Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Fresno Judge Is Latest to Rule New Murder Law Unconstitutional
Bill McEwen updated website photo 2024
By Bill McEwen, News Director
Published 6 years ago on
June 19, 2019

Share

Fresno County Superior Court Judge Brian Alvarez has ruled that a change made by the Legislature to the state’s felony murder law is unconstitutional.
His ruling adds to the growing divide about whether SB 1437, which was signed into law last year by Gov. Jerry Brown, violates the state constitution.


“While this (law) is well-intentioned, as it is written, it is deeply flawed and poses a significant risk to the safety of our communities.” — Fresno County DA Lisa Smittcamp
Some California judges have ruled the law constitutional. Others have not. And some district attorney offices  — San Francisco County, for example —aren’t opposing inmates’ petitions.
Legal experts predict that the California Supreme Court will have the final say on SB 1437.
The Fresno County District Attorney’s Office said in a news release Wednesday that it has received nearly 100 petitions from inmates seeking to have murder sentences changed based on SB 1437.

Judge Dismisses Petition by Convicted Murderer

In a written ruling Wednesday, Alvarez dismissed a petition filed by Charles Jones to have his first-degree murder conviction reversed and his sentence reduced.
Alvarez found that SB 1437 unconstitutionally amended Proposition 7 which was approved by 71% of voters in 1978, and Proposition 115, which was passed by 57% of voters in 1990.
Proposition 7 (Death Penalty Act) expanded the instances in which the death penalty or life sentences without the possibility of parole could be ordered. Proposition 115 (Crime Victims Justice Reform Act) expanded the definition of first-degree murder to cover additional circumstances.

Skinner Wrote SB 1437

State Sen. Nancy Skinner, a Democrat representing the East Bay, authored SB 1437, which restricted the culpability of those who aided and abetted a felony murder. The law also allowed those convicted of murder to petition the court to have their convictions reversed and their sentences reduced.
If Alvarez had granted Jones’ petition, his sentence would have been reduced to five years, and he would have been immediately released from prison.
A jury convicted Jones of first-degree murder in 1993 in the gunshot killing of Abdo Ahmed Ali during a robbery of the Westside Market the previous year. Jones received a life sentence without the possibility of parole. His subsequent appeals of the conviction and sentence failed.

Smittcamp and 41 Other DAs Opposed SB 1437

Fresno County DA Lisa Smittcamp and 41 other county district attorneys asked Brown to veto the bill last September.
“While this bill is well-intentioned, as it is written, it is deeply flawed and poses a significant risk to the safety of our communities,” Smittcamp and the other DAs told Brown in a letter.

About Judge Alvarez

Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger appointed Alvarez to the bench in 2009. He is a military veteran who worked in the Fresno County DA’s office as an investigator and returned as a prosecutor after graduating from San Joaquin College of Law. He served seven years in the state Attorney General’s Office, rising to a supervising attorney before becoming a judge.
 

DON'T MISS

What Are Fresno Real Estate Experts Predicting for 2025 and Beyond?

DON'T MISS

First California EV Mandates Hit Automakers This Year. Most Are Not Even Close

DON'T MISS

California Proposes Allowing Testing of Self-Driving Heavy-Duty Trucks

DON'T MISS

Higher Taxes on Millionaires? Trump Says He’s Open, but Many in His Party Are Not

DON'T MISS

Ex-US Rep. George Santos Sentenced to Over 7 Years in Prison for Fraud and Identity Theft

DON'T MISS

Selma Mayor Charged With Electioneering Violation on Election Day

DON'T MISS

Fresno Air Improves. Where Does It Rank in the US?

DON'T MISS

As Harris Ponders Run for CA Governor, Is She Prepared for the Daunting Job?

DON'T MISS

Stocks Rise With Tech-Related Shares, Notch Weekly Gains; Dollar Up

DON'T MISS

Conflicting US-China Talks Statements Add to Global Trade Confusion

DON'T MISS

Driving Near the Fresno Airport Next Week? Plan for Road Closures

DON'T MISS

Misty Her: Push for Fresno Unified Turnaround Starts Now With ‘Boots on the Ground’

UP NEXT

Selma Mayor Charged With Electioneering Violation on Election Day

UP NEXT

Fresno Air Improves. Where Does It Rank in the US?

UP NEXT

Driving Near the Fresno Airport Next Week? Plan for Road Closures

UP NEXT

Fresno Man Arrested in 2004 Cold Case Rape and Murder

UP NEXT

Valley Crime Stoppers’ Most Wanted Person of the Day: Willie Ray Butler

UP NEXT

California’s Economy Ranks Fourth Worldwide, Surpasses Japan

UP NEXT

Fresno Ranks Fourth in US for an Affordable Night Out

UP NEXT

Fresno Man Tased, Arrested After Suspected Reckless DUI in Kerman

UP NEXT

Madera Vehicle Burglary Leads to Arrests, Gang Charges for Juveniles

UP NEXT

Why Texas Is Ahead of California on Bilingual Education

Bill McEwen,
News Director
Bill McEwen is news director and columnist for GV Wire. He joined GV Wire in August 2017 after 37 years at The Fresno Bee. With The Bee, he served as Opinion Editor, City Hall reporter, Metro columnist, sports columnist and sports editor through the years. His work has been frequently honored by the California Newspapers Publishers Association, including authoring first-place editorials in 2015 and 2016. Bill and his wife, Karen, are proud parents of two adult sons, and they have two grandsons. You can contact Bill at 559-492-4031 or at Send an Email

Selma Mayor Charged With Electioneering Violation on Election Day

1 hour ago

Fresno Air Improves. Where Does It Rank in the US?

2 hours ago

As Harris Ponders Run for CA Governor, Is She Prepared for the Daunting Job?

2 hours ago

Stocks Rise With Tech-Related Shares, Notch Weekly Gains; Dollar Up

3 hours ago

Conflicting US-China Talks Statements Add to Global Trade Confusion

3 hours ago

Driving Near the Fresno Airport Next Week? Plan for Road Closures

3 hours ago

Misty Her: Push for Fresno Unified Turnaround Starts Now With ‘Boots on the Ground’

3 hours ago

Fresno Police Arrest 17 in Domestic Violence Crackdown

3 hours ago

What’s Next for Fresno Smoke Shop Ordinance: Lawsuit, Veto, Override?

4 hours ago

Visalia Man Sentenced to Life in Prison for 2019 Fatal Stabbing

5 hours ago

California Proposes Allowing Testing of Self-Driving Heavy-Duty Trucks

LOS ANGELES — California regulators have released a new proposal to allow the testing of self-driving heavy duty trucks on public roads. The...

41 minutes ago

41 minutes ago

California Proposes Allowing Testing of Self-Driving Heavy-Duty Trucks

47 minutes ago

Higher Taxes on Millionaires? Trump Says He’s Open, but Many in His Party Are Not

50 minutes ago

Ex-US Rep. George Santos Sentenced to Over 7 Years in Prison for Fraud and Identity Theft

Selma Mayor Scott Robertson (left) has been charged with misdemeanor electioneering for allegedly campaigning near voters at a polling place during the November 2024 election. (Facebook)
1 hour ago

Selma Mayor Charged With Electioneering Violation on Election Day

2 hours ago

Fresno Air Improves. Where Does It Rank in the US?

2 hours ago

As Harris Ponders Run for CA Governor, Is She Prepared for the Daunting Job?

3 hours ago

Stocks Rise With Tech-Related Shares, Notch Weekly Gains; Dollar Up

A drone view shows containers at the terminals at the port in Kwai Chung in Hong Kong, China, April 3, 2025. (REUTERS/Tyrone Siu/File Photo)
3 hours ago

Conflicting US-China Talks Statements Add to Global Trade Confusion

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend