Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Failed Immigration Policies Put Farmers at Severe Risk
GV-Wire-1
By gvwire
Published 7 years ago on
January 18, 2018

Share

Opinion
by George Radanovich

In the United States, as in many prosperous nations, foreign workers play a critical role in the production of our nation’s food supply. As Congress struggles with the contentious issue of illegal immigration, it is important that legislators consider the disastrous consequence if no workers show up to grow, harvest and ship our nation’s fruits and vegetables, even if only for one season.
If our president, senators and congressmen are willing to consider the needs of American farmers — and the importance of sustaining a domestic food supply — in their deliberations over immigration policy, the strategy they develop quite possibly could end illegal immigration altogether.

The challenge remains the same for American agriculture: bring an end to illegal immigration and do no harm to our domestic food supply.

During my 16-year term as a congressman representing California’s agriculturally diverse San Joaquin Valley, I sought to address the labor needs of America’s specialty crop farmers. I co-authored H.R. 3142 (2003), H.R. 884 (2005), H.R. 371 (2007), and H.R. 2414(2009), and championed initiatives that would end illegal immigration while protecting farmers. This can happen only by strengthening border security, implementing E-verify (an electronic employment verification system), allowing foreign workers to come and go with the season, and permitting those who are otherwise law-abiding to continue their contribution in food production.

Failed Immigration Policies

Today, as an executive for a California-based agricultural trade association (our growers, packers and shippers help produce most of our nation’s domestically grown fruits) I am again confronted with the ongoing difficulties of ensuring a stable, legal workforce in the face of our government’s failed immigration policies. The challenge remains the same for American agriculture: bring an end to illegal immigration and do no harm to our domestic food supply.

Most agricultural labor in the western United States is unauthorized residents — estimated at 400,000 in California and 800,000 nationally.

In the past, most foreign worker programs originated from the executive branch of government as treaties. Some of those treaties became legislated programs, such as H2A. In the West, the Bracero program was negotiated with Mexico to address agricultural labor needs, until its termination in the 1960s.
The border was open for migrant workers to cross to harvest crops as they ripened; generally, workers returned to Mexico when the growing season ended. However, as border enforcement increased over the years, so did the dangers and expense of crossing the border. As a result, many workers remain in the United States. Now, most agricultural labor in the western United States is unauthorized residents — estimated at 400,000 in California and 800,000 nationally.
So, while every American should support the immediate removal of dangerous and violent criminals, a majority of these immigrants crossed the border as poor and downtrodden souls.  The idea of immigrating by the letter of the law under desperate circumstances seems like ivory-tower semantics, especially in the absence of robust border security and a legitimate foreign worker agreement.

Specialty Crop Agriculture at Risk

In this, the United States shares the blame of enabling illegal immigration along with those who crossed illegally. It is those immigrants that specialty crop agriculture cannot survive without, even for one year, while waiting for a new guest worker program and tighter border security.

“Is immigration a domestic policy or a foreign policy? A purely legislative, domestic approach has simply not worked.”

Since the annulment of the Bracero program, the agricultural workforce issue has not been adequately addressed. Sound immigration policy is mired down in the Beltway swamp of politics. In our partisan Congress, anything but border control and mass deportation is amnesty to some, while open borders and a pathway to citizenship seem perfectly acceptable to others. Fifty years of congressional debate has produced nothing.
Timothy J. Kane, JP Conte Fellow in Immigration Studies at the Hoover Institution at Stanford University, has it right when he says, “The immigration quagmire in Congress may be a consequence of misplaced authority. Is immigration a domestic policy or a foreign policy? A purely legislative, domestic approach has simply not worked.” Indeed, the legislative branch will need help from the president, who could negotiate with foreign partners while working with Congress to end illegal immigration.

Breaking the Immigration Impasse

Through a diplomatic agreement such as a treaty, trade or executive agreement, President Trump could break the immigration impasse and provide the farm sector the assurance of an uninterrupted supply of labor while effective border control is put in place. On a parallel track, while Congress considers strengthening border security, the president could negotiate an agreement with foreign countries, resulting in conditional legal status for qualifying farm workers residing in the United States.
There are benefits to this strategy. It could:
·         Eliminate incentive for hiring undocumented individuals by requiring use of a federal employment verification system (E-Verify);
·         Serve as a blueprint for other industries that, to a lesser degree, depend upon a foreign labor supply;
·         Secure cooperation with Mexico and/or other nations to make sure workers fulfill their obligations;
·         Include a fee to address program administration and border security priorities;
·         Specify immigration enforcement action, including deportation, against foreign nationals failing to qualify or refusing to participate.
We must use a scalpel, not a hatchet, to end illegal immigration and protect the U.S. food supply. The combination of an agreement from the executive branch, E-Verify, and strong border enforcement from Congress could do just that. Now is the time to take a fresh approach to immigration reform, starting with agricultural labor.
George Radanovich is a former Republican U.S. representative for California’s 19th District, serving from 1995 to 2011. He is president of the California Fresh Fruit Association, a voluntary, nonprofit agricultural trade association. Reach him at gradanovich@cafreshfruit.com.

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Ben & Jerry’s Founder Arrested at Senate Hearing After Protesting War in Gaza

DON'T MISS

Trump Navigates Iran Nuclear Talks. Should US Insist on Zero Enrichment?

DON'T MISS

WNBA Set To Tipoff Season With Teams Looking To Challenge For Title

DON'T MISS

CA Gov. Gavin Newsom Tries To Rebrand Himself Ahead Of A Potential Presidential Run

DON'T MISS

Who Is Theo Von? The ‘Manosphere’ Podcaster With Trump In Qatar

DON'T MISS

Texas Lawmaker Behind Abortion Ban Now Seeks to Clarify Life-Saving Exceptions

DON'T MISS

Fresno, Wake Up. We’re Numb to Our DUI Problem

DON'T MISS

Is the Secret to CA Housing Affordability Buried in the Building Code?

DON'T MISS

Students Are Short-Circuiting Chromebooks for a Social Media Challenge

DON'T MISS

Trump says US and Iran ‘Sort of’ Agree on Terms for a Nuclear Deal

UP NEXT

Trump Navigates Iran Nuclear Talks. Should US Insist on Zero Enrichment?

UP NEXT

WNBA Set To Tipoff Season With Teams Looking To Challenge For Title

UP NEXT

CA Gov. Gavin Newsom Tries To Rebrand Himself Ahead Of A Potential Presidential Run

UP NEXT

Who Is Theo Von? The ‘Manosphere’ Podcaster With Trump In Qatar

UP NEXT

Texas Lawmaker Behind Abortion Ban Now Seeks to Clarify Life-Saving Exceptions

UP NEXT

Fresno, Wake Up. We’re Numb to Our DUI Problem

UP NEXT

Is the Secret to CA Housing Affordability Buried in the Building Code?

UP NEXT

Students Are Short-Circuiting Chromebooks for a Social Media Challenge

UP NEXT

Trump says US and Iran ‘Sort of’ Agree on Terms for a Nuclear Deal

UP NEXT

Fresno Police Arrest Teen, Woman in Triple Shooting

CA Gov. Gavin Newsom Tries To Rebrand Himself Ahead Of A Potential Presidential Run

1 hour ago

Who Is Theo Von? The ‘Manosphere’ Podcaster With Trump In Qatar

1 hour ago

Texas Lawmaker Behind Abortion Ban Now Seeks to Clarify Life-Saving Exceptions

1 hour ago

Fresno, Wake Up. We’re Numb to Our DUI Problem

2 hours ago

Is the Secret to CA Housing Affordability Buried in the Building Code?

2 hours ago

Students Are Short-Circuiting Chromebooks for a Social Media Challenge

2 hours ago

Trump says US and Iran ‘Sort of’ Agree on Terms for a Nuclear Deal

3 hours ago

Fresno Police Arrest Teen, Woman in Triple Shooting

3 hours ago

Hanford Is Valley Location for Statewide Teachers Protest on Saturday

3 hours ago

Marte Hits 2 Homers, Suárez Adds 3-Run Blast As D-Backs Outlast Giants

3 hours ago

Ben & Jerry’s Founder Arrested at Senate Hearing After Protesting War in Gaza

One of the founders of Ben & Jerry’s, Ben Cohen, was arrested Wednesday in Washington, D.C., after he interrupted a Senate committee hea...

30 minutes ago

https://www.communitymedical.org/thecause?utm_source=Misfit+Digital&utm_medium=GVWire+Banner+Ads&utm_campaign=Branding+2025&utm_content=thecause
Ben Cohen, left, and Jerry Greenfield, co-founders of Ben & Jerrys, speak during a protest in Washington on Thursday, May 20, 2021. Ben Cohen, a co-founder of the ice cream brand, was among a group that interrupted a Senate hearing on Wednesday, protesting Congress’s funding of Israel’s military. (Stefani Reynolds/The New York Times)
30 minutes ago

Ben & Jerry’s Founder Arrested at Senate Hearing After Protesting War in Gaza

53 minutes ago

Trump Navigates Iran Nuclear Talks. Should US Insist on Zero Enrichment?

1 hour ago

WNBA Set To Tipoff Season With Teams Looking To Challenge For Title

1 hour ago

CA Gov. Gavin Newsom Tries To Rebrand Himself Ahead Of A Potential Presidential Run

1 hour ago

Who Is Theo Von? The ‘Manosphere’ Podcaster With Trump In Qatar

1 hour ago

Texas Lawmaker Behind Abortion Ban Now Seeks to Clarify Life-Saving Exceptions

2 hours ago

Fresno, Wake Up. We’re Numb to Our DUI Problem

2 hours ago

Is the Secret to CA Housing Affordability Buried in the Building Code?

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend