Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Elon Musk Sues OpenAI and CEO Sam Altman, Claiming Betrayal of Its Goal to Benefit Humanity
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 10 months ago on
August 5, 2024

Billionaire Elon Musk files lawsuit against OpenAI, alleging deviation from its original nonprofit mission to benefit humanity. (AP File)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

SAN FRANCISCO – Elon Musk is suing OpenAI and its CEO Sam Altman over what he says is a betrayal of the ChatGPT maker’s founding aims of benefiting humanity rather than pursuing profits.

In a lawsuit filed at San Francisco Superior Court, billionaire Musk said that when he bankrolled OpenAI’s creation, he secured an agreement with Altman and Greg Brockman, the president, to keep the AI company as a nonprofit that would develop technology for the benefit of the public.

Under its founding agreement, OpenAI would also make its code open to the public instead of walling it off for any private company’s gains, the lawsuit says.

However, by embracing a close relationship with Microsoft, OpenAI and its top executives have set that pact “aflame” and are “perverting” the company’s mission, Musk alleges in the lawsuit.

OpenAI declined to comment on the lawsuit Friday.

“OpenAI, Inc. has been transformed into a closed-source de facto subsidiary of the largest technology company in the world: Microsoft,” the lawsuit filed Thursday says. “Under its new Board, it is not just developing but is actually refining an AGI to maximize profits for Microsoft, rather than for the benefit of humanity.”

Understanding AGI and Musk’s Legal Claims

AGI refers to artificial general intelligence, which are general purpose AI systems that can perform just as well as — or even better than — humans in a wide variety of tasks.

Musk is suing over breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty and unfair business practices. He also wants an injunction to prevent anyone, including Microsoft, from benefiting from OpenAI’s technology.

Those claims are unlikely to succeed in court but that might not be the point for Musk, who is getting his take and personal story on the record, said Anupam Chander, a law professor at Georgetown University.

“Partly there’s an assertion of Elon’s founding role in OpenAI and generative AI technology, in particular his claim he named OpenAI and he hired the key scientist and that he was the principal funder of its early years,” Chander said. “In some sense it’s a lawsuit that tries to establish his own place in the history of generative AI.”

Musk’s Early Involvement and OpenAI’s Evolution

Musk was an early investor in OpenAI when it was founded in 2015 and co-chaired its board alongside Altman. In the lawsuit, he said he invested “tens of millions” of dollars in the nonprofit research laboratory.

Musk resigned from the board in early 2018 in a move that OpenAI said at the time would prevent conflicts of interest as the Tesla CEO was recruiting AI talent to build self-driving technology at the electric car maker. “This will eliminate a potential future conflict for Elon,” OpenAI said in a February 2018 blog post. Musk has since said he also had disagreements with the startup’s direction, but he continued to donate to the nonprofit.

Later that year, OpenAI filed papers to incorporate a for-profit arm and began shifting most of its workforce to that business, but retained a nonprofit board of directors that governed the company. Microsoft made its first $1 billion investment in the company in 2019 and the next year, signed an agreement that gave the software giant exclusive rights to its AI models. That license is supposed to expire once OpenAI has achieved artificial general intelligence, the company has said.

Its unveiling of ChatGPT in late 2022 bought worldwide fame to OpenAI and helped spark a race by tech companies to capitalize on the public’s fascination with the technology.

When the nonprofit board abruptly fired Altman as CEO late last year, for reasons that still haven’t been fully disclosed, it was Microsoft that helped drive the push that brought Altman back as CEO and led most of the old board to resign. Musk’s lawsuit alleged that those changes caused the checks and balances protecting the nonprofit mission to “collapse overnight.”

Legal Experts Weigh In on Musk’s Lawsuit

One of Musk’s claims is that the directors of the nonprofit have failed to uphold their obligations to follow its mission, but Dana Brakman Reiser, a professor at Brooklyn Law School, is skeptical that Musk had standing to bring that claim.

“It would be very worrisome if every person who cared about or donated to a charity could suddenly sue their directors and officers to say, ‘You’re not doing what I think is the right thing to run this nonprofit,'” she said. In general, only other directors or an attorney general, for example, could bring that type of suit, she said.

Even if Musk invested in the for-profit business, his complaint seems to be that the organization is making too much profit in contradiction to its mission, which includes making its technology publicly available.

“I care about nonprofits actually following the mission that they set out and not being captured for some kind for profit purpose. That is a real concern,” Brakman Reiser said. “Whether Elon Musk is the person to raise that claim, I’m less sure.”

Whatever the legal merits of the claims, a brewing courtroom fight between Musk, who now has his own AI startup, and Altman could offer the public a peek into the internal debates and decision-making at OpenAI, though the company’s lawyers will likely fight to keep some of those documents confidential.

“The discovery will be epic,” posted venture capitalist Chamath Palihapitiya on Musk’s social media platform X on Friday. To which Musk replied in his only public commentary so far on the case: “Yes.”

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Sinner Bids for His First French Open Title Against Defending Champion Alcaraz

DON'T MISS

Coco Gauff Defeats Top-Ranked Aryna Sabalenka in 3 Sets to Win Her First French Open Title

DON'T MISS

Texas Beats Texas Tech in 3rd Game of WCWS to Win Its 1st National Championship

DON'T MISS

Conforto Comes Through, Dodgers Rally in 8th for Victory Abetted by Mets Mishap

DON'T MISS

Giants Beat the Slumping Braves in 10 Innings on a Wild Pitch

DON'T MISS

Trans Troops, Facing a Deadline, Opt to Stay and Fight the Ban

DON'T MISS

Can This 14-Year-Old Football Star Become a High School Millionaire?

DON'T MISS

Trump EPA Moves to Roll Back Rules Projected to Save Billions of Dollars and Thousands of Lives

DON'T MISS

Valley Foster Care Agencies Are Facing an Insurance Crisis and Possible Closure

DON'T MISS

World’s Largest Almond Processor Will Shutter Sacramento Plant. 600 Workers Impacted

UP NEXT

Coco Gauff Defeats Top-Ranked Aryna Sabalenka in 3 Sets to Win Her First French Open Title

UP NEXT

Texas Beats Texas Tech in 3rd Game of WCWS to Win Its 1st National Championship

UP NEXT

Conforto Comes Through, Dodgers Rally in 8th for Victory Abetted by Mets Mishap

UP NEXT

Giants Beat the Slumping Braves in 10 Innings on a Wild Pitch

UP NEXT

Trans Troops, Facing a Deadline, Opt to Stay and Fight the Ban

UP NEXT

Can This 14-Year-Old Football Star Become a High School Millionaire?

UP NEXT

Trump EPA Moves to Roll Back Rules Projected to Save Billions of Dollars and Thousands of Lives

UP NEXT

Valley Foster Care Agencies Are Facing an Insurance Crisis and Possible Closure

UP NEXT

World’s Largest Almond Processor Will Shutter Sacramento Plant. 600 Workers Impacted

UP NEXT

Trump Eyes Major Funding Cuts for California, Including All Public Universities

Trump Has Options to Punish Musk Even if His Federal Contracts Continue

8 hours ago

Ukrainian Attack Damaged 10% of Russia’s Strategic Bombers, Germany Says

8 hours ago

Riot Police, Anti-ICE Protesters Square Off in Los Angeles After Raids

8 hours ago

Why Reforming California’s Bedrock Environmental Law Is Good for the Environment

12 hours ago

Sinner Bids for His First French Open Title Against Defending Champion Alcaraz

14 hours ago

Coco Gauff Defeats Top-Ranked Aryna Sabalenka in 3 Sets to Win Her First French Open Title

14 hours ago

Texas Beats Texas Tech in 3rd Game of WCWS to Win Its 1st National Championship

14 hours ago

Conforto Comes Through, Dodgers Rally in 8th for Victory Abetted by Mets Mishap

14 hours ago

Giants Beat the Slumping Braves in 10 Innings on a Wild Pitch

14 hours ago

Trans Troops, Facing a Deadline, Opt to Stay and Fight the Ban

16 hours ago

Sights & Sounds: The 2025 Fresno Rainbow Pride Parade and Festival

The 35th Annual Fresno Rainbow Pride Parade and Festival brought vibrant sights, sounds, and unity to the Tower District and Fresno City Col...

3 hours ago

3 hours ago

Sights & Sounds: The 2025 Fresno Rainbow Pride Parade and Festival

7 hours ago

Trump Says Musk Relationship Over, Warns of ‘Serious Consequences’ if He Funds Democrats

7 hours ago

Iran Says It Obtained Sensitive Israeli Nuclear Documents

8 hours ago

Trump Has Options to Punish Musk Even if His Federal Contracts Continue

8 hours ago

Ukrainian Attack Damaged 10% of Russia’s Strategic Bombers, Germany Says

8 hours ago

Riot Police, Anti-ICE Protesters Square Off in Los Angeles After Raids

13 hours ago

Why Reforming California’s Bedrock Environmental Law Is Good for the Environment

14 hours ago

Sinner Bids for His First French Open Title Against Defending Champion Alcaraz

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend