Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Walters: Should California Make It Easier to Practice Law?
By admin
Published 6 years ago on
December 19, 2018

Share

Does California have too many lawyers, or too few?


Opinion
by Dan Walters
CALmatters Commentary

The passage rate on the State Bar’s July test, released in November, plummeted to an all-time low of 40.7 percent, which Tani Cantil-Sakauye, chief justice of the state Supreme Court, described as “frightening” last week.
That’s the unspoken question underlying a complicated debate within California’s legal community over whether the examination that would-be attorneys must pass to be licensed is too difficult.
The passage rate on the State Bar’s July test, released in November, plummeted to an all-time low of 40.7 percent, which Tani Cantil-Sakauye, chief justice of the state Supreme Court, described as “frightening” last week.
California’s minimum score on the test is the nation’s second highest and as the passage rate has declined year after year, critics have called for lowering the “cut score,” as it’s known, thereby allowing more law school graduates to be admitted to the bar.
The loudest complaints come from deans of the state’s 21 accredited law schools, some of which are in danger of losing their accreditation because too few of their graduates are passing the State Bar’s exam.
The American Bar Association, which accredits law schools, has been cracking down on schools whose graduates have high failure rates. Losing accreditation would be an institutional death sentence.

Supreme Court Has Declined to Lower the Cut Score

“We recognize that some critics blame us for this situation,” three of those deans wrote in a Los Angeles Times op-ed article last month, after the latest passage rate was announced.

“It is more plausible to hypothesize that the bar exam has grown anachronistic, a test designed for a paper-and-pencil generation now inflicted on a smartphone generation.”deans of the state’s accredited law schools
“They say that we are admitting students to law schools who are not adequately qualified. From 2010 to 2017 there was a decline in LSAT scores and undergraduate GPAs of admitted law students in California and nationally, and there is undoubtedly some correlation between those metrics and performance on the bar exam, as well as in law school. However, while this may explain some of the recent decline in bar passage rates, it does not explain most of it, nor does this provide any legitimate reason for keeping California’s cut score so much higher than other states’.
“It is more plausible to hypothesize that the bar exam has grown anachronistic, a test designed for a paper-and-pencil generation now inflicted on a smartphone generation. Memorizing large amounts of information and regurgitating it over a few days has little predictive power for lawyering competence today. Recent graduates may well be worse than their predecessors at this skill set — likely we all are — but they may be at least as good at other problem-solving skills lawyers need.”
So far, however, the state Supreme Court, which has the ultimate say over the issue, has declined to lower the cut score, awaiting results of two State Bar studies. One assesses California law school students, and the other weighs what skills contemporary lawyers need and how those traits can be tested.

Not Much Enthusiasm for Change in the Legal Community

“We know we still need to take a look, and we’re waiting for those (studies’) results to come in. And then we’ll sit around this table, all seven of us, and we’ll talk about these results and whether or not we should lower the exam score.” —  Tani Cantil-Sakauye, chief justice of the state Supreme Court
“We know we still need to take a look, and we’re waiting for those (studies’) results to come in,” Cantil-Sakauye told legal affairs reporters who asked about the low passage rate during a joint interview. “And then we’ll sit around this table, all seven of us, and we’ll talk about these results and whether or not we should lower the exam score.”
While the law school deans push for lowering the State Bar’s cut score, there’s not much enthusiasm for change in the larger legal community.
When the State Bar conducted an on-line survey of its members about the issue, nearly 80 percent voted in favor of leaving the cut score at its present level.
One might surmise that those who have passed the test and are practicing law aren’t interested in having even more attorneys competing for legal business.
CALmatters is a public interest journalism venture committed to explaining how California’s state Capitol works and why it matters. For more stories by Dan Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

DON'T MISS

Judge Dismisses Corruption Case Against New York City Mayor Eric Adams

DON'T MISS

State Center Trustees Render Split Decision on Future of PLAs

DON'T MISS

California’s Schools Chief Has a $200,000 Salary and a Side Gig

DON'T MISS

Why Project Labor Agreements Are Good for Our Schools and Students: Opinion

DON'T MISS

Trump Proposes Tax Deduction for Auto Loan Interest on US-Made Cars

DON'T MISS

Western US Sees Sharp Increase in Extreme Weather Impact

DON'T MISS

Amazon Said to Make a Bid to Buy TikTok in the US

DON'T MISS

Fresno Man Found Dead, Coroner’s Office Seeks Help Finding Family

DON'T MISS

The ‘Six’ Wives of King Henry VIII Sing Their Hearts Out in Fresno

DON'T MISS

7-Year-Old Girl Was Killed by a Falling Boulder at a Lake Tahoe Ski Resort

UP NEXT

State Center Trustees Render Split Decision on Future of PLAs

UP NEXT

California’s Schools Chief Has a $200,000 Salary and a Side Gig

UP NEXT

Why Project Labor Agreements Are Good for Our Schools and Students: Opinion

UP NEXT

Trump Proposes Tax Deduction for Auto Loan Interest on US-Made Cars

UP NEXT

Western US Sees Sharp Increase in Extreme Weather Impact

UP NEXT

Amazon Said to Make a Bid to Buy TikTok in the US

UP NEXT

Fresno Man Found Dead, Coroner’s Office Seeks Help Finding Family

UP NEXT

7-Year-Old Girl Was Killed by a Falling Boulder at a Lake Tahoe Ski Resort

UP NEXT

Musk Could Be Headed for a Washington Exit After Turbulent Times at Trump’s DOGE

UP NEXT

Outrage Grows Over Maryland Man’s Mistaken Deportation to El Salvador Prison

Why Project Labor Agreements Are Good for Our Schools and Students: Opinion

1 hour ago

Trump Proposes Tax Deduction for Auto Loan Interest on US-Made Cars

2 hours ago

Western US Sees Sharp Increase in Extreme Weather Impact

2 hours ago

Amazon Said to Make a Bid to Buy TikTok in the US

2 hours ago

Fresno Man Found Dead, Coroner’s Office Seeks Help Finding Family

2 hours ago

The ‘Six’ Wives of King Henry VIII Sing Their Hearts Out in Fresno

2 hours ago

7-Year-Old Girl Was Killed by a Falling Boulder at a Lake Tahoe Ski Resort

2 hours ago

Musk Could Be Headed for a Washington Exit After Turbulent Times at Trump’s DOGE

2 hours ago

Outrage Grows Over Maryland Man’s Mistaken Deportation to El Salvador Prison

3 hours ago

Kings County Chase Ends in Meth Arrest, but Deputies Are Looking for Driver

3 hours ago

Judge Dismisses Corruption Case Against New York City Mayor Eric Adams

NEW YORK — A federal judge dismissed New York City Mayor Eric Adams’ corruption case on Wednesday, agreeing it was the only practical ...

7 minutes ago

7 minutes ago

Judge Dismisses Corruption Case Against New York City Mayor Eric Adams

9 minutes ago

State Center Trustees Render Split Decision on Future of PLAs

54 minutes ago

California’s Schools Chief Has a $200,000 Salary and a Side Gig

West Fresno satellite campus of Fresno City College
1 hour ago

Why Project Labor Agreements Are Good for Our Schools and Students: Opinion

2 hours ago

Trump Proposes Tax Deduction for Auto Loan Interest on US-Made Cars

A new Gallup poll shows that extreme weather events have sharply increased in the Western U.S., with 43% of residents affected, largely due to wildfires and extreme heat, while concerns about climate change continue to rise. (Shutterstock AI)
2 hours ago

Western US Sees Sharp Increase in Extreme Weather Impact

An Amazon distribution facility in Garner, N.C., on Feb. 8, 2025. Amazon has reportedly put in a last-minute bid to acquire all of TikTok, the popular video app, as it approaches an April deadline to be separated from its Chinese owner or face a ban in the United States, according to three people familiar with the bid. (Kate Medley/The New York Times)
2 hours ago

Amazon Said to Make a Bid to Buy TikTok in the US

The Fresno County Sheriff’s Coroner’s Office is asking for public assistance in locating the family of 60-year-old Jonathan Scott, who passed away from natural causes on March 17, 2025. (Fresno County SO)
2 hours ago

Fresno Man Found Dead, Coroner’s Office Seeks Help Finding Family

Help continue the work that gets you the news that matters most.

Search

Send this to a friend