Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Supporters Say Prop. 36 Will Correct Crime and Homeless Ills. What Do Voters Think?
Edward Smith updated website photo 2024
By Edward Smith
Published 2 hours ago on
November 5, 2024

If it passes, Proposition 36 will allow prosecutors and judges to charge repeat criminals with felonies rather than only misdemeanors as had been dictated by the controversial Prop. 47. (GV Wire Composite/Paul Marshall)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

To almost no one’s surprise, voters are approving Proposition 36 by a commanding margin.

Early voting results show the criminal justice measure earning 70.8% approval with 22.9% of precincts reporting.

The rate surpasses even the initiative that Prop. 36 sought to reform. 2014’s Prop. 47 only received 60%.

GV Wire will update results as they come in.

The bipartisan proposal quickly became divisive, with Gov. Gavin Newsom coming out opposed to the legislation. Democratic legislators floated some laws to add penalties to retail theft that would be nullified if Prop. 36 passes. Politicos surmised it was a way to lull major retailers such as Walmart away from supporting the initiative. Walmart was a major funder of Prop. 36.

Prop. 36 Advocates Say Law Will Lower Crime, Reduce Homelessness

Largely authored by California district attorneys, authors say the crime initiative will reverse many of the policies of Proposition 47 — the 2014 voter initiative that reduced sentences for some crime and drug offenses.

Prop. 36 allows prosecutors and judges to bring felony charges against criminals arrested on their third offense. Prop. 47 reduced penalties for many nonviolent crimes to misdemeanors. Opponents said that took away fear of the law as thieves knew to steal less than $950 worth of goods — the threshold outlined by Prop. 47.

For drug users, those facing a possession charge will receive a choice of treatment or prison.

Tulare County District Attorney Tim Ward said the return of drug courts — which he said largely disappeared after Prop. 47 — will help the part of California’s homelessness crisis driven by drug addiction.

“We were able to come up with … a comprehensive, yet very fair plan to really treat our drug, mental health crisis for the individuals we see living on the street and also while doing so address the rampant theft issue, which many of us feel those two things are intrinsically connected,” Ward said.

Opponents said the bill overly punishes people who are not a danger. They also said the $750 million price tag for the bill takes away from mental health efforts, drug treatment, and rehab programs.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Tangipa Holds Slight Lead Over Radanovich in Early Voting

DON'T MISS

From Tax Measures to Prison Labor: Keep Track of State Propositions

DON'T MISS

Some Fresno Area School and College Bond Measures Struggling. But 3rd Time Might Be Charm for Sierra.

DON'T MISS

Republicans Take Senate Majority for First Time in 4 Years

DON'T MISS

Strong Initial Opposition to Rent Control Ballot Initiative

DON'T MISS

Two Union-Funded Challengers Trailing in Fresno Area Trustee Races

DON'T MISS

Supporters Say Prop. 36 Will Correct Crime and Homeless Ills. What Do Voters Think?

DON'T MISS

Bonakdar Leads Richardson By Slim Margin in NE Fresno Council Race

DON'T MISS

Early Voting Shows Bredefeld, Chavez Leading in Supervisor Races

DON'T MISS

Different Faces, Different Voices, But the Same Goal: Exercising Democracy by Voting

UP NEXT

From Tax Measures to Prison Labor: Keep Track of State Propositions

UP NEXT

Some Fresno Area School and College Bond Measures Struggling. But 3rd Time Might Be Charm for Sierra.

UP NEXT

Republicans Take Senate Majority for First Time in 4 Years

UP NEXT

Strong Initial Opposition to Rent Control Ballot Initiative

UP NEXT

Two Union-Funded Challengers Trailing in Fresno Area Trustee Races

UP NEXT

Supporters Say Prop. 36 Will Correct Crime and Homeless Ills. What Do Voters Think?

UP NEXT

Bonakdar Leads Richardson By Slim Margin in NE Fresno Council Race

UP NEXT

Early Voting Shows Bredefeld, Chavez Leading in Supervisor Races

UP NEXT

Different Faces, Different Voices, But the Same Goal: Exercising Democracy by Voting

UP NEXT

Live Updates: Who Will Be President? AP Calls States for the Candidates

Edward Smith,
Multimedia Journalist
Edward Smith began reporting for GV Wire in May 2023. His reporting career began at Fresno City College, graduating with an associate degree in journalism. After leaving school he spent the next six years with The Business Journal, doing research for the publication as well as covering the restaurant industry. Soon after, he took on real estate and agriculture beats, winning multiple awards at the local, state and national level. You can contact Edward at 559-440-8372 or at Edward.Smith@gvwire.com.

Republicans Take Senate Majority for First Time in 4 Years

2 hours ago

Strong Initial Opposition to Rent Control Ballot Initiative

2 hours ago

Two Union-Funded Challengers Trailing in Fresno Area Trustee Races

2 hours ago

Supporters Say Prop. 36 Will Correct Crime and Homeless Ills. What Do Voters Think?

2 hours ago

Bonakdar Leads Richardson By Slim Margin in NE Fresno Council Race

2 hours ago

Early Voting Shows Bredefeld, Chavez Leading in Supervisor Races

2 hours ago

Different Faces, Different Voices, But the Same Goal: Exercising Democracy by Voting

7 hours ago

Live Updates: Who Will Be President? AP Calls States for the Candidates

7 hours ago

Fresno County Road Rage Incident Leads to Violent Assault, High-Speed Chase

8 hours ago

When to Expect Fresno County Election Results

9 hours ago

Tangipa Holds Slight Lead Over Radanovich in Early Voting

Early voting results from the California Secretary of State are painting a picture of how voters are leaning in four state Assembly races. G...

21 mins ago

21 mins ago

Tangipa Holds Slight Lead Over Radanovich in Early Voting

1 hour ago

From Tax Measures to Prison Labor: Keep Track of State Propositions

1 hour ago

Some Fresno Area School and College Bond Measures Struggling. But 3rd Time Might Be Charm for Sierra.

2 hours ago

Republicans Take Senate Majority for First Time in 4 Years

2 hours ago

Strong Initial Opposition to Rent Control Ballot Initiative

2 hours ago

Two Union-Funded Challengers Trailing in Fresno Area Trustee Races

2 hours ago

Supporters Say Prop. 36 Will Correct Crime and Homeless Ills. What Do Voters Think?

2 hours ago

Bonakdar Leads Richardson By Slim Margin in NE Fresno Council Race

Search

Send this to a friend