Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Can California Improve Lives of Iowa's Hogs?
By admin
Published 1 year ago on
October 24, 2022

Share

When politicians or the media use the term “pork,” they refer to spending taxpayers’ money on projects that benefit a particular person or interest group.

In California, however, the word has another connotation — a case now before the U.S. Supreme Court dealing with a 2018 ballot measure that imposes strict living conditions for hogs whose bacon, hams, ribs, and other cuts are to be sold in the state.

Dan Walters

CalMatters

Opinion

It may seem strange that such a law would make it all the way to the Supreme Court, but the National Pork Producers Council is pressing the issue, contending that the measure violates a section of the U.S. Constitution barring states from interfering with interstate commerce. Moreover, its outcome could have much wider effects, as the court’s members speculated during oral arguments this month.

If California can impose its own conditions on how hogs are raised in other states, several justices mused, it could affect a wide variety of issues in which state policies differ — even abortion. And justices in both the court’s conservative majority and its liberal minority voiced concerns.

The ballot measure, Proposition 12, prohibits California sales of pork products when the seller knows or should know that the meat came from the offspring of sows that had been confined “in a cruel manner.” Among other things, the law requires sows to have at least 24 square feet of living space.

Does Prop 12 Violate US Constitution?

Timothy Bishop, an attorney for the pork producers and other agriculture groups, told the court that “California wants to change farming methods everywhere” and therefore violates the Constitution’s Article I, Section 8, Clause 3, which gives the federal government the exclusive right to regulate interstate commerce. The farm groups have support on the issue from President Joe Biden’s White House.

Liberal Justice Elena Kagan and others worried aloud that if the California law is upheld, what she called “policy disputes” would proliferate and states would be “constantly at each other’s throats,” passing laws in attempts to change the policies of rival states.

“A lot of policy disputes,” Kagan told California’s lawyer, Michael Mongan, “can be incorporated into laws like yours.” For example, she speculated, California could implement laws requiring products to be manufactured using union labor, while Texas could implement a law prohibiting the use of union labor.

“We live in a divided country,” Kagan said, in which the “balkanization” that concerned drafters of the Constitution “is surely present.”

Conservative Justice Amy Barrett asked Mongan whether California could “pass a law that said we’re not going to buy any pork from companies that don’t require all their employees to be vaccinated or from corporations that don’t fund gender-affirming surgeries.”

The court’s newest member, Ketanji Brown Jackson, sharply questioned Jeffrey Lamken, who represented the Humane Society of the United States, asking why California couldn’t address its concerns some other way, such as segregating Iowa’s pork or requiring it to be labeled as coming from conditions to which the state objects.

Governors’ Feud

The pork case hit the Supreme Court at an opportune time because of the noisy feud between California Gov. Gavin Newsom and governors of Florida and Texas that’s not only been exchanges of words, but some efforts to pass conflicting laws on abortion, transgender rights, and guns.

The tone of the justices’ questioning indicates that they are not inclined to let Proposition 12 stand, but it’s also possible that they will avert a definitive ruling. Kagan suggested that since the issue never had a lower court trial, the case could be bounced back down for such a trial.

About the Author

Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. For more columns by Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.

Make Your Voice Heard

GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration. 

RELATED TOPICS:

DON'T MISS

When Newsom Gives His State of the State, He Should Be Candid About California’s Economy

DON'T MISS

CA’s Liberal Government Has a Long History of Caving to Special Interests

DON'T MISS

Newsom, Legislators Opt for Gimmicks and Wishful Thinking to Close California’s Budget Deficit

DON'T MISS

Courage to Embrace Change: El Rio Reyes Conservation Trust Boldly Rebrands as Kings River Land Trust

DON'T MISS

Committed to Politics or Committed to Fresno’s Children?

DON'T MISS

Repealing Prop. 47 is a Misguided Battle Cry. It Won’t Make California Safer.

DON'T MISS

Misty Her Might Be Best Superintendent Candidate. But Fresno Unified Still Needs a Statewide Search.

DON'T MISS

How California’s Prized Solution for Methane Gas Is Backfiring on Farmers

DON'T MISS

Many Californians Rely on This Farmers Market Program. Newsom Wants to Cut It

DON'T MISS

Carbon Capture Storage Is Key to California’s Economy & Energy Future

No data was found

Facebook News Tab Will Soon Be Unavailable as Meta Scales Back News and Political Content

9 hours ago

Stock Market Today: Wall Street Rises to More Records to Close Out Its Latest Winning Month

9 hours ago

A Fresno County First: Kerman Council Passes Amended Gaza Cease-Fire Resolution

9 hours ago

UN Top Court Orders Israel to Open More Land Crossings for Aid into Gaza

10 hours ago

How Involved Is Southern California Consulting Firm in FUSD Executive Dealings?

10 hours ago

Biden’s Fundraiser with Obama and Clinton Nets a Record $25 Million, His Campaign Says

10 hours ago

Fresno Unified’s Self-Protection Racket Is Hurting Our Kids

11 hours ago

Rockin’ Out or Laughing, the Valley Has Its Pick of Weekend Events

11 hours ago

Ex-Correctional Officer at Women’s Prison in California Sentenced for Sexually Abusing Inmates

14 hours ago

Caitlin Clark and Iowa Draw Nearly 5 Million Viewers for Second-Round NCAA Win

14 hours ago

PGA HOPE at Riverside Golf Course Introduces Military Veterans to the Game

PGA HOPE, now underway at Fresno’s Riverside Golf Course, is designed to introduce golf to veterans and active duty military members t...

7 hours ago

PGA HOPE at Fresno's Riverside Golf Course
7 hours ago

PGA HOPE at Riverside Golf Course Introduces Military Veterans to the Game

9 hours ago

Cronenworth’s Big Hit Helps Lift the Padres to a 6-4 Win Over Melvin’s Giants

9 hours ago

Shohei Ohtani Reaches 3 Times in Home Debut as the Dodgers Rout the Cardinals 7-1

9 hours ago

Facebook News Tab Will Soon Be Unavailable as Meta Scales Back News and Political Content

9 hours ago

Stock Market Today: Wall Street Rises to More Records to Close Out Its Latest Winning Month

9 hours ago

A Fresno County First: Kerman Council Passes Amended Gaza Cease-Fire Resolution

10 hours ago

UN Top Court Orders Israel to Open More Land Crossings for Aid into Gaza

10 hours ago

How Involved Is Southern California Consulting Firm in FUSD Executive Dealings?

MENU

CONNECT WITH US

Search

Send this to a friend