Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Oakland Needs Serious Leadership Changes. What About Bringing Back Jerry Brown?
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 12 seconds ago on
August 24, 2024

Dan Walters proposes a radical solution to Oakland's leadership crisis: bringing former mayor Jerry Brown out of retirement. (CalMatters/Max Whittaker)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

When author Gertrude Stein uttered the words “There’s no there there” about her hometown of Oakland, she did not intend it to be an insult, but rather a lament about nostalgia. Nevertheless, the phrase has been used — and abused — for decades to describe the city that faces the much more celebrated city across the bay, and is forever destined to exist in its shadow.

Dan Walters Profile Picture

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

Oakland and its 440,000 residents have fallen on particularly hard times of late. Just about everything bad that can happen to a city has plagued Oakland in recent years.

As Politico reported in a recent article chronicling the city’s woes, it spotlighted in painful detail, “Politicians facing recall votes. A crime surge that’s drawn Fox News fixation. Financial woes prompting the sale of the city’s baseball stadium. And that was before the FBI raided the mayor’s house.”

One could also add the loss of three major league sports teams and the city’s whopping budget deficit, born of irresponsible financial decisions, to Oakland’s list of issues.

Just a few years ago, the city seemed to be prospering as a less expensive alternative to San Francisco. But the COVID-19 pandemic took a toll and the city’s politics evolved into a loony left focused on identity politics and symbolism while good governance suffered.

Things got so bad, as Politico noted, that even two left-leaning officials, Gov. Gavin Newsom and Attorney General Rob Bonta, felt the need to intervene. They singled out Mayor Sheng Thao and Alameda County District Attorney Pamela Price, both of whom now face recall elections.

“Newsom, who has built a national profile ahead of a possible future presidential run, convened a meeting of business and community leaders earlier this year at which he repeatedly lamented Thao missing a state deadline to apply for state aid for fighting crime,” Politico reported. “He has also assailed Price for not accepting state assistance and pushed Thao to amend Oakland’s police chase policy, increasing the political pressure on two embattled officials.

“Oakland also has more direct implications for Bonta, a potential gubernatorial candidate who represented the city for years in the state Assembly, lives in neighboring Alameda and endorsed Thao early. Since then, he’s joined Newsom in dispatching more state law enforcement help to Oakland while seeking to distance himself from the family at the center of the FBI investigation.”

Given the negativity engulfing Oakland, Californians may wonder what could be done to get it back into shape.

Politics as usual — awaiting the recall election and otherwise allowing traditional processes to continue — won’t cut it. Oakland needs adult supervision, something akin to an intervention or a receivership that would make fundamental changes in how the city operates.

That’s what happened in 2003 when state officials took control of Oakland’s school district, which had worked itself into a financial crisis for many of the same reasons that the city government is in crisis now.

A Bold Proposal: Bring Back Jerry Brown

Here’s an off-the-wall suggestion: Oakland’s civic leadership, if it exists, should persuade former mayor and two-time Gov. Jerry Brown to interrupt his retirement and offer himself as a benevolent czar. He could be labeled a city manager with authority to cut through red tape, reorganize the city government, fire those who need to be fired and fix its deficit-ridden budget.

Brown was a very good mayor of Oakland two decades ago and he demonstrated an ability to handle crisis when he returned to the governorship in 2011. He might be the only person who could save Oakland from itself.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times.

CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more columns by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to bmcewen@gvwire.com for consideration.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Oakland Needs Serious Leadership Changes. What About Bringing Back Jerry Brown?

DON'T MISS

The ‘Joyful’ Democratic Convention Is Over. The Real Test for Kamala Harris’ Campaign Now Begins

DON'T MISS

California Woman Fed Up With Stolen Mail Sends Apple AirTag to Herself to Catch Thief

DON'T MISS

Pepito, The Ultimate Couch Potato Frenchie With a Taste for Reality TV, Awaits a Home

DON'T MISS

As Dyer Calls Housing a ‘Fundamental Right,’ State Threatens City for Killing North Fresno Project

DON'T MISS

Big 12 Leaders to Weigh UConn Invite After School’s Pitch: AP Sources

DON'T MISS

Iowa Man Indicted for Allegedly Distributing Videos of Monkey Torture and Abuse

DON'T MISS

South Carolina Sets Date for First Execution in More Than 13 Years

DON'T MISS

Fresno Journalist Lloyd Carter, Who Exposed Kesterson Environmental Disaster, Dies at 76

DON'T MISS

An Attack at a Festival in a German City Kills 3 People and Wounds 4 Seriously, Police Say

UP NEXT

The ‘Joyful’ Democratic Convention Is Over. The Real Test for Kamala Harris’ Campaign Now Begins

UP NEXT

California Woman Fed Up With Stolen Mail Sends Apple AirTag to Herself to Catch Thief

UP NEXT

Pepito, The Ultimate Couch Potato Frenchie With a Taste for Reality TV, Awaits a Home

UP NEXT

As Dyer Calls Housing a ‘Fundamental Right,’ State Threatens City for Killing North Fresno Project

UP NEXT

Iowa Man Indicted for Allegedly Distributing Videos of Monkey Torture and Abuse

UP NEXT

South Carolina Sets Date for First Execution in More Than 13 Years

UP NEXT

Fresno Journalist Lloyd Carter, Who Exposed Kesterson Environmental Disaster, Dies at 76

UP NEXT

An Attack at a Festival in a German City Kills 3 People and Wounds 4 Seriously, Police Say

UP NEXT

San Diego Padres Reinstate Yu Darvish From Restricted List

UP NEXT

On Truth Social, Donald Trump Tries to Refashion Himself as Supportive of Abortion Rights

Pepito, The Ultimate Couch Potato Frenchie With a Taste for Reality TV, Awaits a Home

1 hour ago

As Dyer Calls Housing a ‘Fundamental Right,’ State Threatens City for Killing North Fresno Project

13 hours ago

Big 12 Leaders to Weigh UConn Invite After School’s Pitch: AP Sources

13 hours ago

Iowa Man Indicted for Allegedly Distributing Videos of Monkey Torture and Abuse

14 hours ago

South Carolina Sets Date for First Execution in More Than 13 Years

14 hours ago

Fresno Journalist Lloyd Carter, Who Exposed Kesterson Environmental Disaster, Dies at 76

14 hours ago

An Attack at a Festival in a German City Kills 3 People and Wounds 4 Seriously, Police Say

14 hours ago

San Diego Padres Reinstate Yu Darvish From Restricted List

14 hours ago

On Truth Social, Donald Trump Tries to Refashion Himself as Supportive of Abortion Rights

15 hours ago

3 Detroit-Area Mall Guards Not Guilty of Involuntary Manslaughter in Man’s Death in 2014

15 hours ago

Oakland Needs Serious Leadership Changes. What About Bringing Back Jerry Brown?

13 seconds ago

14 seconds ago

Oakland Needs Serious Leadership Changes. What About Bringing Back Jerry Brown?

15 mins ago

The ‘Joyful’ Democratic Convention Is Over. The Real Test for Kamala Harris’ Campaign Now Begins

45 mins ago

California Woman Fed Up With Stolen Mail Sends Apple AirTag to Herself to Catch Thief

1 hour ago

Pepito, The Ultimate Couch Potato Frenchie With a Taste for Reality TV, Awaits a Home

13 hours ago

As Dyer Calls Housing a ‘Fundamental Right,’ State Threatens City for Killing North Fresno Project

13 hours ago

Big 12 Leaders to Weigh UConn Invite After School’s Pitch: AP Sources

14 hours ago

Iowa Man Indicted for Allegedly Distributing Videos of Monkey Torture and Abuse

14 hours ago

South Carolina Sets Date for First Execution in More Than 13 Years

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend