Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Lawsuit: Yellen Should Ignore 'Unconstitutional' Debt Limit
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 12 months ago on
May 8, 2023

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

WASHINGTON — A union of government employees on Monday sued Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen and President Joe Biden to try to stop them from complying with the law that limits the government’s total debt, which the lawsuit contends is unconstitutional.

The lawsuit comes just weeks before the government could default on the federal debt if Congress fails to raise the borrowing limit. Financial markets have become increasingly nervous about the potential for default, with economists warning that a failure to raise the debt limit could trigger a global financial crisis.

Biden to Meet with Top Republicans and Democrats in Congress

On Tuesday, Biden will meet with the top Republicans and Democrats in Congress to seek a potential breakthrough. The two sides remain far apart. Republicans have demanded steep spending cuts as the price of agreeing to raise the debt limit. Biden has argued that the debt ceiling, which applies to borrowing the government has already done, shouldn’t be used as leverage in budget talks.

The lawsuit, filed by the National Association of Government Employees, says that if Yellen abides by the debt limit once it becomes binding, possibly next month, she would have to choose which federal obligations to actually pay. Some analysts have argued that the government could prioritize interest payments on Treasury securities. That would ensure that the United States wouldn’t default on its securities, which have long been regarded as the safest investments in the world and are vital to global financial transactions.

But under the Constitution, the lawsuit argues, the president and Treasury secretary have no authority to decide which payments to make because the Constitution grants spending power to Congress. Doing so, it contends, would violate the Constitution’s separation of powers.

“Nothing in the Constitution or any judicial decision interpreting the Constitution,” the lawsuit states, “allows Congress to leave unchecked discretion to the President to exercise the spending power vested in the legislative branch by canceling, suspending, or refusing to carry out spending already approved by Congress.”

A Treasury Department spokesperson declined to comment on the lawsuit.

The NAGE represents about 75,000 government employees who it says are at risk of being laid off or losing pay and benefits should Congress fail to raise the debt ceiling. The debt limit, currently $31.4 trillion, was reached in January. But Yellen has since used various accounting measures to avoid breaching it.

Last week, Yellen warned that the debt limit would become binding as early as June 1, much earlier than many analyses had previously predicted, because tax receipts have come in lower than projected.

Laurence Tribe, a law professor at Harvard University, suggested that “it is possible that the Treasury Department would welcome the suit” because it expresses the view that “the ceiling is not a permissible bargaining tool for Congress to employ because it simply threatens to destroy the economy and hold the president hostage.”

White House Aides Explore Invoking 14th Amendment to the Constitution

Tribe has written a column in the New York Times expressing support for the idea that the debt ceiling is unconstitutional. White House aides have explored the notion of having the president invoke the 14th Amendment to the Constitution, which says the “validity” of the public debt “shall not be questioned.”

How fast the lawsuit may advance through the legal system depends, in part, “on which federal district judge gets the suit,” Tribe noted. ”It could move extremely quickly. … It’s quite hard to predict.”

Experts Warn of Economic “Calamity” if Debt Ceiling Isn’t Raised

On Sunday, Yellen said there were “no good options” for the United States to avoid an economic “calamity” if the debt ceiling isn’t raised. Economists say the standoff has distorted financial markets. Since Yellen warned a week ago that the government could default on its debt as early as June 1, interest rates on one-month Treasury bills have been shooting higher. They reached 5.35% Monday, up from 4.12% a week earlier — an unusually sharp move.

That suggested that investors were shunning the one-month bills out of concern that they could suffer from a default. The one-month yield, in an unusual move, now exceeds the rates on all longer-dated Treasuries, including 10-year notes, which yield 3.49%. Typically, borrowers demand higher rates to lock up their money for longer periods. Rates on the 10-year have fallen because investors expect a recession later this year that would force the Federal Reserve to cut its benchmark rate.

“Markets are beginning to aggressively price in a potential default,” said Joe Brusuelas, chief economist at tax advisory firm RSM. “The timing of an economic and financial crisis caused by the political authority could not be any worse.”

In the wake of three large bank failures in the past two months, Brusuelas, like many economists, thinks many banks are pulling back on lending to bolster their finances, a trend that could weaken the economy.

“A partial or full default would exacerbate those trends and result in a pullback in spending and investment by households and firms, as well as an increase in unemployment,” Brusuelas said. “It would almost surely tip the economy into a full-blown recession.”

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Did State Supreme Court Decide on Defamation Suit Against Assemblymember Soria?

DON'T MISS

Two Months to Count Election Ballots? California’s Long Tallies Turn Election Day Into Weeks, Months

DON'T MISS

Pennsylvania Nurse Who Gave Patients Lethal or Possibly Lethal Insulin Doses Gets Life in Prison

DON'T MISS

Merced’s Treacherous ‘Tunnel Lane’ Removed from Northbound Highway 99

DON'T MISS

US Employers Scaled Back Hiring in April. How That Could Let the Fed Cut Interest Rates

DON'T MISS

Bulldog Football Outlook: More Explosive Offense, a Potential Game-Wrecker on Defense

DON'T MISS

Over 2,300 Arrested in Pro-Palestinian Protests

DON'T MISS

See How Valley Lawmakers Voted on a Bill That Chills Free Speech

DON'T MISS

Meet Goldie Hawn: The Adorable Yorkie with a Heart of Gold

DON'T MISS

Police Investigating Possible Vandalism at Jewish Temple, Catholic Church

UP NEXT

US Employers Scaled Back Hiring in April. How That Could Let the Fed Cut Interest Rates

UP NEXT

See How Valley Lawmakers Voted on a Bill That Chills Free Speech

UP NEXT

President Joe Biden Calls Japan and India ‘Xenophobic’ Nations That Do Not Welcome Immigrants

UP NEXT

US Airstrike Targeting Al-Qaida Leader in Syria Killed a Farmer, American Military Says

UP NEXT

Another State Department Official Resigns Over Biden’s Gaza Policy

UP NEXT

Senators Want Limits on Government’s Use of Facial Recognition Technology for Airport Screening

UP NEXT

Biden Stays Quiet Amid Gaza Protests, College Police Clashes

UP NEXT

Fresno State Shows the Nation How a Peaceful Palestinian Protest is Done

UP NEXT

Trump Calls Judge ‘Crooked’ After Facing a Warning of Jail Time if He Violates a Trial Gag Order

UP NEXT

Federal Reserve Says Interest Rates Will Stay at Two-Decade High Until Inflation Further Cools

Merced’s Treacherous ‘Tunnel Lane’ Removed from Northbound Highway 99

2 hours ago

US Employers Scaled Back Hiring in April. How That Could Let the Fed Cut Interest Rates

2 hours ago

Bulldog Football Outlook: More Explosive Offense, a Potential Game-Wrecker on Defense

3 hours ago

Over 2,300 Arrested in Pro-Palestinian Protests

3 hours ago

See How Valley Lawmakers Voted on a Bill That Chills Free Speech

6 hours ago

Meet Goldie Hawn: The Adorable Yorkie with a Heart of Gold

6 hours ago

Police Investigating Possible Vandalism at Jewish Temple, Catholic Church

17 hours ago

Valley PBS’ Top 2 Executives Departing. Were Their Resignations a Surprise?

Entertainment /

19 hours ago

Unfiltered Clip: Insights from Dr. Trita Parsi on Navigating the Israel-Palestine Conflict

Video /

19 hours ago

Hamas Is Sending a Delegation to Egypt for Further Cease-Fire Talks in the Latest Sign of Progress

20 hours ago

What Did State Supreme Court Decide on Defamation Suit Against Assemblymember Soria?

The California Supreme Court denied an appeal from Assemblymember Esmeralda Soria, who is defending herself from a defamation lawsuit by a F...

20 mins ago

20 mins ago

What Did State Supreme Court Decide on Defamation Suit Against Assemblymember Soria?

1 hour ago

Two Months to Count Election Ballots? California’s Long Tallies Turn Election Day Into Weeks, Months

2 hours ago

Pennsylvania Nurse Who Gave Patients Lethal or Possibly Lethal Insulin Doses Gets Life in Prison

2 hours ago

Merced’s Treacherous ‘Tunnel Lane’ Removed from Northbound Highway 99

2 hours ago

US Employers Scaled Back Hiring in April. How That Could Let the Fed Cut Interest Rates

3 hours ago

Bulldog Football Outlook: More Explosive Offense, a Potential Game-Wrecker on Defense

3 hours ago

Over 2,300 Arrested in Pro-Palestinian Protests

6 hours ago

See How Valley Lawmakers Voted on a Bill That Chills Free Speech

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend