Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
More Skilled Migration Can Solve a Global Problem
Inside-Sources
By InsideSources.com
Published 1 year ago on
May 9, 2023

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

If politicians were truly serious about ending global inequality, many economists would say there is one obvious policy: allow greater global migration. A nurse is paid $1,900 annually in poor countries and $32,000 in rich countries. A McDonald’s worker in India earns 16 times less than their counterpart doing the same job in the United States. Economic theory holds that most of the world’s poor could become much more productive and richer if allowed to move to the developed world.

Bjorn Lomborg

InsideSources.com
Opinion

Studies routinely suggest that opening the entire world to migration could increase global gross domestic product by 50 percent to 150 percent. Of course, it would also involve more than 2 billion workers moving to the rich world. No mainstream politician in the rich world is about to call for unrestricted mobility. However, another migration policy is likely to be more politically achievable while reducing inequality and helping the rich and poor world: an increase in skilled migration.

Failed Promises

For many years, the Copenhagen Consensus has worked with several Nobel laureates and more than a hundred leading economists to look at how governments allocate money to do good for the world and establish where each dollar is most effectively spent.

This work has been driven by the failure of the world’s governments to reach their promises. In the United Nations’ Global Goals, all the world’s nations made extravagant promises for 2030 across nearly every agenda. We are at halftime for these promises this year, but we are far from halfway to delivery. On our current trajectory, even with very optimistic assumptions, we’re likely to achieve the goals at least half a century late.

This means the world needs to start prioritizing. As we’re clearly unable to deliver on everything we have promised, maybe we should start with the most effective policies first. New research for Copenhagen Consensus identifies 12 effective policies that could deliver huge benefits at moderate costs. Smart migration is one such policy, especially for reducing inequality.

Enabling more skilled migration to countries that need more skilled labor could achieve higher productivity and less inequality. And surveys tend to suggest it’s more politically viable, as skilled migration is less divisive than overall migration.

37 Million Skilled Workers Worldwide

Our study on migration looks at the effects of allowing more skilled migration, particularly of doctors and STEM workers.

The world today has 37 million skilled migrants. STEM workers comprise 9 million of these, and medical doctors about 1 million. Compare this to the fact that the world has just 13 million doctors.

What would happen if each nation took in 10 percent more skilled migrants from the same mix of countries they already have?

Migrants themselves would clearly benefit. For example, a doctor moving from the Caribbean or Central America to the United States will see a dramatic and sustained increase in wages, worth almost $1.6 million. But countries receiving skilled migrants, including the United States, would benefit: specialized doctors will fill available positions so that less specialized doctors or nurses can return to doing what they do best, and there is likely to be slightly higher economic growth. This is because introducing more diverse ways of thinking, doing things and approaching problems can generate more innovation which drives growth.

Recipient countries can also gain a skilled worker without incurring the costs of a lengthy, costly education.

Less obviously, countries where migrants originate will also see more benefits than costs. Often, we focus on the so-called “brain drain” that forces the country to pay to educate new doctors, while lowering the productivity of the doctors who remain.

Overall Benefits Outweigh Costs

But the new research shows these costs will be outweighed by the fact that skilled migrants who leave will establish new and additional channels for trade, investment and production that can boost their home countries. Moreover, they will also send home substantial and regular remittances, enabling their extended family to pay for more education and productivity. These benefits will likely outweigh the costs about two to one.

Globally, the overall benefits to everyone will be much higher than the costs.

While the total costs add up over the next 25 years to about $55 billion, the benefits will add up to almost a trillion dollars. Each dollar spent on the policy will deliver a substantial $18 of social benefit globally, which will mostly flow to the world’s poorer nations.

The research shows that increasing skilled migration globally offers a real opportunity to address inequality and increase global productivity. If the world is far behind on almost all its promises, let’s focus on the most effective policies first. Allowing more skilled migration where needed could be just one such policy.

About the Writer

Bjorn Lomborg is the president of the Copenhagen Consensus and a visiting fellow at Stanford University’s Hoover Institution. He wrote this for InsideSources.com

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration. 

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Russia and Ukraine Swap 95 Prisoners of War Each in Their Latest Exchange

DON'T MISS

US Tells Russian Minister Putin Should Release Detained Americans Including Gershkovich and Whelan

DON'T MISS

Judge’s Order Dismissing Trump Classified Docs Case Won’t Be Final Word as Long Court Fight Awaits

DON'T MISS

Former Mayor Known for Guaranteed Income Programs Launches Bid for California Lieutenant Governor

DON'T MISS

Southern California School District Sues Gov. Newsom Over New Gender-Identity Law

DON'T MISS

Watch: Republicans Share Their Wishlist for Trump

DON'T MISS

Fact Focus: A Look at Ominous Claims Around Illegal Immigration Made at the Republican Convention

DON'T MISS

AP-NORC Poll: Nearly Two-Thirds of Democrats Call for Biden’s Withdrawal

DON'T MISS

Democrats Aim to Nominate President in First Week of August, as Some Push Biden to Quit the Race

DON'T MISS

Singer Ingrid Andress Says She Was Drunk During Panned MLB Anthem Performance, Will Get Treatment

UP NEXT

The Secret of Trump’s Resurrection

UP NEXT

Fresno State Weighs in on City’s Industrial Battle: Be Wary of University’s Data

UP NEXT

What Polls Tell Us About Biden’s Chances

UP NEXT

Border Arrests Plunge 29% in June to the Lowest of Biden’s Presidency as Asylum Halt Takes Hold

UP NEXT

Is Inflation Finally Corralled? Powell Says Federal Reserve Believes It’s Close

UP NEXT

Amazon Prime Day Deals Are Almost Here. Should You Take Advantage of Them?

UP NEXT

Republicans Will Regret a Second Trump Term

UP NEXT

The Deep Source of Trump’s Appeal

UP NEXT

When Progressive Ideals Become a Luxury

UP NEXT

John Roberts Makes His Bid for Infamy

Former Mayor Known for Guaranteed Income Programs Launches Bid for California Lieutenant Governor

23 mins ago

Southern California School District Sues Gov. Newsom Over New Gender-Identity Law

28 mins ago

Watch: Republicans Share Their Wishlist for Trump

30 mins ago

Fact Focus: A Look at Ominous Claims Around Illegal Immigration Made at the Republican Convention

34 mins ago

AP-NORC Poll: Nearly Two-Thirds of Democrats Call for Biden’s Withdrawal

43 mins ago

Democrats Aim to Nominate President in First Week of August, as Some Push Biden to Quit the Race

49 mins ago

Singer Ingrid Andress Says She Was Drunk During Panned MLB Anthem Performance, Will Get Treatment

55 mins ago

The Secret of Trump’s Resurrection

58 mins ago

Brandon Aiyuk Requests Trade From 49ers

1 hour ago

Shohei Ohtani Hits 3-Run Homer for National League in All-Star Game Loss

1 hour ago

Russia and Ukraine Swap 95 Prisoners of War Each in Their Latest Exchange

KYIV, Ukraine — Ukraine and Russia exchanged 95 prisoners of war each, officials in both countries said Wednesday, three weeks after their l...

11 mins ago

11 mins ago

Russia and Ukraine Swap 95 Prisoners of War Each in Their Latest Exchange

14 mins ago

US Tells Russian Minister Putin Should Release Detained Americans Including Gershkovich and Whelan

18 mins ago

Judge’s Order Dismissing Trump Classified Docs Case Won’t Be Final Word as Long Court Fight Awaits

Photo of Mayor Michael Tubbs
23 mins ago

Former Mayor Known for Guaranteed Income Programs Launches Bid for California Lieutenant Governor

28 mins ago

Southern California School District Sues Gov. Newsom Over New Gender-Identity Law

30 mins ago

Watch: Republicans Share Their Wishlist for Trump

34 mins ago

Fact Focus: A Look at Ominous Claims Around Illegal Immigration Made at the Republican Convention

43 mins ago

AP-NORC Poll: Nearly Two-Thirds of Democrats Call for Biden’s Withdrawal

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend