Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: Old Tax Loopholes Live Again
dan_walters
By Dan Walters, CalMatters Commentary
Published 6 years ago on
August 28, 2019

Share

Everything old is new again, at least when it comes to punching loopholes in state tax laws to benefit corporate interests.
As noted in a recent column, legislation is moving to re-establish “redevelopment” in California cities, albeit with a new name, just a few years after the program was eliminated.


Dan Walters
CALmatters

Opinion
It’s a way for local officials to subsidize certain kinds of businesses with property tax funds that would otherwise go to schools, thus forcing the state to backfill school money. The program was plagued by misuse and there’s no particular reason to believe it won’t be again, if it’s resurrected.
Former Gov. Jerry Brown persuaded the Legislature to eliminate redevelopment as a response to a severe budget crisis he inherited after returning to the governorship in 2011.
He also took aim at another tax boondoggle called “enterprise zones” that offered tax breaks to businesses that invested in designated poverty-ridden neighborhoods.
Critics, however, said while the program drained money from the state treasury, there was no evidence that it provided any net benefit.

Bottom Line: A Lot of Taxpayer Money Was Being Handed to Businesses

“Most rigorous research has found that EZs do not create a net increase in jobs or increase the rate of job creation,” the Legislature’s budget analyst concluded in 2011 as it endorsed their elimination.
Two years later, Brown finally persuaded the Legislature to act, but he had to sweeten the deal with a replacement program of direct subsidies to some businesses that created new jobs.
However, the legislative analyst later examined the replacement and found that 35% of the awards, representing 15% of the dollar value, went to businesses that sold goods and services nearby, therefore generating little or no gain in economic activity for the state as a whole.
Another 65% of the awards and 85% of the money went to firms that marketed both in and out of the state, but the LAO said it was impossible to determine whether the subsidies had any net positive effect.
Bottom line: a lot of taxpayer money was being handed to businesses without any objective evidence that it was doing anything other than improving their bottom lines.
Moreover, Brown championed another tax break specifically for the motion picture industry that the legislative analyst also criticized.
Undeterred by the lack of beneficial evidence, Brown’s successor, Gavin Newsom, is proposing a new program of enterprise zones, now dubbed “opportunity zones.”

The State’s Tax Codes Are Already Riddled With Loopholes

The recent federal tax overhaul, signed by President Donald Trump, coined the new title, offering hefty corporate income tax breaks for investment in the newly designated zones, including 879 in 57 of California’s 58 counties.

Don’t hold your breath. Politicians love to give out goodies to influential interest groups.
Newsom wants the Legislature to piggyback on the federal tax loophole, giving $100 million in state tax breaks to businesses that invest in low-cost housing or “green tech” in the zones.
In governmental circles, loopholes that benefit specific activities are called “tax expenditures,” and for good reason. They have precisely the same fiscal effect as direct appropriations in the budget, but are not subject to the same scrutiny as direct expenditures.
The state’s tax codes are already riddled with loopholes costing tens of billions of dollars a year. We’d all be better off if the narrowest ones, such as the handout to movie producers or the sales tax exemption for custom software programs, were eliminated and the money used for the broader welfare, such as education.
But don’t hold your breath. Politicians love to give out goodies to influential interest groups.
CalMatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.
[activecampaign form=31]

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

Hey PG&E Customers, Get Ready for New ‘Transaction Fees’

DON'T MISS

Fresno County Ending ‘Squaw Valley’ Fight After Latest Court Ruling

DON'T MISS

Exclusive: Tesla to Delay US Launch of Affordable EV, a Lower-Cost Model Y, Sources Say

DON'T MISS

Clovis Reconsiders Recycling Vote. Will a Campaign Contribution Matter?

DON'T MISS

Gov. Newsom Offers $50K Reward in 2022 Kings County Homicide

DON'T MISS

Trump’s White House Launches COVID Website That Criticizes WHO, Fauci and Biden

DON'T MISS

Fresno ‘Powers Up’ the Nation’s Largest Combined Solar and Battery Storage Project

DON'T MISS

Trump Admin Asserts COVID-19 Originated in Chinese Lab, Targets Fauci

DON'T MISS

Vendors Back at Fresno’s Art Hop? Survey Wants to Know What You Think

DON'T MISS

Russian Missile Attack Kills One, Wounds 112 in Ukraine’s Kharkiv, Officials Say

UP NEXT

Why Is It So Expensive to Build Affordable Homes in CA? It Takes Too Long

UP NEXT

What Some Animals Endure Before We Eat Them

UP NEXT

Zakaria Warns of ‘Crony Capitalism’ in Trump’s Tariff Reversal

UP NEXT

How California Can Reduce High Concession Prices in Its Taxpayer-Funded Stadiums

UP NEXT

Why Palestinian Christians Feel Betrayed by American Christians

UP NEXT

Other States Do Housing Better Than California; a New Study Shows How They Do It

UP NEXT

Trump and Netanyahu Steer Toward an Ugly World, Together

UP NEXT

New Plan to Accelerate CA High-Speed Rail Construction Deserves Attention, Support

UP NEXT

Why Did So Many People Delude Themselves About Trump?

UP NEXT

LA Feud Is Prime Example of Constant Clashes Between CA Cities and Counties

Clovis Reconsiders Recycling Vote. Will a Campaign Contribution Matter?

4 hours ago

Gov. Newsom Offers $50K Reward in 2022 Kings County Homicide

4 hours ago

Trump’s White House Launches COVID Website That Criticizes WHO, Fauci and Biden

5 hours ago

Fresno ‘Powers Up’ the Nation’s Largest Combined Solar and Battery Storage Project

5 hours ago

Trump Admin Asserts COVID-19 Originated in Chinese Lab, Targets Fauci

6 hours ago

Vendors Back at Fresno’s Art Hop? Survey Wants to Know What You Think

6 hours ago

Russian Missile Attack Kills One, Wounds 112 in Ukraine’s Kharkiv, Officials Say

6 hours ago

Iran Says Nuclear Deal Is Possible if Washington Is Realistic

6 hours ago

49ers Look to Strengthen Depleted Defense in NFL Draft

6 hours ago

Habit Burger & Grill Quietly Drops Impossible Burger From Menu

7 hours ago

Hey PG&E Customers, Get Ready for New ‘Transaction Fees’

Pacific Gas & Electric customers are already paying some of the nation’s highest rates for electricity, and their bills could be g...

3 hours ago

3 hours ago

Hey PG&E Customers, Get Ready for New ‘Transaction Fees’

3 hours ago

Fresno County Ending ‘Squaw Valley’ Fight After Latest Court Ruling

Tesla Inc. vehicle facility is pictured in Costa Mesa, California, U.S., November 1, 2023. (REUTERS/Mike Blake/File Photo)
3 hours ago

Exclusive: Tesla to Delay US Launch of Affordable EV, a Lower-Cost Model Y, Sources Say

4 hours ago

Clovis Reconsiders Recycling Vote. Will a Campaign Contribution Matter?

California Gov. Gavin Newsom speaks during a press conference in Los Angeles, Wednesday, Sept. 25, 2024. Newsom vetoed a landmark bill aimed at establishing first-in-the-nation safety measures for large artificial intelligence models Sunday, Sept. 29. (AP Photo/Eric Thayer, File)
4 hours ago

Gov. Newsom Offers $50K Reward in 2022 Kings County Homicide

The logo of the World Health Organization is seen at the WHO headquarters in Geneva, Switzerland, January 28, 2025. (REUTERS/Denis Balibouse/File Photo)
5 hours ago

Trump’s White House Launches COVID Website That Criticizes WHO, Fauci and Biden

5 hours ago

Fresno ‘Powers Up’ the Nation’s Largest Combined Solar and Battery Storage Project

6 hours ago

Trump Admin Asserts COVID-19 Originated in Chinese Lab, Targets Fauci

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend