Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
CA Court Ruling Could Crack Down on Tactics to Delay or Block Housing Construction
By admin
Published 1 year ago on
February 23, 2024

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Assembly Bill 1633 aims to reduce CEQA delays in urban projects.

A recent court ruling could make it harder to use CEQA to stop projects.

The ruling could lead to a “judicial transformation of CEQA.”


California’s perpetual conflict over housing, pitting advocates of state-level pro-development policies against defenders of local government land use authority, has often involved friction between two state laws.

Dan Walters Profile Picture
Dan Walters
CalMatters
Opinion

One, the Housing Accountability Act, or HAA, aims to remove barriers to construction, while the older California Environmental Quality Act has been employed to delay or block specific projects.

One tactic used by local authorities to overcome the accountability law’s pro-housing provisions has been indefinitely delaying decisions on whether projects are eligible for CEQA clearance by demanding ever-more data from developers.

Last year, the Legislature, which has been strengthening HAA provisions in recent years, cracked down on CEQA delays by passing Assembly Bill 1633, carried by Assemblyman Phil Ting, a Democrat from San Francisco, where the tactic has often been employed. It decreed that excessive CEQA delays in high-density urban projects violate state law and subject officials to lawsuits.

While AB 1633 gives pro-housing advocates a new legal weapon, its applicability to only specific kinds of projects falls short of a wider overhaul of CEQA that some political figures have supported.

CEQA Reform Is “the Lord’s Work”: Jerry Brown

For instance, former Gov. Jerry Brown once described CEQA reform as “the Lord’s work” but was unwilling to take on the heavy political burden such changes would require. If politicians are unwilling to take on CEQA reform – which would draw opposition from environmental groups, and labor unions which invoke the law to demand agreements with developers – California’s courts may do the job.

This month, a state appellate court delivered a ruling that, if not overturned by the state Supreme Court, would make it much more difficult to use CEQA to stop projects that conform to local zoning laws.

The case involved a corporation, Hilltop Group Inc., that wanted to construct a facility to recycle construction debris on a site adjacent to Interstate 15 in northern San Diego County that had been designated for industrial uses in the county’s general plan.

The county’s staff declared that the North County Environmental Resources Project was entitled to a CEQA exemption because it met the criteria of the general plan, which had been certified as compatible with CEQA. However, when residents of the area and the city of Escondido opposed the facility, citing noise, traffic, and aesthetic impacts, the San Diego County Board of Supervisors declared that it needed more environmental mitigation under CEQA.

Hilltop sued and the county prevailed in the trial court, but a three-judge panel on the 4th District Court of Appeal unanimously declared that the county could not impose additional conditions because the project was compatible with the industrial zone the county created in its general plan.

Ruling Is Major Blow to Using CEQA as Delay Tactic

Chris Elmendorf, a UC Davis law professor who is the state’s foremost authority on development laws, says the appellate court ruling is a major blow to the tactic of using CEQA to delay projects of any kind – not just housing – that conform to the standards of pre-existing general plans.

It could be a “judicial transformation of CEQA (that) won’t be rendered ineffectual by project-labor, community-benefit or other everything bagel conditions,” Elmendorf remarked on X.

Elmendorf likens the appellate court decision to the Washington Legislature’s sweeping overhaul of its environmental quality act last year, also meant to minimize delays in housing development. It exempts zoning-compliant housing from further environmental review.

If the decision has the effect Elmendorf anticipates, one wonders whether those who have for years invoked CEQA on specific projects, particularly environmentalists and labor unions, will accept a changed legal climate or try to overturn the ruling through the Legislature.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more columns by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to bmcewen@gvwire.com for consideration.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Trump Admin Asserts COVID-19 Originated in Chinese Lab, Targets Fauci

DON'T MISS

Vendors Back at Fresno’s Art Hop? Survey Wants to Know What You Think

DON'T MISS

Russian Missile Attack Kills One, Wounds 112 in Ukraine’s Kharkiv, Officials Say

DON'T MISS

Iran Says Nuclear Deal Is Possible if Washington Is Realistic

DON'T MISS

49ers Look to Strengthen Depleted Defense in NFL Draft

DON'T MISS

Habit Burger & Grill Quietly Drops Impossible Burger From Menu

DON'T MISS

What Happens After a Homeless Person Is Arrested for Camping? Often, Not Much

DON'T MISS

Thousands of Pilgrims Trek Through New Mexico Desert to Historic Adobe Church for Good Friday

DON'T MISS

Rams’ Draft Headquarters to Be at LAFD Air Base to Honor First Responders to Wildfires

DON'T MISS

The US Has a Single Rare Earths Mine. Chinese Export Limits Are Energizing a Push for More

UP NEXT

Vendors Back at Fresno’s Art Hop? Survey Wants to Know What You Think

UP NEXT

Russian Missile Attack Kills One, Wounds 112 in Ukraine’s Kharkiv, Officials Say

UP NEXT

Iran Says Nuclear Deal Is Possible if Washington Is Realistic

UP NEXT

49ers Look to Strengthen Depleted Defense in NFL Draft

UP NEXT

Habit Burger & Grill Quietly Drops Impossible Burger From Menu

UP NEXT

What Happens After a Homeless Person Is Arrested for Camping? Often, Not Much

UP NEXT

Thousands of Pilgrims Trek Through New Mexico Desert to Historic Adobe Church for Good Friday

UP NEXT

Rams’ Draft Headquarters to Be at LAFD Air Base to Honor First Responders to Wildfires

UP NEXT

The US Has a Single Rare Earths Mine. Chinese Export Limits Are Energizing a Push for More

UP NEXT

A Startling Admission From a GOP Senator: ‘We Are All Afraid’

Iran Says Nuclear Deal Is Possible if Washington Is Realistic

29 minutes ago

49ers Look to Strengthen Depleted Defense in NFL Draft

1 hour ago

Habit Burger & Grill Quietly Drops Impossible Burger From Menu

1 hour ago

What Happens After a Homeless Person Is Arrested for Camping? Often, Not Much

2 hours ago

Thousands of Pilgrims Trek Through New Mexico Desert to Historic Adobe Church for Good Friday

2 hours ago

Rams’ Draft Headquarters to Be at LAFD Air Base to Honor First Responders to Wildfires

2 hours ago

The US Has a Single Rare Earths Mine. Chinese Export Limits Are Energizing a Push for More

2 hours ago

A Startling Admission From a GOP Senator: ‘We Are All Afraid’

2 hours ago

Trump Administration Kicks off Plan for Expanded Offshore Drilling

2 hours ago

Google to Appeal Against Part of US Court’s Decision in Monopoly Case

2 hours ago

Trump Admin Asserts COVID-19 Originated in Chinese Lab, Targets Fauci

The Trump administration launched a webpage Friday, which asserts that COVID-19 originated from a laboratory leak in China and accuses publi...

10 minutes ago

10 minutes ago

Trump Admin Asserts COVID-19 Originated in Chinese Lab, Targets Fauci

25 minutes ago

Vendors Back at Fresno’s Art Hop? Survey Wants to Know What You Think

Firefighters work at the site of a garment production factory hit by a Russian missile strike, amid Russia's attack on Ukraine, in Kharkiv, Ukraine April 18, 2025. (REUTERS/Stringer)
26 minutes ago

Russian Missile Attack Kills One, Wounds 112 in Ukraine’s Kharkiv, Officials Say

Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araqchi attends a press conference following a meeting with Russia's Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov in Moscow, Russia, April 18, 2025. (Tatyana Makeyeva/Pool via REUTERS)
29 minutes ago

Iran Says Nuclear Deal Is Possible if Washington Is Realistic

1 hour ago

49ers Look to Strengthen Depleted Defense in NFL Draft

Habit Burger & Grill has discontinued its Impossible Burger offerings but continues to offer vegetarian options like veggie patties, salads, and sides. (Shutterstock)
1 hour ago

Habit Burger & Grill Quietly Drops Impossible Burger From Menu

2 hours ago

What Happens After a Homeless Person Is Arrested for Camping? Often, Not Much

2 hours ago

Thousands of Pilgrims Trek Through New Mexico Desert to Historic Adobe Church for Good Friday

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend