Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Elon Musk Cannot Keep Tesla Pay Package Worth More Than $55 Billion, Judge Rules
gvw_ap_news
By Associated Press
Published 1 year ago on
January 31, 2024

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

DOVER, Del. — Elon Musk is not entitled to landmark compensation package awarded by Tesla’s board of directors that is potentially worth more than $55 billion, a Delaware judge ruled Tuesday.

The ruling by Chancellor Kathaleen St. Jude McCormick comes more than five years after a shareholder lawsuit targeted Tesla CEO Musk and directors of the company. They were accused of breaching their duties to the maker of electric vehicles and solar panels, resulting in a waste of corporate assets and unjust enrichment for Musk.

Shareholder’s Argument

The shareholder’s lawyers argued that the compensation package should be voided because it was dictated by Musk and was the product of sham negotiations with directors who were not independent of him. They also said it was approved by shareholders who were given misleading and incomplete disclosures in a proxy statement.

Defense attorneys countered that the pay plan was fairly negotiated by a compensation committee whose members were independent, contained performance milestones so lofty that they were ridiculed by some Wall Street investors, and blessed by a shareholder vote that was not even required under Delaware law. They also argued that Musk was not a controlling shareholder because he owned less than one-third of the company at the time.

An attorney for Musk and other other Tesla defendants did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment.

Musk’s Reaction

But Musk reacted to the ruling on X, the social media platform formerly know as Twitter that he owns, by offering business advice. “Never incorporate your company in the state of Delaware,” he said.

In trial testimony in November 2022, Musk denied that he dictated terms of the compensation package or attended any meetings at which the plan was discussed by the board, its compensation committee, or a working group that helped develop it.

Judge’s Ruling

McCormick determined, however, that because Musk was a controlling shareholder with a potential conflict of interest, the pay package must be subject to a more rigorous standard.

“The process leading to the approval of Musk’s compensation plan was deeply flawed,” McCormick wrote in the colorfully written 200-page decision. “Musk had extensive ties with the persons tasked with negotiating on Tesla’s behalf.”

McCormick specifically cited Musk’s long business and personal relationships with compensation committee chairman Ira Ehrenpreis and fellow committee member Antonio Gracias. She also noted that the working group working on the pay package included general counsel Todd Maron who was Musk’s former divorce attorney.

“In fact, Maron was a primary go-between Musk and the committee, and it is unclear on whose side Maron viewed himself,” the judge wrote. “Yet many of the documents cited by the defendants as proof of a fair process were drafted by Maron.”

McCormick concluded that the only suitable remedy was for Musk’s compensation package to be rescinded. “In the final analysis, Musk launched a self-driving process, recalibrating the speed and direction along the way as he saw fit,” she wrote. “The process arrived at an unfair price. And through this litigation, the plaintiff requests a recall.”

Greg Varallo, a lead attorney for the shareholder plaintiff, praised McCormick’s decision to reverse the “absurdly outsized” Musk pay package for Musk.

“The fact that they lost this in Delaware court, it’s a jaw dropper,” said Wedbush Securities analyst Dan Ives. “It’s unprecedented, a ruling like this. I think going in investors thought it was just typical legal noise and nothing was going to come out about it. The fact that they went head to head with Tesla and Musk and the board and voided this, it’s a huge legal decision.”

During his trial testimony, Musk downplayed the notion that his friendships with certain Tesla board members, including sometimes vacationing together, meant that they were likely to do his bidding.

Details of the Compensation Plan

The plan called for Musk to reap billions if Tesla hit certain market capitalization and operational milestones. For each incidence of simultaneously meeting a market cap milestone and an operational milestone, Musk, who owned about 22% of Tesla when the plan was approved, would get stock equal to 1% of outstanding shares at the time of the grant. His interest in the company would grow to about 28% if the company’s market capitalization grew by $600 billion.

Each milestone included growing Tesla’s market capitalization by $50 billion and meeting aggressive revenue and pretax profit growth targets. Musk stood to receive the full benefit of the pay plan, $55.8 billion, only by leading Tesla to a market capitalization of $650 billion and unprecedented revenues and earnings within a decade.

Tesla has achieved all twelve market capitalization milestones and eleven operational milestones, providing Musk nearly $28 billion in stock option gains, according to a January post-trial brief filed by the plaintiff’s attorneys. The stock option grants are subject to a five-year holding period, however.

Defense attorney Evan Chesler argued at trial that the compensation package was a “high-risk, high-reward” deal that benefitted not just Musk, but Tesla shareholders. After the plan was implemented, the value of the company, based in Austin, Texas, climbed from $53 billion to more than $800 billion, having briefly hit $1 trillion.

Chesler also said Tesla made sure that the $55 billion compensation figure was included in the proxy statement because the company wanted shareholders to know that “this was a heart-stopping number that Mr. Musk could earn.”

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Taylor Swift Has Regained Control of Her Music, Buys Back First 6 Albums

DON'T MISS

How the Trump’s Vow to Revoke Chinese Student Visas Could Hurt California

DON'T MISS

Speaker Johnson Raises Campaign Money in Fresno

DON'T MISS

2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs: Panthers-Oilers Final Rematch, Who Is Favored and What to Watch For

DON'T MISS

Visalia House Fire Causes Evacuations, Road Closures

DON'T MISS

Brunson, Towns Carry Knicks to Victory That Cuts Pacers’ Series Lead to 3-2

DON'T MISS

NY Times Bestselling Author Celebrating Book Release at Fresno Barnes & Noble

DON'T MISS

Dodgers Acquire Former All-Star Reliever Alexis Díaz in Trade With Cincinnati Reds

DON'T MISS

Christian McCaffrey Returns to 49ers Practice, Showing No Ill Effects From Injuries

DON'T MISS

Wall Street Falls as Trump Says China Violated Tariff Terms

UP NEXT

How the Trump’s Vow to Revoke Chinese Student Visas Could Hurt California

UP NEXT

Speaker Johnson Raises Campaign Money in Fresno

UP NEXT

2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs: Panthers-Oilers Final Rematch, Who Is Favored and What to Watch For

UP NEXT

Visalia House Fire Causes Evacuations, Road Closures

UP NEXT

Brunson, Towns Carry Knicks to Victory That Cuts Pacers’ Series Lead to 3-2

UP NEXT

NY Times Bestselling Author Celebrating Book Release at Fresno Barnes & Noble

UP NEXT

Dodgers Acquire Former All-Star Reliever Alexis Díaz in Trade With Cincinnati Reds

UP NEXT

Christian McCaffrey Returns to 49ers Practice, Showing No Ill Effects From Injuries

UP NEXT

Wall Street Falls as Trump Says China Violated Tariff Terms

UP NEXT

US Consumer Spending Slows in April, Inflation Benign

2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs: Panthers-Oilers Final Rematch, Who Is Favored and What to Watch For

40 minutes ago

Visalia House Fire Causes Evacuations, Road Closures

44 minutes ago

Brunson, Towns Carry Knicks to Victory That Cuts Pacers’ Series Lead to 3-2

46 minutes ago

NY Times Bestselling Author Celebrating Book Release at Fresno Barnes & Noble

57 minutes ago

Dodgers Acquire Former All-Star Reliever Alexis Díaz in Trade With Cincinnati Reds

60 minutes ago

Christian McCaffrey Returns to 49ers Practice, Showing No Ill Effects From Injuries

1 hour ago

Wall Street Falls as Trump Says China Violated Tariff Terms

2 hours ago

US Consumer Spending Slows in April, Inflation Benign

2 hours ago

US Supreme Court Lets Trump Revoke ‘Parole’ Status for Migrants

2 hours ago

Tulare County Man Convicted of Child Molestation During Burglary Faces Life Without Parole

17 hours ago

Taylor Swift Has Regained Control of Her Music, Buys Back First 6 Albums

NEW YORK — Taylor Swift has regained control over her entire body of work. In a lengthy note posted to her official website on Friday, Swift...

3 minutes ago

3 minutes ago

Taylor Swift Has Regained Control of Her Music, Buys Back First 6 Albums

4 minutes ago

How the Trump’s Vow to Revoke Chinese Student Visas Could Hurt California

12 minutes ago

Speaker Johnson Raises Campaign Money in Fresno

40 minutes ago

2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs: Panthers-Oilers Final Rematch, Who Is Favored and What to Watch For

44 minutes ago

Visalia House Fire Causes Evacuations, Road Closures

46 minutes ago

Brunson, Towns Carry Knicks to Victory That Cuts Pacers’ Series Lead to 3-2

57 minutes ago

NY Times Bestselling Author Celebrating Book Release at Fresno Barnes & Noble

60 minutes ago

Dodgers Acquire Former All-Star Reliever Alexis Díaz in Trade With Cincinnati Reds

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend