Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Top Brazilian Judge Orders Suspension of X Platform in Brazil Amid Feud With Musk
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 2 weeks ago on
August 30, 2024

Brazilian Supreme Court justice orders X suspension amid escalating feud with Musk over free speech and misinformation. (AP File)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

SAO PAULO — A Brazilian Supreme Court justice on Friday ordered the suspension of Elon Musk’s social media giant X in Brazil after the tech billionaire refused to name a legal representative in the country, according to a copy of his decision.

The move further escalates the monthslong feud between the two men over free speech, far-right accounts and misinformation.

Justice Alexandre de Moraes had warned Musk on Wednesday night that X could be blocked in Brazil if he failed to comply with his order to name a representative, and established a 24-hour deadline. The company hasn’t had a representative in the country since earlier this month.

“Elon Musk showed his total disrespect for Brazilian sovereignty and, in particular, for the judiciary, setting himself up as a true supranational entity and immune to the laws of each country,” de Moraes wrote in his decision.

The justice said the platform will stay suspended until it complies with his orders, and also set a daily fine of 50,000 reais ($8,900) for people or companies using VPNs to access it.

In a later ruling, he backtracked on his initial decision to establish a 5-day deadline for internet service providers themselves — and not just the telecommunications regulator — to block access to X, as well as his directive for app stores to remove virtual private networks, or VPNs.

Brazil’s telecommunications regulator Anatel has 24 hours to comply. The regulator’s chairman Carlos Baigorri told GloboNews channel that the country’s biggest service providers will respond quickly, but added smaller ones might need more time to suspend X from their services.

The full bench of Brazil’s Supreme Court is expected to rule on the case, but no date for deliberations was set.

X’s Importance in Brazil and Clash With de Moraes

Brazil is an important market for X, which has struggled with the loss of advertisers since Musk purchased the former Twitter in 2022. Market research group Emarketer says some 40 million Brazilians, roughly one-fifth of the population, access X at least once per month.

X had posted on its official Global Government Affairs page late Thursday that it expected X to be shut down by de Moraes, “simply because we would not comply with his illegal orders to censor his political opponents.”

“When we attempted to defend ourselves in court, Judge de Moraes threatened our Brazilian legal representative with imprisonment. Even after she resigned, he froze all of her bank accounts,” the company wrote. “Our challenges against his manifestly illegal actions were either dismissed or ignored. Judge de Moraes’ colleagues on the Supreme Court are either unwilling or unable to stand up to him.”

X has clashed with de Moraes over its reluctance to comply with orders to block users.

Accounts that the platform previously has shut down on Brazilian orders include lawmakers affiliated with former President Jair Bolsonaro’s right-wing party and activists accused of undermining Brazilian democracy. X’s lawyers in April sent a document to the Supreme Court in April, saying that since 2019 it had suspended or blocked 226 users.

In his decision Friday, de Moraes’ cited Musk’s statements as evidence that X’s conduct “clearly intends to continue to encourage posts with extremism, hate speech and anti-democratic discourse, and to try to withdraw them from jurisdictional control.”

Musk’s Free Speech Claims and de Moraes’ Defense

Musk, a self-proclaimed “free speech absolutist,” has repeatedly claimed the justice’s actions amount to censorship, and his argument has been echoed by Brazil’s political right. He has often insulted de Moraes on his platform, characterizing him as a dictator and tyrant.

De Moraes’ defenders have said his actions aimed at X have been lawful, supported by most of the court’s full bench and have served to protect democracy at a time it is imperiled. He wrote Friday that his ruling is based on Brazilian law requiring internet services companies to have representation in the country so they can be notified when there are relevant court decisions and take requisite action — specifying the takedown of illicit content posted by users, and an anticipated churn of misinformation during October municipal elections.

The looming shutdown is not unprecedented in Brazil.

Lone Brazilian judges shut down Meta’s WhatsApp, the nation’s most widely used messaging app, several times in 2015 and 2016 due to the company’s refusal to comply with police requests for user data. In 2022, de Moraes threatened the messaging app Telegram with a nationwide shutdown, arguing it had repeatedly ignored Brazilian authorities’ requests to block profiles and provide information. He ordered Telegram to appoint a local representative; the company ultimately complied and stayed online.

X and its former incarnation, Twitter, have been banned in several countries — mostly authoritarian regimes such as Russia, China, Iran, Myanmar, North Korea, Venezuela and Turkmenistan. Other countries, such as Pakistan, Turkey and Egypt, have also temporarily suspended X before, usually to quell dissent and unrest. Twitter was banned in Egypt after the Arab Spring uprisings, which some dubbed the “Twitter revolution,” but it has since been restored.

VPN Usage and Legal Implications

Earlier on Friday, a search on X showed hundreds of Brazilian users inquiring about VPNs that could potentially enable them to continue using the platform by making it appear they were logging on from outside the country. It was not immediately clear how Brazilian authorities would police this practice and impose fines cited by de Moraes.

“This is an unusual measure, but its main objective is to ensure that the court order to suspend the platform’s operation is, in fact, effective,” Filipe Medon, a specialist in digital law and professor at the law school of Getulio Vargas Foundation, a university in Rio de Janeiro, told The Associated Press. “As a general rule, there are no provisions in Brazilian law that prevent users from using VPNs, since they are not the subjects of the blocking and suspension orders, but rather the companies.”

Even so, Mariana de Souza Alves Lima, known by her handle MariMoon, showed her 1.4 million followers on X where she intends to go, posting a screenshot of rival social network BlueSky.

X said that it plans to publish what it has called de Moraes’ “illegal demands” and related court filings “in the interest of transparency.”

Also on Thursday evening, Starlink, Musk’s satellite internet service provider, said on X that de Moraes this week froze its finances, preventing it from doing any transactions in the country where it has more than 250,000 customers.

“This order is based on an unfounded determination that Starlink should be responsible for the fines levied—unconstitutionally—against X. It was issued in secret and without affording Starlink any of the due process of law guaranteed by the Constitution of Brazil. We intend to address the matter legally,” Starlink said in its statement. The law firm representing Starlink told the AP that the company appealed, but wouldn’t make further comment.

Another Brazilian Supreme Court Justice, Cristiano Zanin, rejected an appeal by Starlink to unfreeze the company’s bank accounts.

Musk replied to people sharing the reports of the freeze, adding insults directed at de Moraes. “This guy @Alexandre is an outright criminal of the worst kind, masquerading as a judge,” he wrote.

Musk later posted on X that SpaceX, which runs Starlink, will provide free internet service in Brazil “until the matter is resolved” since “we cannot receive payment, but don’t want to cut anyone off.”

In his decision, de Moraes said he ordered the freezing of Starlink’s assets, as X didn’t have enough money in its accounts to cover mounting fines, and reasoning that the two companies are part of the same economic group.

While ordering X’s suspension followed warnings and fines and so was appropriate, taking action against Starlink seems “highly questionable,” said Luca Belli, coordinator of the Getulio Vargas Foundation’s Technology and Society Center.

“Yes, of course, they have the same owner, Elon Musk, but it is discretionary to consider Starlink as part of the same economic group as Twitter (X). They have no connection, they have no integration,” Belli said.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Project 2025 to California: Report Abortion Data or Lose Billions in Medicaid

DON'T MISS

Should California Community Colleges Offer Bachelor’s Degrees in Nursing? Universities Say No

DON'T MISS

Bulldogs Pound a Lightweight, but a Heavyweight Looms in Two Weeks

DON'T MISS

18,000 Miles Later, an American Woman Has Cycled the World

DON'T MISS

Meet Bentley: The Athletic, Snuggly, Bright Eyed Supermutt Ready for Adoption

DON'T MISS

How Hamas Uses Brutality to Maintain Power

DON'T MISS

A College Degree While Still in High School? More Valley Students Are Doing It

DON'T MISS

CHP Traffic Stop Bust Yields $1.3 Million Cocaine Seizure

DON'T MISS

Nelson Mandela Monument Unveiled in Fresno State Peace Garden

DON'T MISS

Southern California Wildfire Generates Rare ‘Fire Clouds,’ Visible from Space

UP NEXT

18,000 Miles Later, an American Woman Has Cycled the World

UP NEXT

Meet Bentley: The Athletic, Snuggly, Bright Eyed Supermutt Ready for Adoption

UP NEXT

How Hamas Uses Brutality to Maintain Power

UP NEXT

A College Degree While Still in High School? More Valley Students Are Doing It

UP NEXT

CHP Traffic Stop Bust Yields $1.3 Million Cocaine Seizure

UP NEXT

Nelson Mandela Monument Unveiled in Fresno State Peace Garden

UP NEXT

Southern California Wildfire Generates Rare ‘Fire Clouds,’ Visible from Space

UP NEXT

Canning Makes a Comeback: New Interest in Old-Time Food Preservation

UP NEXT

NFL Tries to Tackle Tackling with a New Next Gen Statistic

UP NEXT

Three Killed in Single-Vehicle Crash Near Fresno Identified

18,000 Miles Later, an American Woman Has Cycled the World

22 hours ago

Meet Bentley: The Athletic, Snuggly, Bright Eyed Supermutt Ready for Adoption

23 hours ago

How Hamas Uses Brutality to Maintain Power

23 hours ago

A College Degree While Still in High School? More Valley Students Are Doing It

1 day ago

CHP Traffic Stop Bust Yields $1.3 Million Cocaine Seizure

1 day ago

Nelson Mandela Monument Unveiled in Fresno State Peace Garden

1 day ago

Southern California Wildfire Generates Rare ‘Fire Clouds,’ Visible from Space

1 day ago

Canning Makes a Comeback: New Interest in Old-Time Food Preservation

1 day ago

NFL Tries to Tackle Tackling with a New Next Gen Statistic

1 day ago

Three Killed in Single-Vehicle Crash Near Fresno Identified

2 days ago

Project 2025 to California: Report Abortion Data or Lose Billions in Medicaid

Project 2025, the 900-page conservative playbook for the next Republican president, issues an ultimatum for California: track and report abo...

4 hours ago

4 hours ago

Project 2025 to California: Report Abortion Data or Lose Billions in Medicaid

4 hours ago

Should California Community Colleges Offer Bachelor’s Degrees in Nursing? Universities Say No

10 hours ago

Bulldogs Pound a Lightweight, but a Heavyweight Looms in Two Weeks

22 hours ago

18,000 Miles Later, an American Woman Has Cycled the World

Bentley, a joyful and energetic supermutt with a unique blend of breeds, is seeking his forever home after spending a year with a rescue. (Mell's Mutts)
23 hours ago

Meet Bentley: The Athletic, Snuggly, Bright Eyed Supermutt Ready for Adoption

23 hours ago

How Hamas Uses Brutality to Maintain Power

1 day ago

A College Degree While Still in High School? More Valley Students Are Doing It

1 day ago

CHP Traffic Stop Bust Yields $1.3 Million Cocaine Seizure

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend