Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Appeal Court Rules City of Fresno Owes Measure P Backer $363K
By admin
Published 1 year ago on
December 28, 2023

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

The city of Fresno owes a Measure P backer hundreds of thousands of dollars, an appeal court ruled this week.

Lawyers representing the city unsuccessfully argued that Fresno’s municipal government did not oppose the measure and thus should be off the hook.

The 3-0 ruling by the Fresno-based Fifth District Court of Appeal said the city owes Fresno Building Healthy Communities $362,835.75 — and likely more with the added cost of the appeal. The case stems from a November 2018 ballot measure that earned 52.17% support for a sales tax measure for parks and the arts.

“Despite the City’s arguments to the contrary, it is clear that without the active participation of FBHC in this case, the City’s failure to declare Measure P passed would never have been litigated and determined to be incorrect. This is precisely the situation Code of Civil Procedure section 1021.5 was intended to address, and to not award reasonable attorney fees in this case would be contrary to its mandate,” Justice Mark Snauffer wrote, with justices Rosendo Pena Jr. and Kathleen Meehan concurring.

Although a majority of voters supported the proposal, the city declared at the time it needed two-thirds to pass — interpreting the accepted threshold for tax measures at the time. Thus, the Fresno City Council declared that Measure P failed.

Measure P supporter Fresno BHC sued, winning the argument on appeal that because the tax measure came to voters through an initiative process, the two-thirds requirement did not apply. The city began collecting the three-eighths of a percent tax in 2020.

Mayor Jerry Dyer’s office deferred comment to City Attorney Andrew Janz — who declined to comment on pending litigation. Messages to Fresno BHC and its attorneys were not returned.

The city could appeal the ruling to the state Supreme Court. That decision would come from the city council.

Battle Over Court Fees

The state Code of Civil Procedure 1021.5 allows a prevailing party to collect attorney fees. The city opposed Fresno BHC’s motion to recover, arguing mainly that the city was not an opposing party — the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association argued the case against Measure P. The city took a neutral position during the Measure P litigation.

Fresno County Superior Court Judge Kimberly Gaab ruled in the city’s favor. Once again, Fresno BHC appealed. Through a prior arrangement, Fresno BHC and HJTA agreed not to seek attorney fees from each other.

The Court of Appeal was not moved by the argument of neutrality.

“The City’s purported neutrality during litigation does not neutralize the City’s failure to declare Measure P passed, an error of constitutional dimension affecting the public interest. In this same vein, the City was clearly a losing party because new judgments were ultimately entered declaring that the City erred in failing to declare that Measure P had passed,” the appeal court wrote.

The appeal court also did not buy the city’s argument that Fresno BHC’s efforts were unnecessary, because the city sought judicial relief to answer the question of whether Measure P passed.

The appeal court wrote that the Superior Court’s ruling “that FBHC’s participation here was unnecessary was an abuse of discretion.”

In addition, the appeal court stated: “This argument implies that FBHC could have chosen not to participate and the ultimate result here would have been the same — that is, Measure P would have been declared passed. The record shows this is false. The City filed statements of neutrality in the trial court and in this court in the first appeal. Thus, without FBHC, there would have been no one to zealously argue the side against HJTA. And even with FBHC’s participation, HJTA still prevailed in the trial court.

“The City would not — and indeed did not — appeal the judgments declaring Measure P had failed. Had FBHC not participated in the trial court proceedings, it would not have had standing to appeal the erroneous judgments — no one could have appealed the erroneous judgments. FBHC also handled all of the appellate briefing for the pro-Measure P side, so to speak.”

If the case is not appealed to the Supreme Court, it would return to Fresno County Superior Court to determine the final attorney fees.

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

World Leaders React to US Attack on Iran

DON'T MISS

Congress Members Split Over US Attack on Iran

DON'T MISS

Investors Brace for Oil Price Spike, Rush to Havens After US Bombs Iran Nuclear Sites

DON'T MISS

Investors React to US Attack on Iran Nuclear Sites

DON'T MISS

Tulare County’s Colvin Fire Ignites With 80 Personnel on Scene

DON'T MISS

US B-2 Bombers Involved in Iran Strikes, U.S. Official Says

DON'T MISS

Trump Says Iran’s Key Nuclear Sites ‘Obliterated’ by Airstrikes

DON'T MISS

LA Dodgers Pledge $1 Million to Support Families Impacted by ICE Raids

DON'T MISS

Pakistan to Nominate Trump for Nobel Peace Prize

DON'T MISS

Vance, in Los Angeles, Says Troops Need to Stay, Blasts Newsom Over Immigration

UP NEXT

Congress Members Split Over US Attack on Iran

UP NEXT

Investors Brace for Oil Price Spike, Rush to Havens After US Bombs Iran Nuclear Sites

UP NEXT

Investors React to US Attack on Iran Nuclear Sites

UP NEXT

Tulare County’s Colvin Fire Ignites With 80 Personnel on Scene

UP NEXT

US B-2 Bombers Involved in Iran Strikes, U.S. Official Says

UP NEXT

Trump Says Iran’s Key Nuclear Sites ‘Obliterated’ by Airstrikes

UP NEXT

LA Dodgers Pledge $1 Million to Support Families Impacted by ICE Raids

UP NEXT

Pakistan to Nominate Trump for Nobel Peace Prize

UP NEXT

Vance, in Los Angeles, Says Troops Need to Stay, Blasts Newsom Over Immigration

UP NEXT

Nuclear Diplomacy Stuck, Israel Says It Killed Top Iran Commander

Investors React to US Attack on Iran Nuclear Sites

4 hours ago

Tulare County’s Colvin Fire Ignites With 80 Personnel on Scene

4 hours ago

US B-2 Bombers Involved in Iran Strikes, U.S. Official Says

5 hours ago

Trump Says Iran’s Key Nuclear Sites ‘Obliterated’ by Airstrikes

5 hours ago

LA Dodgers Pledge $1 Million to Support Families Impacted by ICE Raids

10 hours ago

Pakistan to Nominate Trump for Nobel Peace Prize

10 hours ago

Vance, in Los Angeles, Says Troops Need to Stay, Blasts Newsom Over Immigration

10 hours ago

Nuclear Diplomacy Stuck, Israel Says It Killed Top Iran Commander

10 hours ago

Mahmoud Khalil Vows to Resume Pro-Palestinian Activism After Release From US Jail

10 hours ago

Trump Says He Wants to Fund More Trade Schools. Just Not These.

10 hours ago

World Leaders React to US Attack on Iran

The reaction of world leaders after U.S. forces struck three Iranian nuclear sites on Sunday Iran time ranged from Israel lauding President ...

2 hours ago

Patrons of the Chapel Street Cafe watch as U.S. President Donald Trump delivers an address to the nation following U.S. strikes on Iran's nuclear facilities, in Chicago, Illinois, U.S. June 21, 2025. (Reuters/Dylan Martinez)
2 hours ago

World Leaders React to US Attack on Iran

The U.S. Capitol building is seen in Washington, U.S., December 1, 2023. (Reuters File)
3 hours ago

Congress Members Split Over US Attack on Iran

Emergency personnel work at an impact site following Iran's missile strike on Israel, amid the Iran-Israel conflict, in Haifa, Israel, June 20, 2025. (Reuters File)
3 hours ago

Investors Brace for Oil Price Spike, Rush to Havens After US Bombs Iran Nuclear Sites

President Donald Trump gestures next to a new flagpole with the U.S. flag after disembarking Marine One upon arrival at the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., June 21, 2025. (Reuters/Kevin Mohatt)
4 hours ago

Investors React to US Attack on Iran Nuclear Sites

A wildfire dubbed the Colvin Fire broke out Saturday near Woodlake in Tulare County, burning 46 acres with 0% containment and threatening two structures, according to CalFire. (CalFire)
4 hours ago

Tulare County’s Colvin Fire Ignites With 80 Personnel on Scene

5 hours ago

US B-2 Bombers Involved in Iran Strikes, U.S. Official Says

U.S. President Donald Trump delivers an address to the nation alongside U.S. Vice President JD Vance, U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio and U.S. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth at the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S., June 21, 2025, following U.S. strikes on Iran's nuclear facilities. REUTERS/Carlos Barria/Pool
5 hours ago

Trump Says Iran’s Key Nuclear Sites ‘Obliterated’ by Airstrikes

Oct 24, 2024; Los Angeles, CA, USA; General view of the centerfield plaza during media prior to game one of the World Series between the Los Angeles Dodgers and the New York Yankees at Dodger Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jayne Kamin-Oncea-Imagn Images/File Photo
10 hours ago

LA Dodgers Pledge $1 Million to Support Families Impacted by ICE Raids

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend