Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Sick of the Electoral College? Stop Whining.
d8a347b41db1ddee634e2d67d08798c102ef09ac
By The New York Times
Published 1 month ago on
September 29, 2024

Gail Collins discusses the frustration with the Electoral College, explaining its convoluted origins and how it diminishes the impact of votes from states like New York in presidential elections, ultimately urging readers to blame the flawed system rather than swing states. (Shutterstock)

Share

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Opinion by Gail Collins on Sept. 26, 2024.

Dear Help Person,

I live in New York and nobody cares how I vote in the big, huge, potentially history-changing presidential race. All because of the Electoral College! Why do we have that thing and how can we get rid of it?

— Wants to Live in Pennsylvania

Dear Wants: Stop whining. True, the only people poll-watchers will really pay attention to are from a handful of states where the political division is very close. Nobody cares if about 2 million New Yorkers cast votes for Kamala Harris because nobody cares about the popular vote.

Snap question: Who won the popular vote in 2016?

Answer: Hillary Clinton, by about 2.9 million. But she lost a few states, including Michigan and Wisconsin, by itsy-bitsy margins, and that knocked her out of the White House. Blame the Electoral College.

How did we get stuck with this thing?

The Electoral College was created at the nation’s constitutional convention after a long, long struggle. Led by the Committee of Unfinished Parts.

Wait a minute. The committee of what?

Yeah, that’s the story. The founding fathers couldn’t decide whether the president should be elected by Congress or state legislatures, the people, or something else. They finally settled on something else.

“They squished it all together,” said Robert Alexander, an expert on the Electoral College at Bowling Green State University. Alexander likes to explain that the founders’ solution “looks like Frankenstein’s monster.”

These were the same guys who gave the power to do everything from trying impeachments to confirming members of the Supreme Court to the Senate, in which California and Wyoming have exactly the same number of votes despite the fact that California’s population is approximately 68 times as large.

What can I tell you, people? True, a lot of you are going to feel cranky when you diligently go to the polls on Election Day, say hello to all your neighbor-voters, and then go home to watch the whole world hanging on their fingernails to see what people who live in Pennsylvania and Arizona decide.

But don’t blame the swing states. Blame the Committee of Unfinished Parts.

This article originally appeared in The New York Times.
c. 2024 The New York Times Company

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

Beyoncé Makes Grammy History With ‘Cowboy Carter,’ Leading 2025 Nominations

DON'T MISS

Macklin Celebrini, NHL’s Youngest Player, Scores on Marc-Andre Fleury, League’s Oldest

DON'T MISS

Ramsey, Beckham Return to SoFi Stadium When the Struggling Dolphins Visit the Streaking Rams

DON'T MISS

San Francisco’s First Black Female Mayor Concedes to Levi Strauss Heir

DON'T MISS

FBI Thwarts Iranian Murder-for-Hire Plan Targeting Donald Trump

DON'T MISS

Israeli Soccer Fans Were Attacked in Amsterdam. The Violence Was Condemned as Antisemitic

DON'T MISS

Longtime Dodgers Ace Clayton Kershaw Is on the Mend After 2 Surgeries

DON'T MISS

USDA Bans School Lunch Fees for Low-Income Families

DON'T MISS

Christian McCaffrey Expected to Make Season Debut for 49ers This Week

DON'T MISS

Southern California Wildfire Destroys 132 Structures as Officials Look for Fierce Winds to Subside

UP NEXT

Macklin Celebrini, NHL’s Youngest Player, Scores on Marc-Andre Fleury, League’s Oldest

UP NEXT

Ramsey, Beckham Return to SoFi Stadium When the Struggling Dolphins Visit the Streaking Rams

UP NEXT

San Francisco’s First Black Female Mayor Concedes to Levi Strauss Heir

UP NEXT

FBI Thwarts Iranian Murder-for-Hire Plan Targeting Donald Trump

UP NEXT

Israeli Soccer Fans Were Attacked in Amsterdam. The Violence Was Condemned as Antisemitic

UP NEXT

Longtime Dodgers Ace Clayton Kershaw Is on the Mend After 2 Surgeries

UP NEXT

USDA Bans School Lunch Fees for Low-Income Families

UP NEXT

Christian McCaffrey Expected to Make Season Debut for 49ers This Week

UP NEXT

Southern California Wildfire Destroys 132 Structures as Officials Look for Fierce Winds to Subside

UP NEXT

Stock Market Today: Wall Street Cruises Toward the Close of Its Best Week in a Year

San Francisco’s First Black Female Mayor Concedes to Levi Strauss Heir

1 hour ago

FBI Thwarts Iranian Murder-for-Hire Plan Targeting Donald Trump

1 hour ago

Israeli Soccer Fans Were Attacked in Amsterdam. The Violence Was Condemned as Antisemitic

1 hour ago

Longtime Dodgers Ace Clayton Kershaw Is on the Mend After 2 Surgeries

1 hour ago

USDA Bans School Lunch Fees for Low-Income Families

1 hour ago

Christian McCaffrey Expected to Make Season Debut for 49ers This Week

1 hour ago

Southern California Wildfire Destroys 132 Structures as Officials Look for Fierce Winds to Subside

2 hours ago

Stock Market Today: Wall Street Cruises Toward the Close of Its Best Week in a Year

2 hours ago

The Latest: House Remains in the Balance as World Reaction to Trump Victory Keeps Pouring In

2 hours ago

Middle East Latest: Israeli Defense Minister Officially Steps Down

2 hours ago

Beyoncé Makes Grammy History With ‘Cowboy Carter,’ Leading 2025 Nominations

NEW YORK — Welcome toBeyoncé country. When it comes to the 2025 Grammy Award nominations, “Cowboy Carter” rules the nation. She ...

4 mins ago

4 mins ago

Beyoncé Makes Grammy History With ‘Cowboy Carter,’ Leading 2025 Nominations

6 mins ago

Macklin Celebrini, NHL’s Youngest Player, Scores on Marc-Andre Fleury, League’s Oldest

Rams
26 mins ago

Ramsey, Beckham Return to SoFi Stadium When the Struggling Dolphins Visit the Streaking Rams

1 hour ago

San Francisco’s First Black Female Mayor Concedes to Levi Strauss Heir

1 hour ago

FBI Thwarts Iranian Murder-for-Hire Plan Targeting Donald Trump

1 hour ago

Israeli Soccer Fans Were Attacked in Amsterdam. The Violence Was Condemned as Antisemitic

1 hour ago

Longtime Dodgers Ace Clayton Kershaw Is on the Mend After 2 Surgeries

1 hour ago

USDA Bans School Lunch Fees for Low-Income Families

Search

Send this to a friend