About 75 people assembled on a northeast Fresno street corner on a cold Thursday evening to urge that the United States avoid a war with Iran at all costs.

At exactly the same time, in Toledo, Ohio, President Donald Trump addressed a crowd of 8,000 at a campaign rally. As president, Trump said, he needn’t inform Congress of planned military action — his decision to kill Iranian Gen. Qassem Soleimani, in particular.

Portrait of GV Wire News Director Bill McEwen

Bill McEwen

Opinion

Is There a Path to Better Relations With Iran?

There you have it, two opposing sides of the coin bearing the American motto, e Pluribus Unum — “out of many, one.”

However, President Trump faces the same challenge as every American, from the most fervent hawk to the most dedicated pacifist.

With the path to eased U.S.-Iran tensions buried under the rubble of mistrust and deadly mistakes made by both sides in the 67 years since the CIA removed Iran’s democratically elected leader, Mohammed Mossadegh, how do we find it?

While interviewing Peace Fresno members and others carrying signs such as “No War With Iran” and “Murder Not in my Name,” I saved the hardest question for last.

“Given that Iran is the world’s leading sponsor of terrorism and a huge funder of groups such as Hezbollah, Hamas, and Islamic Jihad, how exactly is the United States supposed to promote peace in the Middle East?”

Mostly, I got crickets.

Some retreated to yes, Iran is a bad actor, but the United States has blood on its hands, too. Especially in the pursuit of oil.

OK. But knowing this doesn’t make the world safer — unless it informs us about how best to move forward.

Photo of anti-war protesters

People attending a “No War With Iran” rally Thursday in Fresno flash peace signs to passers-by. (GV Wire/Jamie Ouverson)

Sanctions Sound Good, but They Rarely Work

The most clearly articulated answer came from Jeff Crow, who supports Trump and wore a Devin Nunes 2020 baseball cap to the rally. Crow said he showed up to remind the protesters that the U.S. is not at war with Iran.

“I have a number of friends in the Peace Fresno group and I think we all can concur that we don’t want a war with Iran. A war with Iran would be extremely destructive,” Crow said.

So, how do we avoid war if Iran continues its strategically executed belligerence and deadly actions?

Killing Soleimani was a good start because it demonstrated to Iran that there are consequences to its actions, Crow said. After that, “more economic sanctions.”

Indeed, the Trump administration ratcheted up economic sanctions against Iran on Friday. They could cost the regime of Iran’s supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, and his allies billions of dollars. The sanctions aim to eliminate access to the U.S. financial system by Iran’s ruling class.

The problem is, sanctions have been tried by many presidents before and they rarely work. Exhibit A: North Korea.

Besides, Team Trump might kick-start a better relationship with Iran by rejoining the multinational agreement negotiated by the Obama administration. You know, the one in which Iran agreed not to pursue the nuclear bomb in trade for relaxed sanctions. That said, I doubt that the president’s resentment of President Obama or his stick-without-a-carrot negotiating style would allow it.

Photo of Camille Russell

Longtime peace activist Camille Russell says she doesn’t trust President Trump. (GV Wire/Jamie Ouverson)

Peace Fresno Protests Republicans and Democrats Alike

Peace Fresno has about 125 members, according to Camille Russell, a retired teacher and longtime activist. Judging by the honks of support from cars driving past Thursday’s event, many Fresnans are hoping that Iran doesn’t explode into another Vietnam, Iraq, or Afghanistan war.

Something else to know: Peace Fresno members don’t discriminate. They show up for protests at the offices of Republican and Democratic politicians alike.

Just ask Rep. Jim Costa, who has incurred Peace Fresno’s wrath for voting against ending U.S. financial and military support for the war in Yemen. Russell once penned a piece blistering Obama for sending 30,000 additional troops to Afghanistan.

“It was regretful to watch President Obama shatter the hopes and dreams of the millions of Americans who elected him last year,” Russell wrote in an article accompanied by a photo illustration cooked up by Dixie Salazar. It depicted the president with a Nobel Peace Prize around his neck and a button on his shoulder declaring “War Is Peace.”

A Snowball’s Chance

Yes, give peace a chance.

Even though there’s a snowball’s chance in hell that Iran’s theocratic regime — not to be confused with the many millions of Iranians who want democracy and admire America — will soon change its bloody ways.

3 Responses

  1. Dan

    Short answer: stop interfering in the Middle East. Let the natives settle their own problems, including the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Get out of Iraq and Afghanistan.

    The US’s conflict with Iran started when our government refused to return the Shah to Iran to face justice for his despotic behavior (interestingly, we had no problem doing it with Saddam, but that’s another story). The Shah was an American tool in the region for 25 years, unlike Saddam-who got too big for his britches. Our refusal begat the hostage crisis which in turn begat arms for hostages (aka a bribe).

    Reply
  2. perry

    If you dont like the mullahs who run Iran you have no one else but us to blame as we overthrew their democratic government in 1953.
    chief promoter of terrorism is not Iran but Saudi Arabia who are the ideological supporters of Sunni groups such as ISIS DAESH and al nusra.

    Reply
  3. Gene Roza

    Me thinks McEwen leans to the right; 75 protestors for a Peace ralley and he picks a trump puppeteer with a nunes hat to quote……..this reminds of of the local coverage the day before Impeachment of 45 in front of nunes’ Clovis office of 300-400 calling for Impeachment of 45 and a dozen or so of trump puppets on one corner and the media gave equal coverage. Of course no one wants war with Iran ( and we didn’t want one with Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, Palistine or the entire middle east) but the idiot in th WH chose to kill via drone strikes the leader of another country which is an international crime. This attitude is not nor has it every been the road to peace. This current administration seems more interested in continuing the conflicts in the middle east & thereby create profits for the war machine hawks and they keep creating more enemies usage our dollars and killing & destroying other civilizations. We keep saying they are terrorists and yet we do the dirty deeds that terrorist nations are know for………….is this simply another crusade?
    I will say that McEwen’s new book “Stinger” is quite a good read.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

We've got issues, and we're willing to share
(but only if you want them in your inbox).