Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Supreme Court Upholds Law Banning TikTok if Not Sold by Chinese Parent Company
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 1 month ago on
January 17, 2025

Supreme Court upholds TikTok ban, citing national security concerns over Chinese ownership. (AP File)

Share

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Friday unanimously upheld the federal law banning TikTok beginning Sunday unless it’s sold by its China-based parent company, holding that the risk to national security posed by its ties to China overcomes concerns about limiting speech by the app or its 170 million users in the United States.

A sale does not appear imminent and, although experts have said the app will not disappear from existing users’ phones once the law takes effect on Jan. 19, new users won’t be able to download it and updates won’t be available. That will eventually render the app unworkable, the Justice Department has said in court filings.

The decision came against the backdrop of unusual political agitation by President-elect Donald Trump, who vowed that he could negotiate a solution and the administration of President Joe Biden, which has signaled it won’t enforce the law beginning Sunday, his final full day in office.

Trump, mindful of TikTok’s popularity, and his own 14.7 million followers on the app, finds himself on the opposite side of the argument from prominent Senate Republicans who fault TikTok’s Chinese owner for not finding a buyer before now. Trump said in a Truth Social post shortly before the decision was issued that TikTok was among the topics in his conversation Friday with Chinese leader Xi Jinping.

Uncertainty Surrounds Future Options

It’s unclear what options are open to Trump once he is sworn in as president on Monday. The law allowed for a 90-day pause in the restrictions on the app if there had been progress toward a sale before it took effect. Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar, who defended the law at the Supreme Court for the Democratic Biden administration, told the justices last week that it’s uncertain whether the prospect of a sale once the law is in effect could trigger a 90-day respite for TikTok.

“Congress has determined that divestiture is necessary to address its well-supported national security concerns regarding TikTok’s data collection practices and relationship with a foreign adversary,” the court said in an unsigned opinion, adding that the law “does not violate petitioners’ First Amendment rights.”

Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Neil Gorsuch filed short separate opinions noting some reservations about the court’s decision but going along with the outcome.

“Without doubt, the remedy Congress and the President chose here is dramatic,” Gorsuch wrote. Still, he said he was persuaded by the argument that China could get access to “vast troves of personal information about tens of millions of Americans.”

Reactions and Concerns

Some digital rights groups slammed the court’s ruling shortly after it was released.

“Today’s unprecedented decision upholding the TikTok ban harms the free expression of hundreds of millions of TikTok users in this country and around the world,” said Kate Ruane, a director at the Washington-based Center for Democracy & Technology, which has supported TikTok’s challenge to the federal law.

Content creators who opposed the law also worried about the effect on their business if TikTok shuts down. “I’m very, very concerned about what’s going to happen over the next couple weeks,” said Desiree Hill, owner of Crown’s Corner mechanic shop in Conyers, Georgia. “And very scared about the decrease that I’m going to have in reaching customers and worried I’m going to potentially lose my business in the next six months.”

At arguments, the justices were told by a lawyer for TikTok and ByteDance Ltd., the Chinese technology company that is its parent, how difficult it would be to consummate a deal, especially since Chinese law restricts the sale of the proprietary algorithm that has made the social media platform wildly successful.

The app allows users to watch hundreds of videos in about half an hour because some are only a few seconds long, according to a lawsuit filed last year by Kentucky complaining that TikTok is designed to be addictive and harms kids’ mental health. Similar suits were filed by more than a dozen states. TikTok has called the claims inaccurate.

Geopolitical Implications

The dispute over TikTok’s ties to China has come to embody the geopolitical competition between Washington and Beijing.

“ByteDance and its Chinese Communist masters had nine months to sell TikTok before the Sunday deadline,” Sen. Tom Cotton, R-Ark., wrote on X. “The very fact that Communist China refuses to permit its sale reveals exactly what TikTok is: a communist spy app. The Supreme Court correctly rejected TikTok’s lies and propaganda masquerading as legal arguments.”

The U.S. has said it’s concerned about TikTok collecting vast swaths of user data, including sensitive information on viewing habits, that could fall into the hands of the Chinese government through coercion. Officials have also warned the algorithm that fuels what users see on the app is vulnerable to manipulation by Chinese authorities, who can use it to shape content on the platform in a way that’s difficult to detect.

TikTok points out the U.S. has not presented evidence that China has attempted to manipulate content on its U.S. platform or gather American user data through TikTok.

Bipartisan majorities in Congress passed legislation and Biden signed it into law in April. The law was the culmination of a yearslong saga in Washington over TikTok, which the government sees as a national security threat.

TikTok, which sued the government last year over the law, has long denied it could be used as a tool of Beijing. A three-judge panel made up of two Republican appointees and a Democratic appointee unanimously upheld the law in December, prompting TikTok’s quick appeal to the Supreme Court.

Without a sale to an approved buyer, the law bars app stores operated by Apple, Google and others from offering TikTok beginning on Sunday. Internet hosting services also will be prohibited from hosting TikTok.

ByteDance has said it won’t sell. But some investors have been eyeing it, including Trump’s former Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin and billionaire businessman Frank McCourt. McCourt’s Project Liberty initiative has said it and its unnamed partners have presented a proposal to ByteDance to acquire TikTok’s U.S. assets. The consortium, which includes “Shark Tank” host Kevin O’Leary, did not disclose the financial terms of the offer.

McCourt, in a statement following the ruling, said his group was “ready to work with the company and President Trump to complete a deal.”

Prelogar told the justices last week that having the law take effect “might be just the jolt” ByteDance needs to reconsider its position.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Pentagon Says It Will Cut 5,400 Probationary Workers Starting Next Week

DON'T MISS

Federal Order to End DEI Policies Has Fresno Schools Scrambling for Answers

DON'T MISS

Bannon Denies Nazi Salute Accusation at CPAC, Calls It ‘a Wave’

DON'T MISS

Misty Her Calls for ‘Huge Mindset Shift’ at Fresno Unified as She Campaigns for Top Job

DON'T MISS

AP Sues 3 Trump Administration Officials, Citing Freedom of Speech

DON'T MISS

Bullard Teacher Arrested for 10 Sex Felonies Involving Student

DON'T MISS

Protester Hurls Tomato at Tulare Assemblywoman During High-Speed Rail Conference

DON'T MISS

LA Mayor Bass Removes Fire Chief Kristin Crowley After Wildfire Response Criticism

DON'T MISS

Salman Rushdie’s Attacker Found Guilty of Attempted Murder in New York

DON'T MISS

Rate the SE Fresno City Council Candidates Before You Vote

UP NEXT

Federal Order to End DEI Policies Has Fresno Schools Scrambling for Answers

UP NEXT

Bannon Denies Nazi Salute Accusation at CPAC, Calls It ‘a Wave’

UP NEXT

AP Sues 3 Trump Administration Officials, Citing Freedom of Speech

UP NEXT

Bullard Teacher Arrested for 10 Sex Felonies Involving Student

UP NEXT

Protester Hurls Tomato at Tulare Assemblywoman During High-Speed Rail Conference

UP NEXT

LA Mayor Bass Removes Fire Chief Kristin Crowley After Wildfire Response Criticism

UP NEXT

Salman Rushdie’s Attacker Found Guilty of Attempted Murder in New York

UP NEXT

Judge Extends Temporary Block on NIH Funding Cuts

UP NEXT

Judge Considers Further Blocking Trump’s Federal Funding Freeze

UP NEXT

Who Won Fresno GOP Leadership Fight? State Party Decides

Misty Her Calls for ‘Huge Mindset Shift’ at Fresno Unified as She Campaigns for Top Job

2 hours ago

AP Sues 3 Trump Administration Officials, Citing Freedom of Speech

2 hours ago

Bullard Teacher Arrested for 10 Sex Felonies Involving Student

2 hours ago

Protester Hurls Tomato at Tulare Assemblywoman During High-Speed Rail Conference

3 hours ago

LA Mayor Bass Removes Fire Chief Kristin Crowley After Wildfire Response Criticism

4 hours ago

Salman Rushdie’s Attacker Found Guilty of Attempted Murder in New York

4 hours ago

Rate the SE Fresno City Council Candidates Before You Vote

4 hours ago

Judge Extends Temporary Block on NIH Funding Cuts

4 hours ago

Judge Considers Further Blocking Trump’s Federal Funding Freeze

4 hours ago

Who Won Fresno GOP Leadership Fight? State Party Decides

5 hours ago

Pentagon Says It Will Cut 5,400 Probationary Workers Starting Next Week

WASHINGTON — The Defense Department said Friday that it’s cutting 5,400 probationary workers starting next week and will put a hiring ...

43 minutes ago

43 minutes ago

Pentagon Says It Will Cut 5,400 Probationary Workers Starting Next Week

1 hour ago

Federal Order to End DEI Policies Has Fresno Schools Scrambling for Answers

2 hours ago

Bannon Denies Nazi Salute Accusation at CPAC, Calls It ‘a Wave’

2 hours ago

Misty Her Calls for ‘Huge Mindset Shift’ at Fresno Unified as She Campaigns for Top Job

2 hours ago

AP Sues 3 Trump Administration Officials, Citing Freedom of Speech

2 hours ago

Bullard Teacher Arrested for 10 Sex Felonies Involving Student

3 hours ago

Protester Hurls Tomato at Tulare Assemblywoman During High-Speed Rail Conference

Photo of Karen Bass
4 hours ago

LA Mayor Bass Removes Fire Chief Kristin Crowley After Wildfire Response Criticism

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend