Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Duke Study: One Mask Type Spreads COVID-19 Faster. Will MLB Take Note?
TLBBHMAP3-U010ALB5ANM-348f959abae2-512-300x300-1
By Jim Jakobs, Digital Producer
Published 4 years ago on
August 10, 2020

Share

For months, the message has been pretty simple. Wear a mask to help stop the spread of COVID-19.

Now, many months into the pandemic we have a clearer picture of which masks work and which actually spread the virus.

Researchers at Duke University created a simple technique to analyze the effectiveness of various masks.

They tested 14 commonly available masks or mask alternatives and a professionally fit-tested N95 mask.

How the Study was Conducted

In the study published Friday, researchers with Duke’s physics department demonstrated a method that uses a laser beam and cell phone to evaluate mask efficiency and the transmission of respiratory droplets during normal speech.

A laser beam is expanded vertically by a cylindrical lens and shined through slits in the enclosure. The camera is located at the back of the box, a hole for the speaker in the front. The inset shows scattering for water particles from a spray bottle with the front of the box removed. (Duke University/Martin Fischer)

A subject wore a face mask and spoke into the direction of an expanded laser beam inside a dark enclosure. Droplets that propagate through the laser beam scatter light, which is recorded with a cell phone camera. A simple computer algorithm was used to count the droplets in the video.

Here is a video by researchers explaining how they did the study and some of the results they witnessed.

Best Masks: N95, Hand-Made Cotton

The researchers report the best face coverings were N95 masks without valves – hospital-grade coverings used by front-line healthcare workers. Surgical or polypropylene masks also performed well.

But hand-made cotton face coverings provided good coverage, eliminating a substantial amount of the spray.

Worst Masks: Bandanas, Neck Fleeces

“There are some masks actually hurt rather than do good,” said Duke’s Martin Fischer, an associate research chemistry and physics professor.

Bandanas and neck fleeces (also called gaiters) such as balaclavas didn’t block the droplets much at all. The study showed the neck fleece disperses larger droplets into several smaller droplets, therefore increasing the droplet count. The research on these masks showed it would actually be better to wear no mask than wear one of these.

“They were no good,” Duke physician Eric Westman said. “The notion that ‘anything is better than nothing’ didn’t hold true.”

The study explains it this way: “Considering that smaller particles are airborne longer than large droplets (larger droplets sink faster), the use of such a mask might be counterproductive.”

[covid-19-tracker]

Major League Baseball Gaiters

Fans started reaching out to Major League Baseball via Twitter after the study became public. Many big-leaguers are wearing gaiters, and baseball is battling positive coronavirus tests among players.

GV Wire℠ asked Dr. Westman if MLB should consider doing away with the gaiters in light of his study. “The simple, yet untested, answer would be to wear two or three at a time, rather than not wear them at all,” said Westman by email.

GV Wire℠ reached out to MLB public relations via email and didn’t receive a response.

The company that makes the face coverings has tweeted pictures of players wearing them in an effort to promote sales. GV Wire℠ sent an email to FOCO media relations for a response. MLBshop.com has gaiters available for every team.

DON'T MISS

Newsom Uses a Stunt to Position Himself as a Leader of Anti-Trump Resistance

DON'T MISS

CA Legislature Sets Record for Women in Office and Could See Historic Gender Parity

DON'T MISS

Trump to Target Iran’s Oil Trade in Renewed ‘Maximum Pressure’ Campaign

DON'T MISS

Over 2,500 Central Unified Students Receive Spirit Sweaters at 20th Annual ‘Warm for Winter’

DON'T MISS

Fresno Police Arrest Gang Members in Shooting Involving 7-Month-Old

DON'T MISS

Fresno Team Makes Low-Budget Horror Flicks Look Like Multi-Million-Dollar Productions

DON'T MISS

4B Movement: After the Election, a Call for Women to Swear Off Men

DON'T MISS

Homeowners’ Effort to Leave Sierra Unified Ends With County Ed Rejection

DON'T MISS

Will Terance Frazier’s Nonprofit Exit Granite Park? ‘Hell No’ He Says

DON'T MISS

Fresno Crash Sends Pickup Into Tree, Dark Tint Cited as Cause

UP NEXT

Trump to Target Iran’s Oil Trade in Renewed ‘Maximum Pressure’ Campaign

UP NEXT

4B Movement: After the Election, a Call for Women to Swear Off Men

UP NEXT

Macklin Celebrini, NHL’s Youngest Player, Scores on Marc-Andre Fleury, League’s Oldest

UP NEXT

Ramsey, Beckham Return to SoFi Stadium When the Struggling Dolphins Visit the Streaking Rams

UP NEXT

San Francisco’s First Black Female Mayor Concedes to Levi Strauss Heir

UP NEXT

FBI Thwarts Iranian Murder-for-Hire Plan Targeting Donald Trump

UP NEXT

Longtime Dodgers Ace Clayton Kershaw Is on the Mend After 2 Surgeries

UP NEXT

Christian McCaffrey Expected to Make Season Debut for 49ers This Week

UP NEXT

Southern California Wildfire Destroys 132 Structures as Officials Look for Fierce Winds to Subside

UP NEXT

Wave of Racist Texts After Election Prompts FBI Scrutiny

Over 2,500 Central Unified Students Receive Spirit Sweaters at 20th Annual ‘Warm for Winter’

4 hours ago

Fresno Police Arrest Gang Members in Shooting Involving 7-Month-Old

5 hours ago

Fresno Team Makes Low-Budget Horror Flicks Look Like Multi-Million-Dollar Productions

5 hours ago

4B Movement: After the Election, a Call for Women to Swear Off Men

6 hours ago

Homeowners’ Effort to Leave Sierra Unified Ends With County Ed Rejection

7 hours ago

Will Terance Frazier’s Nonprofit Exit Granite Park? ‘Hell No’ He Says

8 hours ago

Fresno Crash Sends Pickup Into Tree, Dark Tint Cited as Cause

9 hours ago

November Has Scattered Cool Temps, Rain Showers for Fresno

9 hours ago

Beyoncé Makes Grammy History With ‘Cowboy Carter,’ Leading 2025 Nominations

10 hours ago

Macklin Celebrini, NHL’s Youngest Player, Scores on Marc-Andre Fleury, League’s Oldest

10 hours ago

Newsom Uses a Stunt to Position Himself as a Leader of Anti-Trump Resistance

Two days after the nation’s voters gave Donald Trump another term as president, Gov. Gavin Newsom staged a publicity stunt to position...

3 hours ago

3 hours ago

Newsom Uses a Stunt to Position Himself as a Leader of Anti-Trump Resistance

3 hours ago

CA Legislature Sets Record for Women in Office and Could See Historic Gender Parity

3 hours ago

Trump to Target Iran’s Oil Trade in Renewed ‘Maximum Pressure’ Campaign

The Foundation for Central Schools' 20th annual Warm for Winter event provided over 2,500 Central Unified students with spirit sweaters, thanks to community partnerships and generous donors. (Central Foundation)
4 hours ago

Over 2,500 Central Unified Students Receive Spirit Sweaters at 20th Annual ‘Warm for Winter’

5 hours ago

Fresno Police Arrest Gang Members in Shooting Involving 7-Month-Old

5 hours ago

Fresno Team Makes Low-Budget Horror Flicks Look Like Multi-Million-Dollar Productions

Following the results of Tuesday's election, Jada Mevs, a 25-year-old from Washington, D.C., is urging women to take action by signing up for self-defense classes, deleting dating apps, getting on birth control, and investing in vibrators, as part of a growing response to the election of Donald Trump for a second term and the failure of abortion rights referendums. (Shutterstock)
6 hours ago

4B Movement: After the Election, a Call for Women to Swear Off Men

7 hours ago

Homeowners’ Effort to Leave Sierra Unified Ends With County Ed Rejection

Search

Send this to a friend