Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Will Judge Amy Coney Barrett Be a Solid Conservative Vote? 'There's No Guarantee' Says Law College Alum.
TLBBHMAP3-U010ALB5ANM-348f959abae2-512-300x300-1
By Jim Jakobs, Digital Producer
Published 5 years ago on
October 6, 2020

Share

When it comes to serving on the highest court in the land, nothing is guaranteed until it’s in writing.

GV Wire℠ spoke with Fresno attorney Mark King, an alum of the San Joaquin College of Law to gain his perspective.

King says history indicates that a Supreme Court justice’s personal life isn’t necessarily indicative of what their professional rulings will be.

Expectations Aren’t Guarantees

“She is expected to be a strong conservative voice on the court. Those expectations can sometimes be dashed by reality.”Fresno attorney Mark King, an alum of the San Joaquin College of Law

“She is expected to be a strong conservative voice on the court,” says King. “Those expectations can sometimes be dashed by reality.”

When asked if Barrett’s selection could reshape the court opinions to lean more conservative, King offers an intriguing assessment.

“There’s no guarantee that’s going to happen,” says King. “She could be more balanced. She could be more liberal on some issues than other people might dare to imagine.”

King explains there have been examples of a Supreme Court nominee bucking their supposed ideology.

Still Young in Her Career

Barrett has been on the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals for three years. King says there are two reasons presidents typically want to nominate someone who hasn’t been a judge for a very long time.

“They want someone young who will be on the court for a long time,” says King. “The less track record they have, the less controversy there will be over rulings they’ve made before.”

Critical of Chief Roberts

“She has been critical of Chief Justice John Roberts’ compromise that preserved Obamacare,” said King.

According to the South Bend Tribune, Barrett wrote in 2017 that Roberts pushed the Affordable Care Act beyond its plausible meaning in order to save it.

Devout Catholic

“There have been devout Catholics, for instance Justice (Anthony) Kennedy, who have ruled in ways that go against the teachings of the Catholic church,” explains King as he says her faith won’t necessarily dictate what she will or won’t do.

During her 2017 confirmation hearing for the federal appeals court, Barrett said she would separate her faith from her work as a judge.

“If you’re asking whether I take my faith seriously and I’m a faithful Catholic, I am,” Barrett responded during that hearing, “although I would stress that my personal church affiliation or my religious belief would not bear in the discharge of my duties as a judge.”

Roe V. Wade

“She has written in non-judicial writings that she thinks abortion is always immoral,” says King. He says some justices have ruled in favor of abortion rights, including Justice Kennedy, despite their personal feeling about the issue.

“We really do not know how her personal views would affect how she would rule on abortion rights as a supreme court justice,” adds King.

Did Not Side With Police

“One ruling last year some criminal defense attorneys encouragement was that she rejected a qualified immunity claim by a police officer,” says King. “That goes against what you would expect the conservative grain to be.”

Coney Barrett ruled on the qualified immunity case during her 7th Circuit Court tenure. Qualified immunity is a judicially created doctrine that shields government officials from being held personally liable for constitutional violations

In 2014, William Rainsberger was charged with the murder of his 88-year-old mother after she was found lying face down in her apartment with head injuries. Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department detective Charles Benner arrived at the crime scene shortly after the 911 call was placed.

Benner, according to court documents, attempted to charge Rainsberger before the results of that DNA test came back, but local prosecutors declined, citing a lack of evidence. Benner again went back to the prosecutor a few months later and omitted the DNA test that exonerated Rainsberger but instead used data from a cell tower to place Rainsberger at the scene.

Coney Barrett found that not only had Benner violated the Fourth Amendment, he’d outright lied in an attempt to charge Rainsberger. She allowed Rainsberger’s qualified immunity civil lawsuit against Benner to proceed, eventually ruling in favor of Rainsberger.

She Could Be a Surprise

“There have been some judges who have been surprises,” according to King. “President Dwight Eisenhower appointed Earl Warren to be Chief Justice. He thought Warren was going to be a stalwart conservative. Warren turned out to be a flaming liberal.”

King says another example is when President George H.W. Bush appointed David Souter and expected him to be a reliable conservative vote. “He turned out to be anything but that,” said King.

One more example King points to is Justice Neil Gorsuch. President Donald Trump’s first nominee to the Supreme Court, delivered an opinion in June to change how more than 7 million LGBTQ individuals will live and work in the United States.

CNN reported it was  a watershed moment from Gorsuch that means gay, lesbian and transgender workers are protected by federal civil rights law. “It is a stunning defeat for judicial conservatives who worked to ensure Gorsuch’s nomination and Republicans, including Donald Trump, who stymied President Barack Obama’s nominee for the Supreme Court, liberal Merrick Garland in 2016,” reported CNN.

Professor and Scholar

Kings says she gets, “very high marks for being a professor and a scholar.” He says her colleagues at the University of Notre Dame Law School respect her for her mind, her reasoning abilities, and no one can claim she’s not qualified to be a Supreme Court justice.

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Kim Kardashian Jewel Heist Trial Starts in Paris

DON'T MISS

NBA Playoff Guide: Who Plays When, How to Watch, What the Odds Are

DON'T MISS

Fresno Man Ejected, Killed in High-Speed Wreck Following Pursuit

DON'T MISS

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Naomi Kaylynn Acker

DON'T MISS

Conclave to Elect a New Pope Will Start on May 7 as Cardinals Get to Know One Another

DON'T MISS

California Faces Automaker Backlash Over 2035 Gas Car Ban

DON'T MISS

Wall Street Mixed in Start to Busy Week for Earnings, Data

DON'T MISS

Will California Meet Newsom’s 2035 EV Deadline? It Won’t Even Hit the 2026 Target 

DON'T MISS

Trump Says Putin May Not Want Peace and May Need to Be ‘Dealt With Differently’

DON'T MISS

Is It Bad to Chew Gum All Day?

UP NEXT

Trump Says Putin May Not Want Peace and May Need to Be ‘Dealt With Differently’

UP NEXT

Dollar Doubts Dominate Gathering of Global Economic Leaders

UP NEXT

US Judge Temporarily Stops West Texas Immigrant Deportations Under Alien Enemies Act

UP NEXT

Only About Half of Republicans Say Trump Has Focused on the Right Priorities

UP NEXT

Israeli Airstrike Kills 10 People, Half of Them Children

UP NEXT

Shedeur Sanders Is Still Waiting for a Call as the NFL Draft Enters the Final Day

UP NEXT

Israel’s AI Experiments in the War in Gaza Raise Ethical Concerns

UP NEXT

Paul Skenes Strikes Out 9, Wins Duel With Yamamoto in Pirates’ Victory Over Dodgers

UP NEXT

Eovaldi Outlasts Verlander as Rangers Beat Giants

UP NEXT

Rams Take Oregon Tight End Terrance Ferguson in Second Round After Trading Out of First

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Naomi Kaylynn Acker

31 minutes ago

Conclave to Elect a New Pope Will Start on May 7 as Cardinals Get to Know One Another

39 minutes ago

California Faces Automaker Backlash Over 2035 Gas Car Ban

45 minutes ago

Wall Street Mixed in Start to Busy Week for Earnings, Data

49 minutes ago

Will California Meet Newsom’s 2035 EV Deadline? It Won’t Even Hit the 2026 Target 

1 day ago

Trump Says Putin May Not Want Peace and May Need to Be ‘Dealt With Differently’

2 days ago

Is It Bad to Chew Gum All Day?

2 days ago

Dollar Doubts Dominate Gathering of Global Economic Leaders

2 days ago

US Judge Temporarily Stops West Texas Immigrant Deportations Under Alien Enemies Act

2 days ago

Shedeur Sanders’ Long Wait Ends When Browns Take Him in the 5th Round of the NFL Draft

2 days ago

Kim Kardashian Jewel Heist Trial Starts in Paris

PARIS (Reuters) – A group of men dubbed the “grandpa gang” were among 10 suspects who went on trial on Monday on charges o...

3 minutes ago

Kim Kardashian arrives at the Vanity Fair Oscars party after the 97th Academy Awards, in Beverly Hills, California, U.S., March 2, 2025. (REUTERS/Danny Moloshok/File Photo)
3 minutes ago

Kim Kardashian Jewel Heist Trial Starts in Paris

Indiana Pacers' Myles Turner (33) reacts after dunking over Milwaukee Bucks' Giannis Antetokounmpo during the second half of Game 4 of a first-round NBA basketball playoff series Sunday, April 27, 2025, in Milwaukee. (AP/Jeffrey Phelps)
8 minutes ago

NBA Playoff Guide: Who Plays When, How to Watch, What the Odds Are

fresno
16 minutes ago

Fresno Man Ejected, Killed in High-Speed Wreck Following Pursuit

Naomi Kaylynn Acker is Valley Crime Stoppers' Most Wanted Person of the Day for April 28, 2025. (Valley Crimes Stoppers)
31 minutes ago

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Naomi Kaylynn Acker

St Peter's Basilica is seen in the background as a cardinal arrives for a college of cardinals' meeting, at the Vatican, Monday, April 28, 2025. (AP Photo/Gregorio Borgia)
39 minutes ago

Conclave to Elect a New Pope Will Start on May 7 as Cardinals Get to Know One Another

People charge their electric cars at a Tesla super charging station next to an EVgo electric charging location in Carlsbad, California, U.S., March 7, 2022. (REUTERS/Mike Blake)
45 minutes ago

California Faces Automaker Backlash Over 2035 Gas Car Ban

A woman walks down Wall Street in New York City, U.S., April 8, 2025. (REUTERS/Kylie Cooper)
49 minutes ago

Wall Street Mixed in Start to Busy Week for Earnings, Data

1 day ago

Will California Meet Newsom’s 2035 EV Deadline? It Won’t Even Hit the 2026 Target 

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend