Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Prime Minister of Yemen’s Houthi Government Killed in Israeli Strike

2 days ago

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott Signs Law Redrawing Congressional Maps

3 days ago

US Air Force will Offer Military Funeral Honors to Slain Capitol Rioter

3 days ago

US Republican Senator Joni Ernst Will Not Run for Re-Election, CBS News Reports

3 days ago

Wall Street Falls as Dell, Nvidia Drive Tech Losses

3 days ago

US Denies Visas to Palestinian Officials Ahead of UN General Assembly

3 days ago

Minneapolis Children Revealed Courage, Absorbed Fear During Church Shooting

4 days ago

Ford Recalls Nearly 500,000 Vehicles Over Brake Fluid Leak

4 days ago

Fresno-Bound Passenger Says Delta Attendant Slapped Him, Seeks $20M

4 days ago
The Polls Have Shifted Toward Harris. Is It Real, or Something Else?
d8a347b41db1ddee634e2d67d08798c102ef09ac
By The New York Times
Published 1 year ago on
August 16, 2024

Political signs supporting Joe Biden and Donald Trump on a lawn in Dickson City, Pa., on Sept. 25, 2020. Last week’s New York Times/Siena College polls showing Vice President Kamala Harris leading in three swing states led some Republicans and Democrats to ask the same question: Is this real? (Mark Makela/The New York Times)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Last week’s New York Times/Siena College polls showing Vice President Kamala Harris leading in three swing states led some Republicans and Democrats to ask the same question: Is this real?

Did the Polls Have It Right?

At the center of this question is whether the Times/Siena polls have surveyed enough voters who supported Donald Trump in 2020. The Trump campaign released a memo arguing those polls would have actually showed a Trump lead if the results had been weighted properly.

The Trump campaign’s critique focused on something pollsters refer to as “recalled vote.” In the polls of Pennsylvania, Michigan and Wisconsin, respondents recalled backing President Joe Biden over Trump by 6 percentage points, 52% to 46%, even though Biden actually won these three states by an average of about 1.5 points. The Trump campaign used this data point to say Trump would have led if the poll had the “right” number of Trump 2020 supporters.

This isn’t an absurd argument. In recent years, many pollsters have embraced recalled vote in exactly the way the Trump campaign describes: as an accurate measure of how people voted in the last election, which can then be used to evaluate the partisan balance of the sample. As an idea, it makes logical sense.

But over the longer run, recalled vote hasn’t usually been very reliable. Back in 2004, it was George W. Bush who led the polls, and it was the Democrats trying to prove that the polls were skewed. Among other things, they argued the polls had too many Bush ’00 voters, based on recalled vote.

Polls Found Bush and Kerry Tied

A CBS News/Times poll at the time, for instance, found Bush and John Kerry tied, but Bush ’00 voters outnumbered Al Gore ’00 voters by 6 points. Gore won the popular vote in 2000; if the poll had the “right” number of Gore supporters, Democrats thought, Kerry would have led — perhaps by a lot. Plausible, right?

Needless to say, the polls leading up to Bush’s 2004 reelection were not badly underestimating Kerry, as the recalled vote implied. This is not an isolated occurrence: Asking how people voted in the last election has been unreliable dating all the way to the earliest polls.

There are at least three factors at play: A surprising number of people don’t seem to remember how they voted; people seem likelier to remember voting for the winner (Biden in 2020; Bush in 2000); and they seem likelier to report voting when they did not.

Despite this history, more pollsters have been using recalled vote in recent years. For some pollsters with lower-quality samples, recall vote is a blunt instrument that can hammer even the worst poll into the ballpark. Indeed, if you take the last year of Times/Siena poll respondents from Manhattan — which Biden won by 74 points — you can produce an entirely plausible Trump plus-3 result for a national poll by weighting it to the 2020 result nationwide.

Even serious pollsters have used recalled vote in recent years. Some believe that the measure has become more accurate during our polarized era, which certainly seems plausible. It’s also possible that it’s more accurate for some new survey methodologies, such as panels (which attract highly engaged voters) or even just online polls in general.

But the Times/Siena data doesn’t support the idea that recalled vote has become much more useful. This year, about half of respondents without a record of voting in the 2020 election said they actually did vote. Only about 92% of those who did vote would say whom they supported — and there’s no way to be sure that the 92% were telling the truth, either.

While some pollsters — even good pollsters — say weighting on recalled vote would have made their polls more accurate in prior elections, the same cannot be said here: Times/Siena polls in 2020 and 2022 would have been less accurate if they had been weighted by recalled vote to match the election result.

It’s especially striking that recalled vote wouldn’t have helped Times/Siena polls in 2020, a year when they (along with virtually all other surveys) fairly significantly underestimated support for Trump. In fact, the Times/Siena polls would have underestimated Trump by even more if they had been weighted by recalled vote to match the actual results of the 2016 presidential election. That’s because the Times/Siena polls had “too many” Trump ’16 voters, a surprising finding but one consistent with the long history of people who voted for the losing candidate but who often later say they supported someone else.

This cycle, Times/Siena polls yet again show “too many” respondents saying they supported the winner of the last election: Biden. On average, Times/Siena respondents have recalled voting for Biden by about 3 points more than the actual results of the last election.

Is it possible that Times/Siena polls have been underestimating Trump all along? Absolutely. They certainly did in 2020, after all. Nonetheless, the Times/Siena polls so far this cycle routinely provided very positive results for Trump, even when there seemed to be “too many” Biden ’20 voters. Arguably their best result for Trump this cycle — a February poll showing him ahead by 6 points among registered voters — also found Biden with a 12-point edge on recalled vote, compared with his actual 4.5-point victory.

Despite this history, there’s still no guarantee that the Times/Siena data is correct. Even an unequivocally bad methodological decision — say, calling only landlines — can still occasionally yield a more “accurate” result if it cancels out a different kind of bias in another direction (say, Trump’s supporters being less likely to respond to a poll). Weighting on recalled vote is clearly far more debatable, but even if it is every bit as problematic it could still yield accurate results this cycle for the same reason. No one ever knows which polls — or which polling methodologies — will appear “right” or “wrong” until the election results begin to arrive.

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.

By Nate Cohn/Mark Makela
c. 2024 The New York Times Company

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Fresno County Garnet Fire Grows to 18,748 Acres in Sierra National Forest

DON'T MISS

US Judge Blocks Deportations of Unaccompanied Migrant Children to Guatemala

DON'T MISS

Israel Pounds Gaza City Suburbs, Netanyahu to Convene Security Cabinet

DON'T MISS

Thousands in Australia March Against Immigration, Government Condemns Rally

DON'T MISS

Trump Says He Will Order Voter ID Requirement for Every Vote

DON'T MISS

Greta Thunberg Joins Flotilla Heading for Gaza With Aid

DON'T MISS

Chicago Mayor Says Police Will Not Aid Federal Troops or Agents

DON'T MISS

Post-War Gaza Plan Sees Relocation of Population, ‘Digital Token’ for Palestinian Land: Washington Post

DON'T MISS

Labor Day Quiz: Do You Know What a Knocker-Upper Is?

DON'T MISS

Bulldogs Check All the Boxes in Runaway Win Over Georgia Southern

UP NEXT

US Judge Blocks Deportations of Unaccompanied Migrant Children to Guatemala

UP NEXT

Israel Pounds Gaza City Suburbs, Netanyahu to Convene Security Cabinet

UP NEXT

Thousands in Australia March Against Immigration, Government Condemns Rally

UP NEXT

Trump Says He Will Order Voter ID Requirement for Every Vote

UP NEXT

Greta Thunberg Joins Flotilla Heading for Gaza With Aid

UP NEXT

Chicago Mayor Says Police Will Not Aid Federal Troops or Agents

UP NEXT

Post-War Gaza Plan Sees Relocation of Population, ‘Digital Token’ for Palestinian Land: Washington Post

UP NEXT

Labor Day Quiz: Do You Know What a Knocker-Upper Is?

UP NEXT

Bulldogs Check All the Boxes in Runaway Win Over Georgia Southern

UP NEXT

Judge Blocks Pillar of Trump’s Mass Deportation Campaign

Thousands in Australia March Against Immigration, Government Condemns Rally

17 hours ago

Trump Says He Will Order Voter ID Requirement for Every Vote

17 hours ago

Greta Thunberg Joins Flotilla Heading for Gaza With Aid

17 hours ago

Chicago Mayor Says Police Will Not Aid Federal Troops or Agents

17 hours ago

Post-War Gaza Plan Sees Relocation of Population, ‘Digital Token’ for Palestinian Land: Washington Post

17 hours ago

Labor Day Quiz: Do You Know What a Knocker-Upper Is?

18 hours ago

Bulldogs Check All the Boxes in Runaway Win Over Georgia Southern

1 day ago

Judge Blocks Pillar of Trump’s Mass Deportation Campaign

2 days ago

Classic Cars Will Still Need a Smog Test in California After Lawmakers Reject Jay Leno Bill

2 days ago

Visalia Driver Arrested for DUI After Multiple Crashes and Pedestrian Injured

2 days ago

Fresno County Garnet Fire Grows to 18,748 Acres in Sierra National Forest

A lightning-sparked wildfire, the Garnet Fire, in the Sierra National Forest has burned 18,748 acres in Fresno County and remains at 8% cont...

17 hours ago

Photo: USDA - Forest Service Tanker 40 at Fresno Air Attack Base. The Fresno County Garnet Fire in the Sierra National Forest has burned 18,748 acres and is 8% contained as crews make progress on containment lines while bracing for possible thunderstorms early this week. (Sam Wu/USFS)
17 hours ago

Fresno County Garnet Fire Grows to 18,748 Acres in Sierra National Forest

U.S. flag and Judge gavel are seen in this illustration taken, August 6, 2024. (Reuters File)
17 hours ago

US Judge Blocks Deportations of Unaccompanied Migrant Children to Guatemala

Smoke rises from Gaza after an explosion, as seen from the Israeli side of the border, August 31, 2025. (Reuters/Amir Cohen)
17 hours ago

Israel Pounds Gaza City Suburbs, Netanyahu to Convene Security Cabinet

Demonstrators hold a banner during the 'March for Australia' anti-immigration rally, in Sydney, Australia, August 31, 2025. REUTERS/Hollie Adams
17 hours ago

Thousands in Australia March Against Immigration, Government Condemns Rally

President Donald Trump walks on the grounds of the Trump National Golf Club in Sterling, Virginia, U.S., August 30, 2025. (Reuters/Nathan Howard)
17 hours ago

Trump Says He Will Order Voter ID Requirement for Every Vote

Activists Yasemin Acar, Greta Thunberg and Thiago Avila attend a press conference before the departure of the Global Sumud Flotilla, a humanitarian expedition to Gaza, at the port of Barcelona, Spain August 31, 2025. (Reuters/Eva Manez)
17 hours ago

Greta Thunberg Joins Flotilla Heading for Gaza With Aid

National Guard troops wear gas masks during protests against federal immigration sweeps, in Los Angeles, California, U.S., June 12, 2025. (Reuters File)
17 hours ago

Chicago Mayor Says Police Will Not Aid Federal Troops or Agents

A view of tents sheltering Palestinians displaced by the Israeli military offensive, in Gaza City, August 23, 2025. (Reuters File)
17 hours ago

Post-War Gaza Plan Sees Relocation of Population, ‘Digital Token’ for Palestinian Land: Washington Post

Search

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Send this to a friend