast their ballots at Desert Breeze Community Center in Las Vegas during the last day of in-person early voting in Nevada on Friday, Nov. 1, 2024. Nearly 75 million people have cast early ballots, making their voices heard amid worry about the process, the outcome and democracy itself. (Bridget Bennett/The New York Times)
18 mins ago

5 Reasons Early Voting Is Overwhelmed With Falsehoods

26 mins ago

Christian McCaffrey Returns to Practice for the 49ers From Achilles Tendon Injury

30 mins ago

California Sues LA Suburb for Temporary Ban of Homeless Shelters

44 mins ago

You May Have Blocked Someone on X but Now They Can See Your Public Posts Anyway

50 mins ago

Some Republican-Led States Refuse to Let Justice Department Monitors Into Polling Places

Gerrick Franklin (pictured), 34, was taken into custody Sunday in Madera County on suspicion of killing Tyler Hamon, 33. (Fresno PD)
1 hour ago

Fresno Police Arrest Suspect in Fatal NW Apartment Shooting

2 hours ago

Fresno Murder Suspect Stopped in Las Vegas, Others Wanted

Former President Donald Trump, the Republican presidential nominee, on stage during a campaign rally in Lititz, Pa., on Sunday, Nov. 3, 2024. Trump told supporters on Sunday that he “shouldn’t have left” the White House at the end of his term during an end-of-campaign rally where he vented angrily about a spate of new public polls showing him losing ground to Vice President Kamala Harris and joked about reporters being shot at. (Doug Mills/The New York Times)
2 hours ago

Trump’s Crowds Are Dwindling as His Campaign Winds Down

Search

Send this to a friend